ESPN.com award scorecard

Check out ESPN.com's baseball writers would have voted in the major postseason award categories.

Originally Published: November 7, 2003

The following is a rundown of who ESPN.com's baseball writers would have chosen for each of the major postseason awards:

ESPN.com writer AL
Rookie
NL
Rookie
AL
Cy Young
NL
Cy Young
AL
Manager
NL
Manager
AL
MVP
NL
MVP
Peter
Gammons
Angel
Berroa
Dontrelle
Willis
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Felipe
Alou
David
Ortiz
Barry
Bonds
Jayson
Stark
Hideki
Matsui
Brandon
Webb
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Shannon
Stewart
Barry
Bonds
Rob
Neyer
Hideki
Matsui
Scott
Podsednik
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Alex
Rodriguez
Barry
Bonds
Jerry
Crasnick
Angel
Berroa
Dontrelle
Willis
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Jorge
Posada
Albert
Pujols
Jim
Caple
Angel
Berroa
Dontrelle
Willis
Roy
Halladay
Jason
Schmidt
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Jorge
Posada
Barry
Bonds
Buster
Olney
Hideki
Matsui
Dontrelle
Willis
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Alex
Rodriguez
Barry
Bonds
Tim
Kurkjian
Hideki
Matsui
Brandon
Webb
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Nomar
Garciaparra
Barry
Bonds
And the
winner is ...
Angel
Berroa
Dontrelle
Willis
Roy
Halladay
Eric
Gagne
Tony
Pena
Jack
McKeon
Alex
Rodriguez
Barry
Bonds