Commentary

The Talented Mr. Roto: Updating my rankings

Updated: August 19, 2008, 11:11 PM ET
By Matthew Berry | ESPN.com

Not a lot, actually.

As I sat down to do my "Love/Hate" update, I went through my original "Love/Hate" list, which I wrote June 18, and I found that, well, not a lot had changed.

I haven't changed my feelings about many of the guys. In fact, I'm feeling even better about, "loving," Troy Smith. My Laveranues Coles and Jerricho Cotchery picks are looking even better with No. 4 in town, and Chris Johnson hasn't done anything in the preseason to diminish my enthusiasm for him.

But there has been a lot of news this preseason. Not just with Favre to the Jets but also with injuries, role changes and, of course, Anne Hathaway and Megan Fox becoming single.

So I've updated my rankings. All my rankings. But right now, you see only the football ones. It's time for a "Love/Hate" update as well. As always, players I "love" are guys I would draft at least a round ahead of where they are being drafted in ESPN.com live drafts, and those I "hate" are players I would draft at least a round later. It doesn't mean I'd draft a guy I love ahead of a guy I hate, it just means I'm more likely to end up with him on my team when all is said and done.

Players I'm taking off my Love list

Bobby Engram, WR, Seahawks: Being out six weeks will hurt you. Because Deion Branch is coming back around the same time, and because Engram is 35 years old, he dropped quite a bit in my rankings. Incidentally, this doesn't help Nate Burleson in my opinion, because it gives him more defensive attention than he wants. I upped both Ben Obomanu and Courtney Taylor as a result of the injury, and I like Obomanu a bit more.

Chad Johnson, WR, Bengals: I still think Johnson will have a big year because he has something to prove. I like him more than I like Brandon Marshall and Steve Smith, who are both guaranteed to miss the start of the season, but I think Ocho Cinco is going where he should. I have, however, dropped him out of the top 10 of my WR rankings due to the possibility that he'll also miss a couple of games.

Players I'm taking off my Hate list

Click here to add the Matthew Berry widget.
ESPN.comESPN Widgets are portable applications you can place almost anywhere! Click on the image to add the Matthew Berry widget to your Web space.

Jamal Lewis, RB, Browns: I never like paying for a career year (or a resurgent one), so I initially was down on Lewis. But now that more drafts have completed, he's going where he should. Plus, the fact that no player had more YACO (yards after contact ) last year pushed him back into my good graces. I mean, how can you not like a guy who gives you great YACO?

Willie Parker, RB, Steelers: The arguments against him were health and Rashard Mendenhall. But he's healthy, and Mendenhall will get goal-line carries. Fine, Parker scored only two touchdowns last year and still was a productive running back. He won't score fewer than two this year. He's not a first-round running back, but because he's not going in the first round, we're good here. I have no issue with Parker going in the second round.

Marvin Harrison, WR, Colts: He's playing in the preseason. If he's on the field at all during the regular season, he should be going higher than the seventh round, which is where he is currently going.

Matt Leinart, QB, Cardinals: I'm on record as saying I'd rather have Kurt Warner, but if you manage to get both Arizona quarterbacks, you'll be fine. They'll put up a lot of points this year.

Players who are new to the Love list and have risen in my rankings

Ted Ginn Jr., WR, Dolphins: Chad Pennington has to throw it to someone. By the way, if I were a fan in Miami, I would wear a leather fetish outfit to the game and hold up a sign that said "Bring Out the Ginn."

Ricky Williams, RB, Dolphins: Smoke 'em if you got 'em. I never get tired of that joke, hacky as it is. Anyway, Williams has looked good, and Ronnie Brown now has a hurt thumb. Pennington isn't amazing, but he is a legit NFL quarterback, and the Dolphins will be OK on offense. Williams should be among the first of the backup running backs drafted.

Chris Perry, RB, Bengals: Further proof that Rudi Johnson is no longer "Rudi." I still like Kenny Watson more, but Perry definitely will have value.

Troy Smith, QB, Ravens: The guy is a gifted athlete, and guys like him can put points on the board. With a legit run game to take away the focal point of the offense, Smith should be either a useful No. 2 QB in leagues that play two or a solid bye-week/backup type.

JaMarcus Russell, QB, Raiders: See Smith, Troy.

Random observations about my updated rankings

• Of all the places that Brett Favre could land outside of Green Bay, New York was the best possible scenario for his fantasy value. I have him in the top 10 of quarterbacks, and I upped both Jerricho Cotchery and Laveranues Coles as a result.

• I also have Thomas Jones as a solid No. 2 running back. I liked him in June thanks to the new offensive line and his new blocker, Tony Richardson. Favre's addition only helps.

• I also upped Ryan Grant. He'll be the focal point of that offense, and you can say that about only a handful of running backs.

• I still have Steven Jackson at No. 5. I'm not worried about his holdout. Yet. But if you were picking at five and wanted to take Tom Brady instead, I wouldn't blame you.

• I think Clinton Portis should be the next running back off the board because of the following facts: 1. He was second in the NFL last year in touches. 2. He was second in yards after contact 3. He had 47 receptions. He'll be a much better fit for Jim Zorn's offense than folks realize.

It's not too late! Leagues are forming and drafting until Sep. 20, with scoring retroactive to Week 1.
Sign Up Today!

• I rank Peyton Manning only four slots ahead of Drew Brees, and here's why: Last year, there were seven weeks when Manning threw for one or zero touchdowns. Now there are rumors that Manning will miss the first week. The reason you draft Manning is his consistency. He never gets injured, always puts up points … well, that's no longer the case, is it? He's currently going at the end of the first round in ESPN drafts, and that's insane to me. He's a good fantasy QB this year, but I'd rather have Tony Romo (assuming Tom Brady already has been taken, of course).

• In my 50 Facts column, I actually forgot to explain why I don't consider Frank Gore a first-rounder this year. From the fine folks here at the ESPN research department: During the past five years, the lead back in a Mike Martz offense has averaged 1,109 total yards. That includes years with Marshall Faulk and Steven Jackson. That number would have been good for 60th last year. Frank Gore has never had double-digit touchdowns. And whoever lines up at quarterback for the 49ers this year is not Kurt Warner circa 1999. Or, heck, circa right now, either.

• The injury to the Broncos' Ryan Torain upped the values of Selvin Young and Andre Hall on my board. I hate Mike Shanahan as much as anyone alive, but partially because he is impossible to predict. And it wouldn't surprise me in the least if Young were to get all the carries and Andre Hall were to get some goal-line touches, which is what happened in the last preseason game.

• Say what you want about our little "Fantasy NFL Draft Special," but I think some useful nuggets were in there. Look, because it's TV, there are certain constraints. They need to move it quickly, so we could only do an eight-team league. That skews everything. So although I didn't like that Merril Hoge picked Rashard Mendenhall or that Chris Mortensen grabbed Felix Jones, it told me that both guys like those running backs. And they talk to a lot more folks and see a lot more tape and training camps than you or I. I moved both guys up, along with Devin Hester, for those reasons.

• It's not looking good for Ahman Green. I still like Chris Brown the most at running back (and he was in the "Love" section of my original article), but I have moved Steve Slaton up as well.

• If I didn't rank someone, it means I feel he is no better or worse than anyone else in the free-agent pool. So although you won't see Kyle Orton's name in the rankings, it doesn't mean I'm not aware that he's the Week 1 starter. It just means I don't care.

• If you are in the New York City area, stop by our fantasy football draft party (free and open to the public; first come, first served) at 6:30 p.m. Thursday at Brother Jimmy's (Lex and 31st) What will be there: ESPN commentator Linda Cohn and I, along with former Giants and Jets players, giveaways and more!

• If you live in the Chicago area, feel free to come to the ESPN Radio 1000 Fantasy Football Party on Aug. 22 and 23. I'll be there both days along with John Clayton, Mike Ditka and others.

Matthew Berry's Top 250 updated fantasy football rankings
RankNameTeamPositional
1LaDainian TomlinsonChargersRB1
2Brian WestbrookEaglesRB2
3Joseph AddaiColtsRB3
4Adrian PetersonVikingsRB4
5Steven JacksonRamsRB5
6Tom BradyPatriotsQB1
7Clinton PortisRedskinsRB6
8Randy MossPatriotsWR1
9Marshawn LynchBillsRB7
10Marion BarberCowboysRB8
11Ryan GrantPackersRB9
12Frank Gore49ersRB10
13Terrell OwensCowboysWR2
14Maurice Jones-DrewJaguarsRB11
15Tony RomoCowboysQB2
16Reggie WayneColtsWR3
17Braylon EdwardsBrownsWR4
18Marques ColstonSaintsWR5
19Willis McGaheeRavensRB12
20Jamal LewisBrownsRB13
21Thomas JonesJetsRB14
22Willie ParkerSteelersRB15
23Brandon JacobsGiantsRB16
24T.J. HoushmandzadehBengalsWR6
25Larry JohnsonChiefsRB17
26Darren McFaddenRaidersRB18
27Laurence MaroneyPatriotsRB19
28Torry HoltRamsWR7
29Peyton ManningColtsQB3
30Andre JohnsonTexansWR8
31Edgerrin JamesCardinalsRB20
32Reggie BushSaintsRB21
33Drew BreesSaintsQB4
34Larry FitzgeraldCardinalsWR9
35Santonio HolmesSteelersWR10
36Earnest GrahamBuccaneersRB22
37Michael TurnerFalconsRB23
38Ronnie BrownDolphinsRB24
39Fred TaylorJaguarsRB25
40Chad JohnsonBengalsWR11
41Plaxico BurressGiantsWR12
42Ben RoethlisbergerSteelersQB5
43Wes WelkerPatriotsWR13
44Anquan BoldinCardinalsWR14
45Roy WilliamsLionsWR15
46Selvin YoungBroncosRB26
47Brandon MarshallBroncosWR16
48Steve SmithPanthersWR17
49Dallas ClarkColtsTE1
50Donald DriverPackersWR18
51Roddy WhiteFalconsWR19
52Laveranues ColesJetsWR20
53Jonathan StewartPanthersRB27
54Kevin SmithLionsRB28
55Jerricho CotcheryJetsWR21
56Marvin HarrisonColtsWR22
57Greg JenningsPackersWR23
58Tony GonzalezChiefsTE2
59Jason WittenCowboysTE3
60LenDale WhiteTitansRB29
61Matt HasselbeckSeahawksQB6
62Matt ForteBearsRB30
63Antonio GatesChargersTE4
64Hines WardSteelersWR24
65Calvin JohnsonLionsWR25
66Carson PalmerBengalsQB7
67Dwayne BoweChiefsWR26
68Santana MossRedskinsWR27
69Andre HallBroncosRB31
70Justin FargasRaidersRB32
71Joey GallowayBuccaneersWR28
72San Diego Chargers D/ST D1
73Derek AndersonBrownsQB8
74Kenny WatsonBengalsRB33
75Kellen WinslowBrownsTE5
76Chris BrownTexansRB34
77Ahmad BradshawGiantsRB35
78Nate BurlesonSeahawksWR29
79DeAngelo WilliamsPanthersRB36
80Anthony GonzalezColtsWR30
81Maurice MorrisSeahawksRB37
82Jerious NorwoodFalconsRB38
83Rudi JohnsonBengalsRB39
84Patrick CraytonCowboysWR31
85Ted Ginn Jr.DolphinsWR32
86Lee EvansBillsWR33
87David GarrardJaguarsQB9
88Chris CooleyRedskinsTE6
89Jeremy ShockeySaintsTE7
90Brett FavreJetsQB10
91Chris JohnsonTitansRB40
92Julius JonesSeahawksRB41
93Chester TaylorVikingsRB42
94Rashard MendenhallSteelersRB43
95Ricky WilliamsDolphinsRB44
96Donovan McNabbEaglesQB11
97Marc BulgerRamsQB12
98Matt SchaubTexansQB13
99Kevin CurtisEaglesWR34
100Antwaan Randle ElRedskinsWR35
101D.J. HackettPanthersWR36
102Devin HesterBearsWR37
103Deuce McAllisterSaintsRB45
104Felix JonesCowboysRB46
105Heath MillerSteelersTE8
106Ronald CurryRaidersWR38
107Drew BennettRamsWR39
108Minnesota Vikings D/ST D2
109Isaac Bruce49ersWR40
110Reggie WilliamsJaguarsWR41
111Chris ChambersChargersWR42
112Bernard BerrianVikingsWR43
113Tony SchefflerBroncosTE9
114Ray RiceRavensRB47
115Ben ObomanuSeahawksWR44
116Donte' StallworthBrownsWR45
117Sammy MorrisPatriotsRB48
118Chris PerryBengalsRB49
119Kolby SmithChiefsRB50
120Jay CutlerBroncosQB14
121Jason CampbellRedskinsQB15
122Derrick WardGiantsRB51
123Fred JacksonBillsRB52
124Ahman GreenTexansRB53
125Chicago Bears D/ST D3
126Sidney RiceVikingsWR46
127Jerry PorterJaguarsWR47
128Reggie BrownEaglesWR48
129Amani ToomerGiantsWR49
130Seattle Seahawks D/ST D4
131Green Bay Packers D/ST D5
132James JonesPackersWR50
133Indianapolis Colts D/ST D6
134Aaron SteckerSaintsRB54
135Adrian PetersonBearsRB55
136Jake DelhommePanthersQB16
137Jon KitnaLionsQB17
138Philip RiversChargersQB18
139Eli ManningGiantsQB19
140Bobby EngramSeahawksWR51
141Kurt WarnerCardinalsQB20
142Aaron RodgersPackersQB21
143Mike HartColtsRB56
144Steve SlatonTexansRB57
145Pierre ThomasSaintsRB58
146Derrick MasonRavensWR52
147Donald LeePackersTE10
148Pittsburgh Steelers D/ST D7
149Chad PenningtonJetsQB22
150Jeff GarciaBuccaneersQB23
151James HardyBillsWR53
152Matt LeinartCardinalsQB24
153JaMarcus RussellRaidersQB25
154Todd HeapRavensTE11
155Marty BookerBearsWR54
156Owen DanielsTexansTE12
157Muhsin MuhammadPanthersWR55
158Deion BranchSeahawksWR56
159Shaun McDonaldLionsWR57
160Chris RedmanFalconsQB26
161Vince YoungTitansQB27
162J.T. O'Sullivan49ersQB28
163Arnaz Battle49ersWR58
164Bryant Johnson49ersWR59
165Kevin WalterTexansWR60
166Tatum BellLionsRB59
167Vernon Davis49ersTE13
168Alge CrumplerTitansTE14
169Benjamin WatsonPatriotsTE15
170Greg OlsenBearsTE16
171Warrick DunnBuccaneersRB60
172Vincent JacksonChargersWR61
173Javon WalkerRaidersWR62
174Robert MeachemSaintsWR63
175Leon WashingtonJetsRB61
176Ladell BettsRedskinsRB62
177Brandon JacksonPackersRB63
178Ryan TorainBroncosRB64
179Justin GageTitansWR64
180Correll BuckhalterEaglesRB65
181Brad SmithJetsWR65
182Tarvaris JacksonVikingsQB29
183Brodie CroyleChiefsQB30
184Darrell JacksonBroncosWR66
185Dominic RhodesColtsRB66
186Jacksonville Jaguars D/ST D8
187David PattenSaintsWR67
188New York Giants D/ST D9
189Dallas Cowboys D/ST D10
190Mark ClaytonRavensWR68
191LaMont JordanPatriotsRB67
192DeShaun Foster49ersRB68
193Tampa Bay Buccaneers D/ST D11
194New England Patriots D/ST D12
195Kevin JonesBearsRB69
196Garrett WolfeBearsRB70
197Courtney TaylorSeahawksWR69
198Jabar GaffneyPatriotsWR70
199Michael BushRaidersRB71
200Roydell WilliamsTitansWR71
201Andre' DavisTexansWR72
202Ike HilliardBuccaneersWR73
203Michael PittmanBroncosRB72
204Darren SprolesChargersRB73
205Carnell WilliamsBuccaneersRB74
206Kevin BossGiantsTE17
207Steve SmithGiantsWR74
208Ben UtechtBengalsTE18
209Dustin KellerJetsTE19
210Zach MillerRaidersTE20
211Marcedes LewisJaguarsTE21
212Anthony FasanoDolphinsTE22
213Troy SmithRavensQB31
214Trent EdwardsBillsQB32
215Leonard PopeCardinalsTE23
216Kenton KeithColtsRB75
217Chris HenryTitansRB76
218Musa SmithJetsRB77
219J.J. ArringtonCardinalsRB78
220Jacob HesterChargersRB79
221T.J. DuckettSeahawksRB80
222DeSean JacksonEaglesWR75
223Devery HendersonSaintsWR76
224Philadelphia Eagles D/ST D13
225Washington Redskins D/ST D14
226Baltimore Ravens D/ST D15
227Tennessee Titans D/ST D16
228Denver Broncos D/ST D17
229Miami Dolphins D/ST D18
230Carolina Panthers D/ST D19
231San Francisco 49ers D/ST D20
232Houston Texans D/ST D21
233Atlanta Falcons D/ST D22
234Shayne GrahamBengalsK1
235Nick FolkCowboysK2
236Stephen GostkowskiPatriotsK3
237Nate KaedingChargersK4
238Adam VinatieriColtsK5
239Phil DawsonBrownsK6
240Mason CrosbyPackersK7
241Robbie GouldBearsK8
242Jeff ReedSteelersK9
243Rob BironasTitansK10
244Josh BrownRamsK11
245Josh ScobeeJaguarsK12
246Kris BrownTexansK13
247Jason HansonLionsK14
248Neil RackersCardinalsK15
249David AkersEaglesK16
250Matt StoverRavensK17

Matthew Berry -- The Talented Mr. Roto -- is ESPN's senior director of fantasy. He was just as surprised as you to find out it's a real job. He is an Emmy Award winner for his work on Fantasy Football Now and a multiple award winner from the Fantasy Sports Writers Association, including a Writer of the Year award. He is also the creator of RotoPass.com, a Web site that combines a bunch of well-known fantasy sites, including ESPN Insider, for one low price. Use promo code ESPN for 10 percent off.

Cyberstalk the TMR | Be his Cyberfriend

• Senior Fantasy analyst for ESPN
• Member, FSWA and FSTA Halls of Fame
• Best-selling author of "Fantasy Life"

ALSO SEE