Commentary

Not appearing in Rumor Central

We present the majors leaguers with the least trade value

Originally Published: July 27, 2009
By David Schoenfield | Page 2

As we all wait and maybe hope for a Roy Halladay trade, let's take a pause and generate a list of the anti-Halladays: the players no team would want to trade for.

I got to thinking of this list after Dave Cameron posted a list of the 50 players with the most trade value over on fangraphs.com. That list consisted primarily of good, young players signed to team-favorable contracts or players who aren't yet making big money. (His top 10: Evan Longoria, Hanley Ramirez, Justin Upton, Albert Pujols, Matt Wieters, Brian McCann, David Wright, Ryan Braun, Tim Lincecum, Chase Utley.)

Our list, on the other hand, consists primarily of players signed to bloated contracts that make it impossible to foresee their getting traded. Or maybe the player is just really awful.

Anyway, our first annual list of major leaguers with the least trade value (for 2009, we calculated one-third of the player's salary since the season is about two-thirds complete):

[+] EnlargeYuniesky Betancourt
G. Newman Lowrance/Getty ImagesBetancout is hitting .156 since joining the Royals. Enjoy, Royals fans!

15. Yuniesky Betancourt, Royals

Total left: $7 million through 2011 (includes $2 million team buyout and Mariners paying part of salary)

He can't hit, can't field, can't run, doesn't hustle or seem to care at times ... wait, you say the Royals actually just traded for this guy?

14. Kenji Johjima, Mariners

Total left: $18.64 million through 2011

Anybody want a 33-year-old catcher with a .299 on-base percentage and little power? Didn't think so. Congratulations, former Mariners general manager Bill Bavasi, you signed the first two guys on our list!

13. Juan Pierre, Dodgers

Total left: $21.8 million through 2011

C'mon, we had to get at least one Ned Colletti signing on here.

12. Carlos Lee, Astros

Total left: $61.6 million through 2012

Lee is a consistent run producer and has surpassed the predicted output of many analysts, but he's paid like one of the game's true elite hitters (which he isn't), making $18.5 million per season. He's kind of like the Jennifer Aniston of hitters: consistent and solid, but he's never going to win you an Academy Award and it's hard to predict when the decline will come.

11. Todd Helton, Rockies

Total left: $45.28 million through 2011 (includes $4.6 million team buyout)

Helton has had a nice rebound after the first sub-.300 season of his career, but he's nowhere near the player he was when the Rockies signed him to a beast of a $141.5 million contract in 2001. The $16.6 million he'll take home in 2009 represents more than 20 percent of the Rockies' payroll. The deal has only two seasons left (and, yes, Colorado will most definitely take the team buyout after 2011, as Helton would be owed $23 million in 2012), but with his diminished power and health issues, he's untradeable unless the Rockies agreed to pick up a large chunk of his salary. At least he's not a threat to go all Denny Neagle on us.

[+] EnlargeNate Robertson
G Fiume/Getty ImagesRobertson led the AL in earned runs allowed in 2008 and is now a $10-million-per-year mopup reliever.

10. Dontrelle Willis, Nate Robertson, Jeremy Bonderman and Carlos Guillen, Tigers

Total left: $73.5 million (Guillen signed through 2011, others through 2010)

Congratulations, Dave Dombrowski, you've had so many bad signings recently that it's easier just to group them all together (and we considered including Miguel Cabrera, who will earn more than $100 million through 2015, but he's at least young enough to keep producing big numbers).

Note: Total payment increases $500,000 if Willis or Robertson win the Cy Young Award next season.

9. Aaron Rowand, Giants

Total left: $39.96 million through 2012

It's not that he's a bad player, it's just that ... well, he's Aaron Rowand. He's on the wrong side of 30, his one big season came in Philly's bandbox and he's signed for three more seasons. Which probably means the Royals will try to get him this winter.

8. Gary Matthews Jr., Angels

Total left: $26.3 million through 2011

The first $50 million contract given to a backup outfielder still has two seasons remaining.

7. Travis Hafner, Indians

Total left: $44.075 million through 2012 (includes $2.75 million team buyout)

Signing a guy like Hafner is kind of like dating Jessica Simpson. He looked pretty good at his peak (he led the AL in OPS in 2006), but there was risk involved: he was thick-bodied, likely to put on weight, turning 30 and one-dimensional in his skill-set, limited to designated hitter duties only. It doesn't take much for that kind of player to go downhill in a hurry. Even though he can still bring his A-game at times, Cleveland is stuck with this contract.

6. Alfonso Soriano, Cubs

Total left: $94.8 million through 2014

Soriano's career is sort of like a Dickens novel: there were the best of times (his early years, when he put up big numbers, frustrated at times with the flaws in his game, but was a huge positive due to a low salary), there were the worst of times (the current years, when he puts up mediocre numbers, frustrates most of the time with the flaws in his game, and is a bit of an albatross due to his high salary). Soriano will make $18 million a year for five more seasons starting in 2010. He'll be 34 next year. No thank you.

5. CC Sabathia, Yankees

Total left: $142.6 million through 2015

This is no knock on Sabathia's ability or even his girth, but it's difficult to imagine a team willing to take on a pitcher making $23 million per season for another six years. Well, maybe the Mets.

4. Carlos Silva, Mariners

Total left: $28.63 million through 2011 (includes $2 million team buyout)

On the bright side, Mariners fans, this contract was so stupefyingly awful, it led to the long-overdue firing that ended the incompetent reign of Bavasi. The deal was for $48 million and Silva has gone 5-18, 6.77 with the Mariners, is on the disabled list and quite likely to have thrown his last major league pitch.

3. Alex Rodriguez, Yankees

Total left: Approximately $219 million through 2017 (does not include $30 million team marketing agreement)

The "Ishtar" of baseball contracts. On paper, maybe it looked good: the best player in the game, the richest franchise in the game, getting together for a once-in-a-lifetime deal ... but, like the infamous flop that starred Dustin Hoffman and Warren Beatty, it's destined to not return enough on its investment. A-Rod will earn $61 million in the years he turns 40, 41 and 42 -- at which time he'll likely be one very expensive designated hitter, considering the Yanks will have Mark Teixeira at first base. (The idea of a 41-year-old third baseman with a bad hip should bring smiles to AL East fans). The contract is so mammothly outsized even Omar Minaya wouldn't trade for him. And for you Pirates fans hoping to see A-Rod in black and gold someday, he has no-trade protection anyway.

2. Vernon Wells, Blue Jays

Total left: $116 million through 2014

[+] EnlargeVernon Wells
Al Messerschmidt/Getty ImagesWells ranks 79th in the American League in OPS among regulars.

Wells signed his extension following the 2006 season, in which he had hit .303 with 32 home runs. He would be turning 28 years old. Let us attempt to defend J.P. Ricciardi's making Wells one of the highest-paid players in the game:

(1) Wells had been a durable player, playing 154 or more games in four of his five big league seasons.

(2) He had led the AL in total bases, hits and doubles in 2003 (we'll ignore the .272 average in 2004 and the .269 average in 2005).

(3) He was regarded as a top-notch center fielder, having won his third straight Gold Glove.

(4) Umm ... he was well-liked in Toronto, a fixture in the community, was just entering his prime ...

OK, we can't go on any longer. The biggest issue in giving Wells the monster contract was that his on-base percentage was barely league average, even in 2006. He would be unlikely to get better moving forward. He had ranked in the top 10 in the AL in on-base percentage, slugging percentage or OPS just once (eighth in slugging in 2003). Simply put, his offensive production for an outfielder did not come close to justifying the size of the deal.

So now the Jays are saddled with more than $100 million left on a player who has battled injuries, has deteriorated rapidly as a center fielder (the fielding data on fangraphs.com rates him as one of the league's worst outfielders this season) and still doesn't get on base enough. Oh, and is part of the reason the team has to shop Halladay.

Wells can opt out of his contract after 2011. Odds of that happening are slimmer than Prince Fielder's fitting into David Eckstein's uniform.

1. Barry Zito, Giants

Total left: $89.1 million through 2013 (includes $7 million team buyout)

The positives: he stays healthy, has dreamy eyes, and was once linked to Alyssa Milano. The negatives: 27-40 since joining the Giants, 4.79 ERA since joining the Giants, one complete game since joining the Giants, will make $18.5 million in each of the next two seasons, $19 million in 2012 and $20 million in 2013, and was once linked to Hilary Duff. Wait, one more positive: his contract expires when Tim Lincecum is set to become a free agent. Don't you feel a little better now, Giants fans?

Dishonorable mention: Mark Teixeira (size and length of his contract make him nearly untradeable to all but two or three teams), Eric Byrnes (one more season!), Eric Chavez ($66 million deal finally ends next season with $12 million salary and $3 million buyout), Johan Santana (salaries beginning in 2010: $21M, $22.5M, $24M, $25.5M, $25M or $5.5M buyout), A.J. Burnett ($16.5 million per season through 2013 for oft-injured righty), Michael Young (having his best season since 2005, but will earn $16 million per through 2013, when he'll be 36), Daisuke Matsuzaka (owed $28 million for 2010-12 and now faces big-time health problems), Alex Rios (owed $52.8 million through 2014, has continued to regress from his 2006-07 production).

Contract information from Cot's Baseball Contracts.

David Schoenfield | email

SweetSpot blogger