- Alyssa Roenigk, ESPN The Magazine senior writer
- 0 Shares
This column appears in the October 19 Body Issue of ESPN The Magazine.
Weeks before this magazine hit mailboxes, the media wrote about the photographs contained in its pages. Since reporters hadn't seen so much as a stray Polaroid, the stories ranged from the speculative (Will she? Won't she? We think she did!) to the judgmental (How could she?). The common thread: They were writing about the women.
When Ron Sirak, executive editor at Golf World, heard that three members of the LPGA Tour had posed for the Body Issue, sans appropriate golf attire, he wrote a piece asking whether this was the kind of attention the Tour wanted.
Sirak worried that, by posing nude, Sandra Gal, Anna Grzebien and Christina Kim would put the spotlight on their sexuality instead of their sport. This is women's golf, remember, the conservative stepsister to the PGA, the same folks who once
refused to sell Natalie Gulbis' swimsuit calendar in their merchandise tents, demand be damned. How would the suits react to three of their athletes laying it bare? "We support them," said LPGA chief communications officer David Higdon, indicating that the Tour was inching toward accepting a long-held truth in marketing: Beauty sells.
Sirak predicted that Gal, Grzebien and Kim will face some heat for their photo. He was right. Like Gulbis and model-turned-LPGA-member Anna Rawson, the trio will be the talk of message boards and chat rooms. The media will ask them if they believe they can be both role models and sex symbols. Because none of these women have won a major tournament, they will be chastised for promoting their looks without earning the right to do so. These questions will follow them, the way they will follow the other women in this issue who've chosen to bare all in an effort to promote a healthy, athletic body ideal. Not that they were deterred. "Other magazines show anorexic women and celebrities like Paris Hilton," Gal says. "This is about showing off our athleticism and how fit we have to be to play at this level."
No matter the reason, a female athlete's willingness to flaunt her beauty is a marketer's dream. After all, sports -- including women's sports -- are an industry run by and geared toward men. "The vast majority of the audience for sports is male," says Neal Pilson, the former president of CBS Sports who now works as a television consultant to the LPGA (whose audience is estimated to be 57% male), WTA (60%) and WNBA (66%). Execs figured out long ago that the sell for women's sports (great athletes who are great-looking) is different from that for their male counterparts (great athletes in great games). While pundits talk about what is fair and right, arguing that women deserve more
airtime and advertisers are too shallow, their words fall on deaf ears. In the real world, ratings and ticket sales -- demand for the product -- drive all.
The marketing of sports is no different from the marketing of movies, music, underarm deodorant or Under Armour. But the women's leagues that struggle, such as the LPGA, which is down to 27 events this year from 34 in 2008, and the predominantly
female-run WNBA, cling to the idea that, because women have fought long and hard to even the playing field, they've moved past the need to use sex appeal to sell their game. "Since the inception of our league, we've presented talent first," says WNBA president Donna Orender. "Our players have incredible appeal based on their athleticism, passion and personalities." And yet the league's regular-season ratings have remained largely flat in recent years, hovering around a .2, in part because the WNBA is repeating the mistake that women's pro soccer made earlier this decade: The folks in charge look around the bleachers and market a wholesome image to the few thousand fans they see (women, children, families) instead of a more provocative and potentially compelling message to the many thousands they don't (men). "The women and kids in the stands are not watching on TV," Pilson says. "There's the potential to reach many more men watching from home."
And what's the quickest way to get a man's attention? Some leagues, namely the AVP and WTA, have embraced the idea of selling skin. "Part of what makes pro beach volleyball special is the beautiful nature of the sport," says Jason Hodell, CEO of the AVP. "We have the beach, the sun and amazing athletes who are fit and tan. Our current ad campaign takes advantage of that." The ads, most of which feature close-ups of male and female players' butts, abs and shoulders, are meant to draw fans to the beach and to their TVs. Once their attention is grabbed, the theory goes, the action will keep them there. The most widely
talked about ad features a close-up of a female backside covered by a bikini bottom the size of a Post-it note. (We'd expect nothing less from the first sport to establish maximum uniform sizes.) The owner of that rear-end? A model. The AVP doesn't hide this. Nor does it run from the fact that the woman responsible for the campaign, Kristine Lefebvre, VP of business development and legal affairs for the AVP, posed naked for the June 2007 issue of Playboy.
Marketing, after all, has its own rules. And the athletes and leagues that understand how to combine achievement with savvy PR reap the rewards. In recent years, some of the biggest success stories have come from women's tennis, where Serena Williams and Maria Sharapova are as prosperous off the court as they are gifted on it. They both know that with rapt audiences eyeballing them in outfits that leave little to the imagination, players don't need to try hard to sell their beauty. So they use the stage to craft their own images. Serena, as she does in this issue, promotes her body as an instrument of empowerment, sending an appealing message to big brands like Nike, Gatorade and, most recently, Tampax. Sharapova sells polish and
refinement, making her a magnet for high-end sponsors like Cole Haan, TAG Heuer and Tiffany & Co. (As such, she repeatedly turns down offers from Playboy. "We don't want to associate her brand with sex," says her agent, Max Eisenbud.) It's hard to argue with either approach: Each woman earns more per year in endorsements -- an estimated $22 million for Sharapova and $14 million for Williams -- than Peyton Manning, Tom Brady or Kobe Bryant.
But raking it in can come at a price. In 1999, Anna Kournikova, then 18, won her first Grand Slam doubles title at the Australian Open, and went on to finish the year as the No. 1-ranked doubles player in the world. In 2000, she climbed as high as No. 8 in singles and, never one to be shy about her body, parlayed her success on the court into revealing magazine covers and lucrative endorsement contracts. By the time she retired from the WTA in 2003, she had slipped to No. 305 in the world but was bringing in an estimated $10 million annually off the court. Since then, she has served as a spokeswoman for K-Swiss, Omega and Adidas while working tirelessly to raise money for children's charities like the Boys & Girls Club and St. Jude. But you probably didn't know about her philanthropy because, despite being a former Top 10 player, Kournikova can't shake her reputation as the girl who cashed in on her looks. She was never the best singles player in the world, but she was certainly the single most famous. And that rubbed people -- primarily other female athletes -- the wrong way.
"Women take more criticism than guys, but it doesn't come from men," says Will Demps, a former NFL safety who's also a model. "I got heat from teammates for modeling, but it was always joking around. When women do it, it's 'She's too sexy.
She went too far.' " That's because when a male athlete shows his body, it's seen as masculine; male fans barely notice, even when faced with Tom Brady's suggestive Stetson ads or David Beckham in his underwear. But when a woman shows off her body, it's seen as sexual. And women who want to believe female athletes can pay the bills with wins alone have no choice but to sound off.
"It's a very contradictory time," says Linda Blum, a sociology professor at Northeastern University. "On one hand, women having opportunities to market their bodies represents their achieving a new role as respected athletes who are in control. But those opportunities can also be seen by some to reinforce old-fashioned, negative ideas of women as sex objects."
In the end, it can simply come down to a competitor's mindset. "Most athletes think, 'If I do this and this, I will win -- and if I win this much, I should have earned this much money and fame,' " says Tom George, a senior vice president at Octagon, the athlete management and marketing firm. "But marketing is not a linear projection." If it were, Martina Navratilova, who won 59 Grand Slam titles, wouldn't have had to settle for racket and sock sponsorships while Kournikova still makes millions in endorsements. Annika Sorenstam would've been a big name long before becoming the winningest female golfer in history. And beach volleyball's Holly McPeak, who retired in May with 72
tournament titles, an Olympic medal and five league MVP awards, would be the biggest name in her sport. Instead, there's a good chance you read that last sentence and thought, "Holly McWho?"
"I was the best in the world, but never the most famous in my sport," McPeak says. "It kicked sand in my face. The beautiful model got the attention. To this day, people think Gabby Reece is the best who ever played. She was bigger than volleyball, and I don't blame her for it. But if you are the best in your sport,
and the hot girl with average talent gets all the attention, that is frustrating."
It's part of the game, though, and the game has gotten tougher. A struggling economy means fewer ad dollars, and fewer ad dollars means companies are more discerning about who they select to pitch their products. That puts a premium on pretty in a sports world that sees genetic beauty as an unfair advantage, the equivalent of donning an LZR Racer or taking steroids. We laud the good fortune of Michael Phelps' flipper feet and Lance Armstrong's VO2 max, but bemoan Kournikova's good looks. "There's resentment toward those who gain
without sacrifice," says Reece's husband, Laird Hamilton, the surfer and American Express pitchman (featured on page 106). "If you're great at a sport, people think you earned it. But when you're genetically gifted to be smarter or better-looking, people feel you haven't paid your dues." And that goes against the nature of sports.
Or does it? Sports, like life, aren't fair. Anyone who's been benched for the coach's son knows that. But it's a lesson that applies here, because the marketing of sports isn't fair either. And the athletes who accept that fact and figure out how to use it to their advantage are the names and faces people remember. "To be marketable is to be memorable," says Olympic swimmer Amanda Beard, who has no qualms about showing off the killer body that helped her win seven Olympic medals. "Some people will remember me for my swimming, and some will remember me for my Playboy shoots. But either way, they will remember me."
Alyssa Roenigk is a senior writer at ESPN The Magazine.
James Harden and Dwight Howard delivered to lead the Rockets to a win in Game 1 that may prove the offseason roster turnover will yield more good results.
After scoring 23 points in his first playoff game in almost three years, Derrick Rose said he was grateful to be playing again and for his teammates pushing him, because "it feels good."
The Edmonton Oilers won the NHL draft lottery and the right to select Erie Otters star center Connor McDavid with the top pick.
Yordano Ventura was ejected from Kansas City's 5-0 loss to Oakland after hitting A's third baseman Brett Lawrie with what appeared to be a retaliatory pitch.
Ohio State is still the biggest draw in spring football, and the continued buzz following a national title gave it a chance to build on its own record for attendance in spring games.
In a bloody battle that lived up to the hype, Lucas Matthysse defeated Ruslan Provodnikov by the tightest of majority decisions Saturday night in Verona, New York.
While LeBron James finds himself on a new team on the eve of the Cavaliers' playoff opener against the Boston Celtics on Sunday, his past playoff experiences are on his mind.
For the second straight year, Toronto Raptors general manager Masai Ujiri swore during a fan rally prior to the team's postseason opener.
Sidney Crosby made a statement in Game 2 with a stellar two-goal effort that allowed the Penguins to even the series with the Rangers.
Mel Kiper Jr. plays GM for all 32 NFL teams, making his optimal picks for the first three rounds of the 2015 NFL draft -- 99 picks in total.
Kris Bryant got a standing ovation for his first major league hit and reached base five times Saturday in the Chicago Cubs' 7-6, 11-inning win over the San Diego Padres.
Derrick Rose scored 23 points in his first playoff game since 2012, as the Bulls raced past the Bucks 103-91 in Game 1.
Injured defenseman Shea Weber won't travel with the Nashville Predators for Games 3 and 4 in Chicago in their Western Conference quarterfinal series against the Blackhawks.
Paul Pierce scored five of his 20 points in overtime as the Washington Wizards beat the Toronto Raptors 93-86 on Saturday in Game 1 of their first-round playoff series.
Los Angeles Kings center Jarret Stoll was arrested Friday for suspected cocaine possession at the MGM Grand Hotel and Casino's Wet Republic pool complex.
Paul Pierce scored 20 points to lead the Wizards to an overtime win against the Raptors in Game 1.
Top-ranked Novak Djokovic overcame a strong challenge from Rafael Nadal to reach the Monte Carlo Masters final with a 6-3, 6-3 win Saturday.
A frustrated Giancarlo Stanton called out the Miami Marlins following their latest loss, saying "the fire is not there."
At this week's NBA Board of Governors meetings in New York, teams were advised that the league's salary cap could rise past the $100 million mark as soon as the 2017-18 season, sources said.
Los Angeles Angels manager Mike Scioscia met with Josh Hamilton this week for the first time in months, and he said he isn't sure when the star will return to the team.
Ubaldo Jimenez was tossed Friday for hitting Pablo Sandoval in the right shoulder with a pitch, an ejection that Baltimore manager Buck Showalter later called "professionally embarrassing."