Breaking down May trades

A breakdown on the prospects involved in trades.

Originally Published: May 28, 2005
Baseball America

Giants, Cubs trade pitchers
May 28: On the same day they placed Mark Prior on the disabled list for what is expected to be 6-8 weeks with an elbow fracture, the Cubs did a little housecleaning as well.

Prospect Handbook
Baseball America The 2005 Prospect Handbook is the definitive annual reference title on prospects. This book profiles the top 30 prospects in each organization – 900 prospect reviews in all. The Prospect Handbook also ranks each organization's talent and provides in-depth analysis of every team's draft. Whether you want to win your fantasy league or just study your team's future stars, the Baseball Prospect Handbook is your guide to success.
  • Click here to buy this book.
  • They dealt much-maligned LaTroy Hawkins to the Giants on Saturday for a pair of former first-round picks, right-handers Jerome Williams and David Aardsma. Chicago also kicked in cash to cover most of what remained of Hawkins' $3.5 million salary for this season.

    Hawkins, 32, had been frequently booed at Wrigley Field this season, with four saves and four losses as the Cubs closer. Signed before the 2004 season to a three-year, $11 million contract after establishing himself as one of the best setup men in baseball with the Twins, Hawkins struggled after being pressed into the closer role in Chicago.

    Armed with a low-to-mid 90s fastball and plus slider, Hawkins can be effective, particularly against right-handers. He can be prone to getting his pitches up in the zone. Hawkins is expected to be used as a set-up man in the Giants bullpen.

    In 21 games this season, he's 1-4 with a 3.32 ERA, allowing 18 hits and four home runs over 19 innings, striking out 13 and walking seven. A 1991 seventh-round pick by Minnesota, Hawkins has a career record of 50-65 with a 4.80 ERA. He has 73 saves in 464 games.

    Williams, 23, was ranked as the Giants' No. 1 prospect in 2001-02, but has struggled this season while recovering from elbow surgery that limited him to just 22 games last season.

    While he broke camp in the big leagues, he was sent down to Triple-A Fresno after going 0-2 with a 6.48 ERA in four games for the Giants. Things have gotten even worse for him in the Pacific Coast League, as he's gone 1-4 with a 9.39 ERA in his first six starts for the Grizzlies, allowing 47 hits in 31 innings while walking more (17) than he has struck out (15).

    When healthy, Williams has command of a low-90s fastball that he uses to set up a very good changeup. He has yet to find a consistent third pitch however, with both his curveball and slider lacking the depth or command to be a consistent out pitch. Williams' conditioning also has come into question. A 1999 supplemental first-round pick out of a Honolulu high school, Williams has a career major league record of 17-14 with a 3.93 ERA in 47 games. He's expected to report to Triple-A Iowa as he continues to attempt to refine his stuff.

    Aardsma, 23, was the Giants' first-round pick in 2003 after serving as the closer for Rice's national championship squad that year. He reached the majors in 2004, but went 1-0 with a 6.75 ERA in 11 games, allowing 20 hits and 10 walks in just 11 innings. Put in the rotation at Double-A Norwich this season in order to get him more innings and allow him to work on his secondary pitches, Aardsma has gone 6-2 with a 2.93 ERA in nine games, allowing 44 hits over 46 innings while walking 13 and striking out 30.

    He has struggled with his mechanics over the last year, and his fastball is now more often in the low 90s as opposed to the 93-97 mph range he showed in college. His slider also has become inconsistent, dropping in terms of both velocity and bite. Aardsma likely will be returned to the bullpen in the Cubs' system, and could be used in the major leagues as early as this year to shore up a mediocre relief corps in Chicago.

    -- Kevin Goldstein

    Nats, Phils exchange centerfielders
    May 14: In a challenge trade of 27-year-old center fielders, the Phillies sent Marlon Byrd to the Nationals for Endy Chavez on Saturday. Both players split time between Triple-A and the majors this season and could benefit simply from a change of scenery.

    Byrd has the higher upside. He appeared to be Philadelphia's long-term solution in center field after finishing fourth in the 2003 National League rookie-of-the-year voting after he hit .303/.366/.418 with seven homers and 45 RBIs in 135 games. But he quickly fell out of favor in 2004, when he hit .228/.287/.321 with five homers and 33 RBIs in 106 games, and spent the first month of this season at Triple-A Scranton. Byrd hasn't made the same consistent hard contact he made in the minors. He's average defensively and on the bases. He's a career .271/.332/.377 hitter in the majors, with 13 homers and 79 RBIs in 256 games.

    While Byrd has one solid season on his big league résumé, Chavez doesn't even have that. Speed is his best tool and he makes good contact, but he doesn't get on-base enough or have enough power to be much of an asset offensively. He hit .277/.318/.371 with five homers, 34 RBIs and 32 steals in 132 games last year. His unwillingness to make offensive adjustments led to his demotion to Triple-A New Orleans for most of 2005. His speed makes him a good defender in center field, and he has a good arm for his position. In 346 big-league games, he has batted .263/.304/.366 with 11 homers, 96 RBIs and 53 steals.

    -- Matt Meyers

    Restovich moves again, this time to Pirates
    May 11: The suddenly well-traveled Michael Restovich now has a new destination -- PNC Park. The Pirates acquired Restovich from the Rockies on Wednesday in exchange for a player to be named later. Pittsburgh becomes his fourth organization in 2005, as the Devil Rays claimed him off waivers from the Twins at the end of March and lost him on waivers to Colorado six days later.

    Restovich, 26, was a second-round pick out of a Minnesota high school in 1997. He ranked in the top five on Baseball America's Twins prospect lists from 1999-2003, but plateaued over the last two seasons as several outfielders in the deep Minnesota system passed him by. Restovich pounds fastballs with a smooth, sound swing, but quality breaking balls give him trouble. He has good power, but doesn't control the strike zone or hit for a high average. He's a good athlete for his size (6-foot-4, 251 pounds) and a competent corner outfielder. He has batted .278/.362/.444 with four homers and 14 RBI in 144 big league at-bats, including 31 with the Rockies this year. Restovich is a career .285/.366/.492 hitter with 128 homers and 558 RBI in 845 minor league games.

    Once the player to be named has been identified, we'll analyze him as well.

    -- Chris Kline

    ALSO SEE