|ESPN.com: Page 2||[Print without images]|
Thirty-two years ago, I was lucky enough to witness a bit of Olympic history. Some friends and I scored tickets to a few events at the 1976 Summer Olympics in Montreal. And we were just outside Olympic Stadium, on a downhill stretch, to watch the last mile of the men's marathon.
The marathon is one of the most prominent Olympic events. There really isn't a forgettable one. In 1976, even though African nations boycotted the Montreal Games because of the New Zealand national rugby team's tour of South Africa, the men's marathon had many outstanding runners and famous names. The field included: Frank Shorter, the favorite, who had won the 1972 Olympic marathon in Munich (the first American to win the gold in that event since Johnny Hayes in 1908); Bill Rodgers, who had won the Boston and New York City Marathons in 1975; and Finland's Lasse Viren, the mystery man, who had won the 5,000 and 10,000 meters in Munich and Montreal, and was running the first marathon of his career.
|Waldemar Cierpinski waves on his way to Olympic gold in Montreal.|
As it turned out, it was Waldemar Cierpinski, an East German who had competed internationally in the steeplechase, but had no record as a marathoner. But you'd never have known that, the way he pushed the pace that day. He looked less tired than we did on the sidewalk.
Shorter was the next runner to come into view, followed by Karel Lismont, the Belgian who had won the silver medal in the marathon in 1972. Lismont was only a few meters ahead of another American runner, Don Kardong. Then came Viren. Rodgers had dropped behind the lead pack. So had everyone else.
When the lead runners reached the stadium, the order didn't change. There were no late passes. Kardong was closing in on Lismont for the bronze, but he fell just a few strides short. And Cierpinski's win didn't look like a fluke. He won going away. In fact, he even ran a full extra lap inside the stadium at full throttle, unsure of where the finish line was.
It was an upset for the ages. And those who crossed the line behind Cierpinski couldn't grouse about it. The best man clearly had won. In general, track and field is unambiguous. Nothing is left in the hands of judges. There are no questionable calls. It's all about times, heights and distances.
At least it was for 20 years.
Everything changed in the mid-1990s, a few years after the Berlin Wall was knocked down and the German Democratic Republic was no more. That's when the GDR's archives were opened up, and the secrets of East Germany's success in Olympic sports were revealed. Long-standing suspicions were confirmed.
My friends and I had seen history on that marathon course in Montreal. Everyone suspected that steroids were a stain on other events, like the sprints, the throws and the rest. But it seemed like the marathon was above it all. It wasn't. We'd seen the first dirty Olympic marathon.
Was it the first? Even in London in 1908, there was talk that the marathon wasn't on the up-and-up. Canadian Tom Longboat, a Boston Marathon record-holder and a prerace favorite, was in second place when he dropped out after 19 miles, suspecting that he'd been poisoned by either rival coaches or gamblers. But nothing was ever proven.
Back in 1976, some people might have bet that the marathon wasn't going to be clean. But it wasn't Cierpinski they were talking about. Lasse Viren's success had led some to believe he had been blood doping -- getting transfusions of red blood cells. Viren admitted to drinking reindeer milk, but he owned up to nothing else.
There was no testing for blood doping back in '76, but there was steroid testing. In fact, the Montreal Games were the first Olympics to have steroid testing. The testers did manage to catch one cheat in track and field: Poland's Danuta Rosani-Gwardecka, who finished 14th in the women's discus. But according to the test results, every other track-and-field event, including the men's marathon, was clean.
The 1976 Games were also the breakthrough Games for East Germany. The GDR had a population of 16 million people, but came away with a whopping 40 gold medals in Montreal, second only to the Soviet Union's 49 and ahead of the United States' total. The rest of the world had suspicions about the East Germans, but most focused on its female swimmers, who won 11 out of 13 races and looked like the Butkus sisters. Suspicions were also focused on its women's track team, which won nine of 14 events. But not on the marathon champion, Cierpinski, though.
|Cierpinski and Shorter embraced when the race was over.|
Still, Shorter said, he didn't give a single thought to Cierpinksi using performance-enhancing drugs. "In the heat of the event you're focused on what you're doing," he said.
Four years later, Cierpinski went on to win the Olympic marathon again in Moscow. In 1983 he finished third in the marathon at the inaugural World Track and Field Championships in Helsinki. That was his last major marathon. The Soviet-led boycott of the 1984 Summer Games in Los Angeles denied him a shot at a third consecutive Olympic marathon gold. Still, Abebe Bikila of Ethopia was the only other runner to win two Olympic golds in track's longest test. Cierpinski's legacy looked to be secure.
Things changed in 1998, when a German scientist, Dr. Werner Franke, managed to get into the archives of Stasi, East Germany's secret police force. By the time the GDR collapsed, Stasi's spooks had managed to destroy most of its incriminating paperwork, but not a file on State Plan 14:25, which Dr. Franke uncovered at the Stasi headquarters in Leipzig. State Plan 14:25 contained details of East Germany's drug program for its Olympic athletes. The file implicated many gold medalists, five of them winners in track and field in Montreal. Cierpinski's name was at the top of Page 105. He was No. 62.
"The documentary evidence is there," Shorter said. "I'm convinced Franke knows something [more]."
It seemed incriminating enough for the International Olympic Committee to follow up with an inquiry -- maybe even a commission that could reopen the record book and reassign medals? But, no such luck.
When the documents first came to light in 1998, then-International Olympic Committee president Juan Antonio Samaranch declared that there would be "no rewriting history." The results from the 1976 Summer Olympics look like a dead issue now -- even though U.S. Olympic relay runners recently had to hand back medals from the 2000 Games in Sydney because team members Antonio Pettigrew and Marion Jones were exposed as steroid users.
It might end up being the only Olympic marathon that I'll ever see in person, and it was a lie. If I feel cheated, how do those who were actually in the race feel?
When Dr. Franke first revealed State Plan 14:25 to the world, the press made it seem like Shorter was on a mission to scrub Cierpinski's name and other East Germans from the record books. "As someone potentially harmed by this [East German doping], under German law I have the right to the documents," Shorter told the Rocky Mountain News in 1998. "How much persistence are [former] Olympic athletes going to have in this process? You're dealing with a very persistent pool of people."
If anyone felt cheated, though, you'd assume it would be Don Kardong. If Cierpinski's win were voided, Kardong would move up from fourth place to the bronze medal. Back in 1998, though, Kardong sounded philosophical about it. "In the purest sense, the judgment of the IOC is irrelevant," Kardong wrote in Runner's World magazine 10 years ago. "It is the athlete's own measure of self that matters. In my moment of truth, I lost the bronze medal to Karel Lismont. I reached down and found a well of fatigue. I can't change that, but at least I can claim my race -- what I did and didn't do -- as my own."
But things change. At least, some things change.
These days Shorter wants to make it clear that he wasn't just out to upgrade his silver from Montreal to a gold. He was seeking justice and fairness, more than any personal or selfish ends. "I never actively campaigned to have the results from '76 changed," Shorter said. "I can feel good about what I have done in my running career."
|Is it too late to wipe out this result?|
Shorter is convinced that the IOC is on the right track -- a lot of distance has been covered, going from Samaranch's belief that results should be etched in stone to the disqualification of cheaters from the 2000 Olympics eight years after the fact. "I have to give [current IOC president] Jacques Rogge credit," he says. "Rogge has done as good a job as anyone on the planet could do. A lot of progress has been made."
Meanwhile, Kardong sounds a little less accepting of the results from Montreal than he did when Dr. Franke first went public with State Plan 14:25.
"The IOC should do something to acknowledge the fact that the East Germans were cheating," says Kardong, who has long been the chief organizer of the Bloomsday Run in his hometown of Spokane, Wash. "I don't know if the IOC should make some sort of statement, or have something in the record books. I don't know how feasible it is to go back and start changing the order of finishes in all those events. It's an incredibly complicated issue. It's hard to know which East German athletes knew about the drugs they were being given, or if they had any choice even if they knew. Some were victims of the system and had to sacrifice their health and even their lives.
"There's only one thing that would be wrong, and that is to do nothing, which is what the IOC has chosen."
Some things don't change, though.
What Cierpinski thinks about the race in 1976 and State Plan 14:25 is still a mystery. He has declined all interview requests over the years. "If I were his lawyer, I'd give him the same advice," Shorter said. "Say nothing."
Cierpinski's name is still in the record book. So are the names of a bunch of the GDR's Olympic champions whose names show up beside numbers in Stasi documents.
As it stands now, the IOC has a statute of limitations on its chase of drug cheaters: eight years. Montreal is 32 years ago and counting. But if ever history has needed to be rewritten, the time is now.
An asterisk? A footnote? Declaring all GDR results null and void? It will never change what Shorter saw when Cierpinski pulled away from him, what Kardong saw when Lismont beat him to the tape for third place, what we saw on the streets of Montreal. But it would change how we look at the Olympics, an event that would still have stopwatches, but no time limits on fairness.
Gare Joyce is a regular contributor to ESPN The Magazine and ESPN.com.