Safety first for Mays, Berry
The working title for this college football season is fairly straightforward: "Quarterbacks Rule."
That's understandable for the following reasons:
1. Tim Tebow
2. Sam Bradford
3. Colt McCoy
4. Quarterbacks almost always rule, and never more than this decade. They've won eight of the last nine Heisman Trophies as spread offenses proliferate and passing games become more efficient. They are steadily producing a greater portion of the average team's offensive output.
But let me play Clarence Darrow here and speak for the defense. Specifically, the last line of defense. It's safety first on that side of the ball in 2009.
It's nearly as big a year for safeties as it is for those glamour boys who throw the football, get the girls and win the hardware. In Taylor Mays of USC and Eric Berry of Tennessee, the college game is blessed with a pair of superstar defensive backstops.
"I hope we get safeties some love," Mays said.
Love is in full bloom for the finest pair of safeties in college ball in years -- decades, perhaps. Maybe since 1986, when Miami's Bennie Blades and Purdue's Rod Woodson were All-Americans. (Back then, Woodson played both cornerback and safety.) Or maybe since 1980, when Kenny Easley (UCLA), Ronnie Lott (USC) and Dennis Smith (USC) all were de-cleating opponents in the same city. (What a truly awful time that must have been to be a wide receiver in the Pac-10 conference.)
You want safety love? You got it.
It was Berry, not Tebow, who was the leading vote getter for the all-Southeastern Conference team among the league's media members last month. In fact, Tennessee has launched a Heisman campaign for Berry -- which is ironic because many at the school remain utterly chapped that quarterback Peyton Manning lost the 1997 Heisman to the only defensive back ever to win it, Michigan's Charles Woodson.
FUTURE FIRST ROUNDERS
I haven't spent a great deal of time studying Eric Berry (on coaches-copy tape) but I've seen enough on TV to be excited about his pro potential. Both Berry and Taylor Mays obviously bring different attributes to the table. Mays is a freakish athlete at approximately 6-foot-3 and 225 pounds. He is a hard-hitting safety with excellent speed for his size. However, he's not fluid enough to match up versus many wide receivers in the slot, and his recognition skills are not where they should be at this point in his career.
Depending on how the season and workouts play out, I think Mays could go somewhere in the middle of the first round. He really needs to show better instincts as a senior in order to crack the top 10, as many seem to believe he will do. Berry is more of an Ed Reed-type with outstanding range and ball-hawking skills. Berry is as fluid as it gets for a safety, and he can match up man-to-man with most receivers. Berry's ball skills are also excellent.
If everything goes as planned between now and the draft (and assuming Berry leaves early, of course), I think Berry will go slightly higher than Mays. However, both should be off the board in the top-20 picks.
-- Todd McShay, Scouts Inc.
"Just hearing that they wanted to push a campaign for me, that made me feel very good," Berry said. "I really love the UT staff for doing that for me. It's pretty cool. I like this deal."
And it's Mays, not any of USC's flotilla of five-star tailbacks and quarterbacks, who is on the cover of the school's media guide and is unquestionably the biggest name at the nation's glam program.
"I don't think anyone on defense or maybe on our whole team has seen more snaps than Taylor," Trojans defensive coordinator Rocky Seto said. "He's going to be one of the foundations of our team."
They're entertaining to watch and fascinating to compare. The similarities and differences are striking.
They're both from big cities, but opposite sides of the country -- Mays from Seattle, Berry from suburban Atlanta.
They were both considered among the very best defensive backs in the nation coming out of high school -- Mays in 2006, Berry in 2007.
They both broke a few hearts in their home states by matriculating elsewhere.
They both are the sons of former college players -- Stafford Mays at Washington, James Berry at Tennessee.
They both would have laughed at the first suggestion of a redshirt year. No way these guys were going to sit for a minute.
They're both consensus All-Americans -- Berry one time, Mays twice.
They both have been compared to former Miami safeties -- Mays' physical style to the late Sean Taylor, Berry's ball-hawking style to the Baltimore Ravens' Ed Reed. Berry himself made that comparison to me last month.
They'll both be first-round NFL draft choices, or Mel Kiper will shave his head.
They're both allergic to self-satisfaction.
"What makes him fun is how much he wants to be good, how much he wants to maximize himself," Seto said of Mays. "He is ridiculously driven."
Said Berry: "I put a lot of pressure on myself. I go in every offseason like an incoming freshman, trying to earn a spot."
They both have a surplus of personality and are comfortable in the spotlight.
"A lot of people, I think they're scared to come up to me," Berry said. "Maybe they think I'm a mean guy or they're afraid of bothering me. I had a bad experience one time with a pro athlete. I want to be the opposite of that. I was so hurt."
They're both big fans of sushi.
"Me and him are going to see who can eat more," Mays said jokingly.
Over shrimp tempura they can discuss their differences.
Mays is a hitter, the most recent evidence being the Rose Bowl play in which he took out a Penn State receiver and a teammate with a helmet-to-helmet kill shot that drew a penalty. But he's also stunningly fast and athletic for his 6-foot-3, 235-pound size, running a 4.25 40-yard dash and possessing a 41-inch vertical leap.
"I'd like to think he's a big, I guess you could say, freak or monster," Berry said of Mays, "to still be that fast, still that athletic."
Berry is a playmaker -- we all know that based on his 12 career interceptions and the fact that he's a lock to break the NCAA career record for interception return yardage this season. But he's also startlingly physical for his 5-foot-11, 203-pound frame, regularly rocking bigger running backs with his hits.
First-year Tennessee coach Lane Kiffin has his dad, NFL veteran Monte Kiffin, calling his defenses. And Lane said Monte's assessment of Berry is this: "I don't know how he couldn't be the first pick in the draft."
For that to happen in 2010, the junior would have to leave school a year early. That is something Mays elected not to do after last season.
For Berry, the decision could be made for him by his family's financial situation. He said his mom was laid off last year from her job at a construction company, while his dad was laid off in February from Owens Corning.
There were no significant financial considerations for Mays when he made his pro decision. After an eight-year NFL career, Stafford Mays became a senior manager at Microsoft. Mays' mom, Laurie Black, is an executive at Nordstrom.
"They just wanted me to make the decision for myself," Mays said. "They were open to whatever. I didn't want to make it about the money. I had the opportunity to be a complete football player, to work on some things I haven't done."
"I'd like to think he's a big, I guess you could say, freak or monster, to still be that fast, still that athletic."” -- Eric Berry on Taylor Mays
To do that, Mays knows he needs to work on his ball skills. He didn't intercept a single pass last season and has just four in his three-year career. Part of that is a result of playing deeper in Pete Carroll's Tampa 2 defensive scheme to take away vertical threats -- the same defensive scheme Kiffin has installed at Tennessee -- but not all of it.
"I need to catch the ball," Mays said. "I don't get too many opportunities, but I need to add that to my game."
What does Berry want to add to his game? How about a cameo at quarterback, driving defenses crazy from the spread formation?
"I would love to do that," he said, comparing his high school quarterbacking style to Pat White's. "Who wouldn't want to do that?"
Mays wouldn't want to do that. He's in a committed relationship with defense.
"I love the attitude on defense," he said. "The demeanor, the swagger, the camaraderie of the players. Offense is a little more individual, because one player can make a play. Defense is really team-oriented. I love celebrating when they can't run on you, can't pass on you, can't do nothing."
Taylor Mays and Eric Berry can do almost anything on a football field. So much, in fact, that they might be able to swipe some of the spotlight from those glory-hog quarterbacks. Safety first, anyone?
Pat Forde is a senior writer for ESPN.com. He can be reached at ESPN4D@aol.com.
ESPN TOP HEADLINES
- Sources: Howard felt marginalized by D'Antoni
- Golf bans anchor putting, cites 'free swing'
- Sources: Romo out 3 weeks after surgery
- Sports world keeps eye on Oklahoma tornado
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
2009 College Football Preview
Will Florida repeat as BCS champion? Which teams will surprise? Who'll walk away with the major awards? ESPN.com's 2009 college football preview has the answers.