Is Duke accuser's pregnancy relevant?
Just when you think the Duke rape case can't get any more unseemly, along comes a report the alleged victim is pregnant and already might have given birth.
Skeptics will point out that the birth occurred approximately nine months after her alleged rape by members of the Duke lacrosse team.
What does this mean legally?
Possibility No. 1: DNA evidence determines that the father of the child is one of the alleged attackers.
This would prove that the father/player had sex with the alleged victim. It wouldn't prove the sex was non-consensual, or even that it happened the night that the alleged victim claims she was raped.
However, because the defense claims that none of the players had sex with the alleged victim, consensual or otherwise, the knowledge that one of the players is the father of the baby would damage seriously at least his claims of innocence, and I think, would make his claim of innocence difficult to sell to a jury.
Possibility No. 2: None of the lacrosse players is shown to be the father of her child.
This would bolster the players' claim that they did not have sex with the alleged victim. It also would show she had sex with someone else around the time the alleged rape supposedly occurred. It would not prove the rape did not occur. It would show only that none of the defendants is the father of the child.
Possibility No. 3: The fact she gave birth would not even be admissible in a court of law.
Rape shield laws protect a woman's right of privacy and prevent defense lawyers from making an issue of her sexual history.
The days of the "tainted woman" arguments are over.
However, while her pregnancy might not be admissible in court, it will be admissible in the court of public opinion -- a court that has been masterfully manipulated by the defense.
The defense in this case seems to be based upon two foundations. First, that the assault never occurred. As a basis for this we have seen the defendants deny their involvement ("60 Minutes") and have heard leaks from defense lawyers who claim their clients' DNA was not found on the alleged victim.
A lack of DNA evidence would make it difficult for the prosecution to get a conviction. The second part of the defense strategy is this: The alleged victim is a "dancer" who was plying her trade at a "party" that the players attended, and as a "dancer" she has no credibility whatsoever.
This is why I think her pregnancy would not be admitted in court.
It could cause much speculation, but would prove nothing other than she had sex with another man.
Roger Cossack is ESPN's legal analyst.
ESPN TOP HEADLINES
- No. 1 Miss. St. staves off Kentucky's upset bid
- MSU answers pregame slight with late TD
- Bucs sign DT McCoy to $98 million extension
- Boykin throws 7 TDs, TCU scores 82 in rout
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
Lacrosse Scandal at Duke
• Disgraced prosecutor Nifong dropped from lawsuit
• Former prosecutor Nifong files for bankruptcy
• Three Duke lax players sue school, prosecutor
• Dept. of Justice won't investigate Nifong
• Ex-Duke lacrosse coach suing school
• Wrongly accused players sue city, ex-DA
• Duke president apologizes to accused lax players
• Ex-Duke DA Nifong serves sentence, leaves jail
• Exonerated Duke players seek $30M settlement
• Nifong reports for one-day jail sentence
• Nifong held in criminal contempt
• Nifong pleads not guilty to contempt charges
• Four lax players returning to Duke for 5th season
• Nifong apologizes for wrongdoing in Duke case
• State Bar formally orders disbarment for Nifong
• Lax player in Duke case transfers to Loyola, Md.
• Nifong a no-show at removal hearing
• Player's attorneys call for contempt on Nifong
• Nifong's predecessor named as interim replacement
• Governor set to replace Nifong as Durham D.A.
• Duke, former lacrosse players reach settlement
• Judge: Nifong must leave office immediately
• Disciplinary panel disbars Nifong
• Prosecutor Nifong says he'll resign
• Lax player's lawyer testifies about evidence
• Testimony: No conspiracy to hide evidence
• Duke prosecutor faces disbarment in trial
• NCAA grants Duke lax players extra season
• Cleared Duke player Seligmann to attend Brown
• Hopkins ends Duke's run, wins ninth lacrosse title
• Cleared Duke player Seligmann to attend Brown
• Police made mistakes in lineup
• Ex-Duke coach; University caved in to pressure
• AG's office releases report
• Cossack: Case crumbled early
• Nifong apologizes to players
• Ex-coach never lost faith
• What they're saying
• All charges dismissed
• Defense attorney in Duke lacrosse case dies
• Former prosecutor fighting charges
• Top N.C. prosecutor tours Duke lacrosse house
• Ex-DA defends self against charges
• Duke urges diversity following rape allegations
• Duke wins season opener
• Team greeted by near-record support
• Players ready to return to field
• Brown recruiting Duke player charged with assault
• Opponent wants D.A. removed from office
• Grand jurors speak out
• Hearing postponed until May
• Duke begins practice for 2007 season
• Nifong faces more ethics charges from state bar
• Nifong gets extension to answer complaint
• NAACP asks for thorough exam of case
• Prosecutor's future uncertain
• Attorney general takes over
• Prosecutor asks off case
• Defense: Accuser said one player just watched
• Judge orders paternity test
• Duke prez defends decision
• Ex-player sues over failing grade
• Lawyer: Players invited back to class
• N.C. State Bar files complaint against prosecutor
• D.A. drops rape charges
• Legal experts: Why the remaining charges?
• Judge OKs paternity tests
• Report: Accuser is pregnant
• Defense attorneys: No Duke players' DNA found on woman
• Justice Department asked to investigate Duke case