NFL: Week 12 knee-jerk reactions
NFC Knee-jerk Reactions | AFC Knee-jerk Reactions
WEEK 12
| Team | Knee-jerk reaction | Reality or not? |
|---|---|---|
| NFC EAST by Dan Graziano | ||
![]() | There's no hope as long as Jerry Jones owns the team. Losing to the Redskins on Thanksgiving? Why does this team keep finding new lows? | It's a roller-coaster season in Dallas, where the Cowboys aren't good enough or bad enough to sustain long streaks of either kind. Cowboys fans are likely to be feeling hopeful again this time next week. |
![]() | The real Giants are back! Did you see the way they manhandled the Packers? It's just like we've been saying all along -- when the Giants are on, they can beat any team in the league. | They can, yeah. But this whole idea that New York can flip a switch on or off when it wants is a scary one. Sometimes it works out, as it did in 2011. Sometimes it doesn't, as in 2009 and 2010. |
![]() | Well, at this point they really should just lose the rest of their games and try to get that No. 1 draft pick. Maybe we can find our franchise quarterback? | There's no Andrew Luck or Robert Griffin III in this year's draft, and this isn't an Eagles team that has quit. They could lose all the rest of their games for the simple reason that they stink. But they're not going to do it on purpose. |
![]() | This is amazing. All of the tiebreakers favor us. We beat the Saints, Vikings, Buccaneers and Cowboys, and we have the tiebreaker over Seattle, too. Only one game out with five to play -- we're going to the playoffs! | You have to be tied to use a tiebreaker, so although things look a lot better for the Redskins than they did a couple of weeks ago, they still need to keep winning and have the teams in front of them keep losing if they're going to sneak in. |
| NFC WEST by Mike Sando | ||
![]() | Seven straight losses after a 4-0 start and no viable quarterback plan? That's it. Gotta fire the head coach. Ken Whisenhunt is out of excuses. | The schedule makes 4-12 seem more likely than 6-10. One key question is whether mounting injuries will give the organization reason to grant a mulligan. |
![]() | Coach Jim Harbaugh has screwed up the quarterback situation in a big way. How can Alex Smith or any veteran take him at his word after Harbaugh turned on Smith so quickly? | Colin Kaepernick has been much better than anticipated. He's the one responsible for creating the problem. And since when is it a problem to have two legitimately good QBs? |
![]() | Good teams don't go 1-5 on the road. The Seahawks are a fraud. They'll never make a dent in the playoffs as a wild-card team at this rate. | What did you expect, a 12-4 season? Seattle is building around one of the most impressive rookie QBs in the NFL. Simply reaching the playoffs should be enough. |
![]() | The Rams have allowed one touchdown pass while picking off seven passes and collecting 18 sacks against the NFC West. That's great, but something's wrong when a team can go 3-0-1 in its own division and 1-6 outside of it. | Take the victories any way you can get them, Rams fans. Those divisional stats are about as good as they're likely to look, anyway. The Rams get the 49ers on Sunday. They still have to visit Seattle, where Russell Wilson has 11 TDs and 0 INTs. |
| NFC NORTH by Kevin Seifert | ||
![]() | The Bears are going to have trouble protecting Jay Cutler with a patchwork offensive line caused by injuries. | That's not necessarily the case. As we learned Sunday, protecting Cutler is just as much about play calling as pass protection. |
![]() | The Lions haven't grown at all since last season. | That's the unfortunate reality of a team going 4-7 a year after finishing 10-6 and going to the playoffs. The Lions thought their nucleus would continue to develop and brought it back almost intact, but that rarely works in the NFL. You must always keep moving forward. |
![]() | A 28-point loss to the New York Giants should be a warning sign. | I'm not sure about that. It's true the Packers haven't lost a game that badly in nearly four years. But in the end, it might have been the most daunting game remaining on their schedule. |
![]() | The Vikings aren't good enough to play with the big boys. | That sure appeared to be the case in their 28-10 loss to the Bears, and it won't get any easier over the next few weeks. They'll play at the Packers, host the Bears again, then travel to the Houston Texans two weeks after that. |
| NFC SOUTH by Pat Yaskinskas | ||
![]() | The Falcons have solved their run-defense problems after holding back Tampa Bay's Doug Martin. | That was definitely a step in the right direction, and the return of linebacker Sean Weatherspoon from injury made the entire defense better. But this wasn't a team that was bottling up the run even before Weatherspoon's injury. |
![]() | Everything is fine with Cam Newton now. | At least for one night, Newton was pretty close to perfect. He ran for two touchdowns, passed for two touchdowns, and was poised and efficient. But not every opponent is as bad as the Eagles. |
![]() | It was a nice run, but the season is over for the Saints after Sunday's loss to the 49ers. | Not quite. The Saints have six losses and no room for more. The Saints pretty much have to run the table to have any shot at the playoffs, but you can bet they'll try to play the spoiler Thursday night in Atlanta. |
![]() | Sunday's loss to Atlanta really hurt the Buccaneers' playoff chances. | In the long run, that might be true. But at the moment, the 6-5 Bucs have the same record as Seattle and Minnesota, and the Seahawks would get the No. 6 based on tiebreakers. But there still is a lot of football to be played. |
NFC Knee-jerk Reactions | AFC Knee-jerk Reactions
WEEK 12
| Team | Knee-jerk reaction | Reality or not? |
|---|---|---|
| AFC EAST by James Walker | ||
![]() | I can't remember the last time Chan Gailey made a good coaching decision. My mind is made up: Get Gailey outta here! | Lately, Gailey has certainly been more of the problem than the solution in Buffalo. If things don't turn around quickly, Gailey probably won't be back next year. |
![]() | Forget what I said about Chad Henne last week, Walker. I'm glad we drafted Ryan Tannehill. He's pretty cool. | Dolphins fans have to come to their senses about Tannehill. He's a rookie who will go through growing pains. The key is learning from those mistakes. |
![]() | I just bought my airplane ticket to New Orleans for Super Bowl weekend. I fully expect the Patriots to be there. | I hope this isn't a nonrefundable ticket. The Patriots look Super in November. But it's all about who stays healthy and gets hot in January. It's too early to crown anyone. |
![]() | Fire Rex Ryan! Fire Mike Tannenbaum! Fire Fireman Ed! FIRE EVERYBODY! | Sure, the Jets were an on-field circus in their 30-point loss to the Patriots on Thanksgiving. But there are still five games left for Rex Ryan & Co. to prove they deserve one more year. Let's see what happens. |
| AFC WEST by Bill Williamson | ||
![]() | The Broncos' flat performance against the Chiefs is a sign that this team is ready to take a dip. | Nope, it's the NFL. Every week is different, and it is difficult for any team to play at a dominant level on a weekly basis. This isn't college football. You aren't dinged for unimpressive wins. |
![]() | There is no such thing as the Arrowhead Stadium home-field advantage anymore. The Chiefs are 0-6 at home for the first time since 1976. | Yes, but don't blame it on Arrowhead Stadium. It's not the stadium's fault, and it's not the fan base's fault. It's this team's fault. Give the stadium and the fans a good product, and Arrowhead will again be a house of horrors for visiting teams. |
![]() | It's time to think about using Terrelle Pryor in Oakland. The season is lost. Let's see what the kid can do. | It's difficult to argue. But the Raiders' 3-8 record is not Carson Palmer's fault. He's not the problem. |
![]() | The Chargers' defensive collapse on the Ravens' fourth-and-29 conversion Sunday was the biggest gaffe in the NFL this season. | It's hard to argue against that. All anyone wants to talk about is how the Chargers allowed a first down in that circumstance. That play will never be forgotten. |
| AFC NORTH by Jamison Hensley | ||
![]() | The Ravens came back from a 10-point deficit in the fourth quarter. Ray Rice converted on fourth-and-29. This is shaping up to be a special season. | The win in San Diego could be the Ravens' signature victory. Everything is falling into place for the Ravens, from the AFC North title to the second seed in the AFC. The challenge is to keep up that momentum heading into the postseason. |
![]() | The Bengals are playing like the best team in the division right now. They're not just beating teams. They're beating them up. Who Dey! | What's really impressive about the Bengals' three-game win streak is the margin of victory. They're beating teams by an average of 21 points. Cincinnati has the chance to deliver another rout at reeling San Diego. |
![]() | The Browns are starting to turn things around. The win over the Steelers was huge for the confidence of this young team. This is a great sign for the 2013 season. | Cleveland is 3-3 after starting a disastrous 0-5. It won't be enough to save Pat Shurmur's job, but the Browns definitely are building momentum that can carry over into next season. |
![]() | The Steelers are falling apart. They turned the ball over eight times to the Browns. How can you expect Pittsburgh to hold on to the final playoff spot in the AFC when it can't hold on to the ball? | The loss at Cleveland doesn't leave the Steelers much room for error in December. They probably have to win four of their next five games to secure a playoff spot. But this team will get a boost when Ben Roethlisberger and Troy Polamalu return. |
| AFC SOUTH by Paul Kuharsky | ||
![]() | This team is pretty bad for a 10-1 team. The defense has been getting away with murder. We're not worried about Tennessee, but that trip to New England for "Monday Night Football" is going to be ugly. | Houston's ability to find ways to win even with one side of the ball struggling has been remarkable. The defense has hit a lull, but it's going to bounce back. |
![]() | Never mind these people talking about how we've not beaten anyone and can't do damage in the playoffs. Our team has tremendous purpose and will continue to surprise. | There is nothing wrong with beating lesser teams when they are on your schedule. If the Colts keep going like that, it'll be a season to be proud of. |
![]() | In Chad Henne we trust. If they had turned to this guy earlier, maybe we would be in better shape. It sure was fun to watch the Jags win. | It's completely understandable why the team hung with Blaine Gabbert for as long as it did. And Henne's first relief appearance in Oakland gave us no hint he would be such an upgrade. |
![]() | Hooray, they fired Chris Palmer. Couldn't they have done away with Jerry Gray, too? Losing at Jacksonville makes me question how much longer I can root for this team. | It's a reasonable move, and Dowell Loggains has a chance to be a good coordinator. But expecting further change in season is silly. |
SPONSORED HEADLINES
AFC EAST SCOREBOARD
ABOUT THIS BLOG
James Walker
Walker joined ESPN.com in 2008 after four seasons covering the NFL and NBA for the Columbus (Ohio) Dispatch. He's a Temple graduate and Hyattsville, Md. native who lives in Miami.
AFC EAST TEAM COVERAGE
NFL BLOG NETWORK
Romo to miss OTAs after back surgery (about 1 hour ago)
NFL32: Brady better than ever? (5/20, 9:50 PM ET)
Romo to miss OTAs after back surgery (about 1 hour ago)
Breakfast links: It's a world gone RG III (about 2 hours ago)
NFC North chat alert (4 minutes ago)
BBAO: 'Broken' vs. 'injured' fingers (about 2 hours ago)
NFC South links: Freeman feeling pressure? (5/20, 10:45 AM ET)
NFC South programming notes (5/20, 8:11 AM ET)
Around the NFC West: Not a banner day (about 2 hours ago)
Including Patrick Peterson in top CB talk (5/20, 6:00 PM ET)
Morning take: Reshad Jones update (about 3 hours ago)
Mario Williams says he's 'completely fine' (5/20, 5:00 PM ET)
AFC North links: Record motivates Steelers (45 minutes ago)
AFC North links: Marvin Lewis tees it up (5/20, 8:44 AM ET)
AFC South links: Tebow the 'great debate' (5/20, 10:30 AM ET)
Eight in the Box: Returning from injury (5/17, 12:00 PM ET)
AFC West links: Protecting Manti Te’o (5/20, 10:41 AM ET)
Gone fishing (5/19, 5:00 PM ET)
RECENT UPDATES
- Morning take: Reshad Jones update(5/21/2013 7:00 AM ET)
- Mario Williams says he's 'completely fine'(5/20/2013 5:00 PM ET)
- Bills announce Robert Woods signing(5/20/2013 4:28 PM ET)
- Poll: Mike Goodson's future with Jets(5/20/2013 3:13 PM ET)
- Tom Brady: 'I've never felt better throwing'(5/20/2013 1:30 PM ET)


































You must be signed in to post a comment