10 ways to spice up your league's rules
Editor's Note: This article was originally published in July 2010. We are bringing it back in archive form for your convenience.
Repeat after me: "Every fantasy football league is different."
The same set of rules that works perfectly for my league may not fit the bill for yours. After all, the collective personality of each league can vary greatly. Some leagues will be populated by troublemakers and require a constitution with more restrictions to close unwanted loopholes. Other leagues may have a few rebels who want to play the game with a scoring system that more "traditional leagues" may deem crazy.
As you put the finishing touches on the new edition of your league's constitution, you may wish to adopt one or more of the rules below. Certainly not all of these ideas will appeal to everybody who plays fantasy football, but who knows, you may find that one concept which your league has been missing.
Don't ever be afraid to think outside the box. It's your league, so play by the rules that work for you and your fellow owners. To paraphrase the great Ralph Tresvant, "If I like the rule, who cares what you like?"
Rule 1 -- The Window: One of most often-heard complaints after a trade goes through is, "I would have offered so much more for that guy." So why not force these Monday morning quarterbacks to put up or shut up? When a trade is agreed upon and reported to the league as a whole, instead of holding a veto vote, allow a window of time where other teams may make public counter offers to either side. After the window closes, if no other offers have been made, the trade goes through. If offers have been made, either owner (or perhaps even both) may pull out of the original deal in order to accept one of the counteroffers, which will immediately be binding.
Rule 2 -- The Neighbors: Worried about collusion? Make it impossible for poorly performing teams to all of a sudden have a huge impact on your playoffs. Don't allow the last-place team to send his studs to the first-place team in a lopsided deal that practically guarantees the championship trophy. Institute a rule stating that after a certain date in the season, trades may only be made among teams within three spots of each other in the overall standings.
Rule 3 -- The Playground Rule: One of the first concepts of game theory that children develop is the time-honored tradition of "no backsies." Many a league has been ruined when teams turn trades into library loans: for example, swapping players back and forth to help each other out during bye weeks. Even more egregious is the owner who hands over his top-10 backup quarterback to the signal-caller starved team playing his primary rival in a deal that gets made again in reverse two weeks later. One simple rule is all that is needed to ensure this never happens: "Teams may not make two trades in the same season involving the same player."
Rule 4 -- The Psychic: We all know that luck often plays a bigger part than skill in the end result of fantasy football games. An owner can correctly surmise that Team X will win big and choose to run the ball rather than pass, adjust his/her lineup accordingly and still watch in horror as an unexpected injury garners him a goose egg. Why not reward owners who correctly predict the outcome of games -- even if individual players might let them down -- by having each owner also play ESPN's Pigskin Pick 'Em and adding a scoring bonus based on how many games they get correct each week?
Rule 5 -- The Captain: Fantasy owners can't control which members of their team get the ball during the games, but that doesn't mean you can't artificially create your own game plan. Allow each owner to assign a team captain for the upcoming game. The team captain's fantasy points are then given a slight increase, say 20 percent, so if he scores 10 points in your standard scoring, it becomes 12. You can do the same thing defensively by having each owner identify a player to "key on," giving him an automatic 20 percent deduction.
Rule 6 -- The Boy Scout: As the motto says, "be prepared." No matter how elaborate the scoring system, you're bound to end up with a tie every now and again. While that's not a disaster in the regular season, in the playoffs it can cause a nuclear explosion of outrage if there's no plan in place to break the deadlock. While some leagues simply advance the higher seed, why not let the players settle it on the field? Each owner should name an overtime player prior to the game. In the event there is a tie, then the score of these extra players are added to the mix to try to tip the scales.
Rule 7 -- The Ping-Pong Rule: A very real and unfortunate byproduct of some keeper leagues is "tanking," where a team intentionally starts an inferior lineup in the hopes of losing games in order to get a better draft pick for the next season. The biggest problem with this comes when the tanking team's loss ends up "stealing" a playoff spot away from another team by simply handing a victory to his competition. If this is happening in your league, go the David Stern route and get yourself some ping-pong balls. A draft lottery may not eliminate all tanking, but it certainly makes it a lot less likely to occur.
Insiders, have a question about your fantasy team? Get it answered by an ESPN expert! Ask your question
Rule 8 -- The Boot: One of the most frustrating things for a commissioner is having an owner "quit" midseason when his/her team is losing by simply going through the motions and not really putting in any effort to improve. Sometimes it's hard to get rid of owners like this, especially if they've paid a form of league dues. Do you want to ensure people play the entire season no matter what? Take a page from the world of soccer and incorporate "relegation" into the mix. Whoever finishes last overall is out of the league for a year. If an owner truly cares about being in your league, you'll see a change in attitude when this rule gets added to the constitution.
Rule 9 -- The Gold Star: Another way to keep interest year-round is to offer up some consolation prizes that can be attained at any point in the season, even by the so-called bottom of the barrel. How about the top three scores in any single week getting acknowledged with a small percentage of the kitty? How about the winner of the consolation bracket (the playoffs of the non-playoff teams) getting a supplemental draft pick between Rounds 1 and 2 the following season? And as for the dreaded Week 17, when many fantasy leagues go dark, have each team other than the champion field a starting lineup. Give a small prize to the team that finishes with the median score for the week; in other words, in a 12-team league, the sixth-highest score wins. Trust me, there's a lot more strategy to this than it may appear.
Rule 10 -- The Tribe Has Spoken: For many years, my long-time keeper league had a parallel "Survivor" tournament running alongside our regular fantasy league. With divisions treated as "tribes," the highest score received "immunity" while the lowest score was "voted off the island." Eventually, the idea ran its course, but for several seasons, the extra competition was a fun in-season diversion. Don't be afraid to give something different a try. The results may surprise you.
FANTASY TOP HEADLINES
- Crabtree's injury opens chances for Boldin
- Reasons behind B.J. Upton's slump
- Can Corbin, Guthrie keep up win totals?
- KaraBlog: Don't dismiss Adam Dunn, Dan Uggla
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
2012 Fantasy Football Draft Kit
ESPN.com's fantasy analysts offer all the information you'll need to succeed in your draft and all season long.
• Draft Kit Home
• Join/Reactivate a league
• Follow ESPN Fantasy on Facebook
• The NFL on ESPN.com
Profiles and Projections for 2012
• Top 300 | Cheat Sheets
• Analysts: Berry | Harris | Karabell
• Quarterback: Rankings | Preview
• Running back: Rankings | Preview
• Wide receiver: Rankings | Preview
• Tight end: Rankings | Preview
• Def./Special teams: Rankings | Preview
• Kicker: Rankings | Preview
• IDP: Rankings | Preview
• Other formats: PPR | TD-Only | Keepers
• Analysts: Berry | Harris | Karabell
• The Magazine: Position profiles
The Talented Mr. Roto
• Mock 1: 10-team standard (May 7)
• Mock 2: 12-team standard (June 14)
• Mock 3: 12-team PPR (July 17)
• Mock 4: 10-team standard (Aug. 7)
• Mock 5: 10-team, 2 QBs (Aug. 13)
• Mock 6: 10-team auction (Aug. 21)
• Mock 7: 12-team standard (Aug. 29)
• Twitter Mock Draft
Geico Fantasy Draft Special Podcast
• Top 2012 storylines: 20 to 11 (Aug. 3)
• Top 2012 storylines: 10 to 1 (Aug. 7)
• Quarterback preview (Aug. 10)
• Running back preview (Aug. 17)
• Wide receiver preview (Aug. 21)
• TE, D/ST, K preview (Aug. 28)
• Injury updates: QB | RB | WR | TE
• Staff sleepers and busts
• Top faces in new places
• Are TEs worthy of flex consideration?
• Ten hotly debated players for 2012
• Does the two-QB approach work?
• Better predicting kickers' values
• Don't overanalyze strength of schedule
• How to use value-based drafting
• Will Cam Newton repeat his rookie success?
• Metrics to consider in finding IDP breakouts
• Streaming D/ST units
• Finding potential rebound candidates
• Harris' 10 flag-planted players for 2012
• Harris' super-deep sleepers for 2012
• C.J. Spiller's effect on Fred Jackson's value
• Where should Trent Richardson be drafted?
• Will Green-Ellis' TD success continue?
• Ben Tate's impact on Arian Foster's value
• Will Cruz, Nelson fall back to earth?
• Is Jones-Drew poised for drop-off?
• When to draft Darren McFadden
• Demaryius Thomas or Eric Decker?
• Are Panthers RBs unstartable?
• How much will Gore's fantasy value decline?
• How will Charles, Hillis split workload in KC?
• When should you draft Adrian Peterson?
• Rivers' new favorite WR: Meachem or Floyd?
• Vincent Jackson's impact with new team
• Choosing between Bryant and Austin
• The polarizing Michael Turner
• Roddy White or Julio Jones?
• Lloyd effect on Pats' other receivers
• Will any one Patriots RB emerge in 2012?
• Making sense of Saints backfield
• Can you trust DeMarco Murray?
• What is Tim Tebow's value with the Jets?
• Assessing the values of Bucs RBs
• Can Robert Griffin III match Cam Newton?
• Joyner: Underrated PPR WRs for 2012
• Karabell: Top 35 rookies for 2012
• Kiper: Keeper-league targets
• Joyner: Underrated WRs for 2012
• Joyner: Underrated RBs for 2012
• Kiper: Fantasy rookies to target, avoid
• Joyner: Underrated QBs for 2012
• Karabell: Will DeSean Jackson bounce back?
• Joyner: How O-Lines impact QBs in fantasy
• Karabell: Reggie Bush outlook
• Karabell: Early ADP trends
• Karabell: Redskins RB situation
• Joyner: Undervalued, overvalued RBs
• Karabell: Be wary of Steve Smith
• Joyner: Why CJ2K will be top fantasy RB
• Joyner: Five breakout players in 2012
• Karabell: Five keeper-league targets
• Adrian Peterson outlook
• Peyton Manning's health
• Peyton Manning expectations
• Darren McFadden outlook
• Andre Johnson's health
• Projecting Cam Newton
• Second-tier RBs to consider
• Arian Foster versus Ray Rice
• Will DeSean Jackson bounce back?
• Michael Vick expectations
• Mark Sanchez versus Tim Tebow
• Will Rob Gronkowski repeat as top TE?
• Where to draft Gronkowski, Graham
• Aaron Hernandez expectations
• Can RG3 match Newton's rookie season?
• Will Jamaal Charles return to form?
• DeMarco Murray outlook
• Is Beanie Wells being undervalued?
• Rashard Mendenhall versus Isaac Redman
• How will Drew Brees handle turmoil in NO?
• Why has Matt Schaub's ranking fallen?
• Is this the year Matt Ryan breaks out?
• Tight end sleepers for 2012
• Jonathan Stewart versus DeAngelo Williams
• Which rookie RBs could surprise?
• Demaryius Thomas versus Eric Decker
• Better late pick: Rookie WR or Randy Moss?
• Is Jordy Nelson's TD total repeatable?
• Is Eli Manning an elite fantasy QB?
• Will Philip Rivers bounce back in 2012?
• Can Victor Cruz repeat his breakout 2011?
• Andrew Luck's short- and long-term value
• Expectations for Trent Richardson
• Will Julio Jones outperform Roddy White?
• Is it wise to draft a QB early?
• Will Reggie Bush repeat his 2011 numbers?
• Brandon Marshall expectations