Dowd criticizes Selig's selection of Mitchell

Updated: April 1, 2006, 10:16 PM ET
ESPN.com news services

NEW YORK -- Baseball launched its probe Thursday into alleged steroids use by Barry Bonds and others, and right away the head of the investigation came under attack because of his close ties to the sport.

Buster Olney's Blog
Rather than stand up and take responsibility for how he and others within the institution of baseball failed to lead on the steroid issue, Bud Selig is going to order an investigation of the steroid use of Barry Bonds and others.

Summon the hounds. Sound the horn. Let the hunt for scapegoats begin. Call your publicist, your favorite newspaper columnist, and bring 'em along.

More of Buster Olney's blog Insider
What Selig should have said

In the wake of a searing book about Bonds, commissioner Bud Selig appointed former Senate Majority Leader George Mitchell -- and currently a director of the Boston Red Sox -- to lead the inquiry.

The probe will initially be limited to events since September 2002, when the sport first began testing for performance-enhancing drugs, but Mitchell has the authority to expand it. Selig said Mitchell's report will be made public but didn't set a timetable.

"The goal here is to determine facts, not engage in supposition, speculation, rumor or innuendo," Selig said.

Whatever the findings, it will be hard to penalize anyone for conduct before the steroids ban. Baseball began drug testing in 2003 and started testing with penalties the following year.

At San Francisco's home ballpark, Bonds wouldn't discuss the matter.

"I said no, no, no," he said, shaking his head.

"I'm going to jump off the Empire State Building -- flat on my face," he added, laughing.

Mitchell, meanwhile, said he will not resign his position with the Red Sox. He is also chairman of The Walt Disney Co., the parent of ESPN, a national broadcast partner of baseball.

"I don't think there's any conflict," he said in a telephone interview with The Associated Press. "I'm going to be independent, have complete independent authority and will act."

ESPN is airing a weekly behind-the-scenes look at Bonds -- with the San Francisco star's cooperation -- starting next week.

Along with working for the Red Sox, Mitchell is a former director of the Florida Marlins and served on an economic study committee Selig appointed in 1999. He said he previously announced he would leave the Disney board by the end of the year.

"I've assured the Red Sox owners that should any matter arise, anybody affiliated with the Red Sox will be treated exactly as will anyone else," he said.

George Mitchell Biography
Born: Aug. 20, 1933

Education: Graduated from Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine, 1954; graduated, Georgetown University Law Center, Washington, D.C., 1960

Senate service: 1980-95; Democrat
•  Appointed on May 17, 1980, to the U.S. Senate to fill the vacancy caused by the resignation of Edmund S. Muskie.
•  Reelected in 1982 and again in 1988.
•  Chairman, Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (99th Congress).
•  Co-chairman, Democratic Policy Committee, Democratic Conference (100th through 103rd Congresses)
•  Senate majority leader (1989-1995)

Professional experience:
•  Chairman of the Board of the Walt Disney Company since March 2004
•  Director of the Boston Red Sox
•  Chairman of the law firm of DLA Piper Rudnick Gray Cary LLP.
•  Previously served as Chairman of the law firm of Verner, Liipfert, Bernhard, McPherson & Hand in Washington, D.C., which merged with Piper Rudnick in October 2002.
•  Director of Staples, Inc.
•  Chairman of the Peace Negotiations in Northern Ireland and the International Fact-Finding Committee on Violence in the Middle East.

Also:
•  Awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom on March 17, 1999.

ABC News' Stephanopoulos: Who is George Mitchell?

John Dowd, the Washington lawyer who headed baseball's investigation of Pete Rose's gambling in 1989, did not like the choice.

"Mitchell doesn't have a great track record with me. It doesn't look like he's independent," Dowd said.

Sen. Jim Bunning, a Kentucky Republican and baseball Hall of Famer, also criticized Mitchell.

"While George Mitchell is certainly a man of great integrity, I believe that baseball would have been wiser to pick someone who is not as close to the game and may be able to take a more objective look into the facts," Bunning said.

Rep. Henry Waxman, a California Democrat who helped lead a congressional hearing last year on steroids in baseball, praised the probe.

"This is precisely what I had asked MLB to do last year," he said. "Finding out the truth about the depth and breadth of this problem is the only way to close the book on this sad chapter of the game's history."

Selig's decision came soon after "Game of Shadows," a book by two San Francisco Chronicle reporters detailing alleged extensive steroid use by Bonds and other baseball stars.

"I believe the timing on this proper given the charges, given the specificity of the charges for the first time," Selig said.

Mitchell will be assisted by Jeffrey Collins and Thomas Carlucci of Foley & Lardner -- the law firm of Bob DuPuy, baseball's chief operating officer -- and Charles Scheeler, a former federal prosecutor currently at Mitchell's law firm, DLA Piper Rudnick Gray Cary. Collins is a former U.S. Attorney and Carlucci a former assistant U.S. attorney.

"Should Sen. Mitchell uncover material suggesting that the scope of this investigation needs to be broader, he has my permission to expand the investigation and to follow the evidence wherever it may lead," Selig said.

DuPuy said baseball considered Mitchell's potential conflicts of interest.

"Given Sen. Mitchell's integrity, given his background, he was absolutely considered to be the perfect choice for this job," he said.

DuPuy said baseball had the power to force players to cooperate.

"My hope is that others will see it as we do, that it's in the best interests of baseball and the individuals to be forthcoming, but I can't predict," Mitchell said.

A source told The New York Daily News that Bonds will not cooperate with baseball's investigation.

The Giants organization, however, said that they support the commissioner's initiative.

"As we have said all along, the Giants support the commissioner's decision to review all aspects of what is obviously a serious matter," the team said. "We commend the selection of George Mitchell to head up this investigation and we pledge our full support to the commissioner, Senator Mitchell and his team."

New York Yankees first baseman Jason Giambi, who like Bonds testified before a federal grand jury in 2003, said he'd have "no problems" with an inquiry.

"I did the things I needed to do, took care of it and played last year and have just gone forward. I'm not really worried about it," he said.

Teammate Gary Sheffield also testified and said of his cooperation: "If I have to, I will. I'm going to do whatever the law expects me to do, but other than that it's a waste of my time."

In a 1980 case involving pitcher Ferguson Jenkins, arbitrator Ray Goetz curtailed the commissioner's power to order cooperation.

"Arbitrators have been reluctant to allow compelled, potentially self-incriminating testimony," Selig said. "The investigatory authority of Major League Baseball, therefore, is particularly limited when the allegations relate to conduct that can create or has created a risk of criminal prosecution for the player."

Selig would not address possible discipline that could result from the investigation.

"When this investigation is over ... that will be the time for me to make those kind of judgments," he said.

ESPN has learned that Bonds and any other current player who may be part of this investigation will be allowed to play while the investigation is ongoing.

Bonds enters the season with 708 homers, trailing only Babe Ruth (714) and Hank Aaron (755) on the career list.

"I assume physical constraints notwithstanding, Bonds will play the whole year," DuPuy said.

Selig would not discuss whether baseball would commemorate Bonds' pursuit of the home run record.

"We'll work those out in the coming weeks," he said.

More on the Probe and Bonds
Pedro Gomez reports on the planned steroid investigaton and reactions from the Bonds Camp.
• Watch Video

ESPN takes an in-depth look at Barry Bonds. Jeremy Schapp reports on Bonds' childhood in the first of a three-part series.
• Watch Video

Earlier Thursday, Victor Conte -- founder of the Bay Area Laboratory Co-Operative -- was released from a California prison. He spent four months there after pleading guilty to orchestrating an illegal steroids distribution scheme that allegedly involved many high-profile athletes.

Asked whether he gave Bonds steroids, Conte said: "No, I did not."

"I plan to provide evidence in the near future to prove that much of what is written in the book is untrue," Conte told the AP. He declined to list specific inaccuracies or what evidence he would provide but said, "It's about the character assassination of Barry Bonds and myself."

Union head Donald Fehr and chief operating officer Gene Orza did not respond to e-mails seeking comment.

Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.