Turner's schedule will hurt '09 numbers
Is Michael Turner a lock to finish as a top-five running back?
As a fantasy analyst, you know when you are writing a column how well it will be generally received: pick on anything Cowboys or Steelers and expect a backlash, compliment the Patriots and expect to be accused of a New England bias. It comes with the territory, so I'll let you know up front that I expect several comments below within ESPN Conversation that will convey how "highly" I am thought of by some readers and how they could do this job better. Go ahead, let 'er rip. My job isn't to write columns that will be widely accepted and ignored; rather it is to present information to you that will help you make an informed decision on draft day, so hear me out.
Buried behind LaDainian Tomlinson for four years in the San Diego backfield, Turner teased fantasy owners by averaging 5.5 yards per carry in mop-up duty for the Chargers. Finally unleashed by the Falcons in 2008, Turner didn't disappoint at all as he posted elite-level statistics of 1,699 rushing yards and 17 touchdowns. Since everyone who waited for this future stud to get an opportunity to shine was proved right, it's easy to see why owners love Turner this year. But should they?
If you prorate the 10 games Turner played against non-bottom-seven rush defenses last season, his stats for 2008 would have been 1,322 yards and 13 scores. All in all those numbers are solid, but definitely not worthy of top-five, or even first-round status. Those stats equate to 210 fantasy points, which places him as the 10th-best running back according to our 2009 projections.
I understand that some will have issues with projecting him over just those 10 games, but consider this: Turner's opponents in those 10 games last year averaged 108 rushing yards against per game. His complete 2009 schedule allowed 102 rushing yards per game last year. This means his 2009 schedule is even tougher than his 2008 schedule after you remove the six easiest opponents from last year's schedule.
Then, there's the passing game. As a rookie last season, Matt Ryan demonstrated he is more than a capable quarterback, he's a future star. By adding Tony Gonzalez to the receiving corps, the Falcons are signaling to all that Ryan will be increasingly responsible for moving Atlanta down the field through the air. Any extra yardage gained through the air means fewer opportunities for Turner on the ground.
At the end of the day, you need to take these two factors into account when projecting Turner's 2009 performance. Do you expect that he's going to improve on his 4.5 yards per carry from last year? Do you expect that he's going to get more touches this season? Do you believe that the splits versus normal teams and the bottom feeders are enough to move him down in your own personal rankings? Personally, I put a lot of stock in those splits and can't see an improvement in either of the other two metrics. Therefore, for me, Turner is severely overvalued this season and won't find his way onto any of my rosters this year.
Ken Daube is a fantasy football analyst for ESPN.com. His ESPN.com fan profile is available here.
FANTASY TOP HEADLINES
- Hard Count: Make choices you can live with
- Matthew Berry's Love/Hate for Week 16
- Week 16 flex ranks: Trust your Bears
- Kaiser: More playing time, more value