Single page view Page 2

Friday, October 14

Editor's note: Jon Garland pitched. Paul Konerko hit. The umpires umped. Chicago won again. Pretty basic, right? Not if you're Rob Neyer and Eric Neel, who can always find something to second-guess ...

Rob Neyer: OK, you're Ozzie Guillen and you've got the deepest bullpen in the major leagues. Jon Garland is pitching one of his best games of the year, but he's also thrown 91 pitches. Do you let him come out for the bottom of the eighth to protect a three-run lead?

Eric Neel: Hang on, I'm still wrestling with "OK, you're Ozzie Guillen." Do I get to take a potshot at Mags Ordonez before I answer this question? Can I call for a gratuitous sacrifice bunt first? The possibilities are dizzying, and that's before we get to whether I can now cuss in Spanish without even thinking about it. But as for your question, no, I do not come out with Garland. As I said last night about Phil Garner's use of Brad Lidge, I'd like to get my guys a bit of work here. Cliff Politte and Bobby Jenks both need a little LCS experience and some loosening of the arms and such. They're my move here. Pollitte for the eighth and Jenks to seal the deal. And you, if you're Ozzie (which, by the way, you can't be, because I'm never giving up the role), what do you do?

Rob: Well, as I'm writing this the White Sox are batting in the eighth and they've got runners on first and third with nobody out, so the lead might get bigger in a hurry ... For the moment, though, I would say it's still Garland's game, since he's thrown so few pitches and the White Sox have two more games in the next 48 hours. A rested bullpen is a real luxury in the postseason, because of course you're generally not going to be as patient with your starter as you would be in June. If the bullpen's rested tomorrow night, it's all hands on deck in case Freddy Garcia doesn't look good early. Anyway, the Angels escaped with no damage, so it's still a three-run lead heading to the bottom of the eighth.

Eric: I see what you're getting at, and maybe Ozzie is right there with you. But if I'm Ozzie (and again, this is just a ridiculously intoxicating thought; I mean, I could threaten to retire right here, tonight), my guess is I'm actually leaving JG in because I'm feeling kind of throwback, kind of men-are-men about it all. Either way, Garland looks good and, as you say, the bullpen is rested.

More playoff coverage
Click here for complete coverage of the MLB playoffs, including Insider columnist Rob Neyer, who will be contributing to Second Guessing during the postseason.

Rob Neyer: Oct. 11 chat wrap Insider

Playoff theories: What really wins in the postseason

Angels-White Sox series page
Astros-Cardinals series page

So here's my question for you. If you're Mike Scioscia, at what point to do you call the guys together, all Buttermaker-hatching-a-secret-plan-in-the-dugout style and say, "OK, somebody take a walk. Trust me. It'll shock them. It'll be like Mo sticking fingers in Curly's eyes, they won't know where they are ... "? What's up with the no walks, is what I'm saying. Can it be even remotely justified?

Rob: I would like to be Mike Scioscia, just for a day. Maybe that's a part of our future, the ability to be Mike Scioscia. In that Spielberg movie set in 2047 (or whenever; not the one about the robot boy, the other one), the people in the fantasy parlor were either yelling at their boss or enjoying the pleasures of multiple beautiful women. But me? I'd like to be a manager. Or a center fielder. I'd pay good money for that.

Oh, you asked about walks ... Yeah. Lou Piniella actually had the unmitigated gall to point out that the Angels have just one walk in this entire series (and they walked only five times in five games against the Yankees). This is pretty ridiculous.

I don't think it's intentional, per se. But have you ever noticed that as we get older, our dominant qualities tend to become more dominant? I wonder if the same thing doesn't happen to baseball teams. "You thought we were aggressive during the regular season? Just watch this." Basically, if they don't draw any walks and Vladimir Guerrero's not doing anything, they're not going to score enough runs to compete.

Eric: Yeah, it's hard to change philosophically at this stage, and as things get tighter, more intense, you do tend to do what you do all the more. That said, part of winning a seven-game series is making adjustments. And it seems to me very likely that both Bengie Molina and Vlad Guerrero are hurting to some degree, and that's a big, big part of your offense right there (actually, Vlad and anyone, Vlad and a skate rat you find on the curb and cajole to play with some quality nug is a big, big part of your offense), and it seems to me you have to be willing, as a club, to change what you do to compensate for those sorts of things. We've seen the Angels do that with their pitching staff -- making the desperate switch to Santana, leaving Colon off the ALCS roster, etc. -- but it's not something we're seeing with their approach at the plate.

Continued...


Page 1 of 2Next>>         Single page view