Ruling to come Friday on AP request for names in Grimsley case
PHOENIX -- A federal magistrate judge planned to rule Friday on an application by The Associated Press to have prosecutors reveal the names of players allegedly implicated in drug use by former major league pitcher Jason Grimsley.
During a hearing Thursday at federal court in Phoenix, Major League Baseball Players Association lawyer Ethan Balogh called the AP's attempt to make the names public a "craven search for the sensational and the morbid, nothing more.''
Balogh argued that to reveal the names would violate the players' right to privacy and unfairly brand them even though they have not been charged with any wrongdoing.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward C. Voss closely questioned the attorney representing the AP on why revealing the names would be in the public good and override other legal considerations.
Voss said he had received a sealed affidavit from lead prosecutor Jeff Nedrow outlining the status of the investigation, which authorities say goes far beyond the Grimsley case. Voss acknowledged AP lawyer Peter Kozinets was "handcuffed'' because he had no access to that affidavit.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Matt Parrella said revealing the names could negatively impact an ongoing investigation.
"As Yogi Berra said, 'It ain't over 'til it's over,' "' Parrella said in summing up his case.
The names don't really add anything. It's the facts that are important, at least to me.
-- U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward C. Voss
Voss indicated there would be an appeal regardless of his decision, noting that he expected other judges to eventually rule on the case.
"I wish them well,'' he said.
The AP request is aimed at a sworn statement signed in May 2006 by IRS Special Agent Jeff Novitzky. The affidavit was used for a search warrant for Grimsley's Arizona home, and when the document was made public by prosecutors, names of the players Novitzky said were implicated by Grimsley were blacked out.
David Segui told ESPN in June 2006 that he was one of the blacked-out names. The Los Angeles Times reported last October that Roger Clemens, Andy Pettitte, Miguel Tejada, Brian Roberts and Jay Gibbons also were named.
Players in the Times report denied using steroids, and Randy Hendricks, the agent for Clemens and Pettitte, said he was told Grimsley denied making the statements attributed to him by Novitzky. Grimsley has not commented publicly, and Kevin Ryan, then the U.S. Attorney in San Francisco, said the Times report contained "significant inaccuracies.''
Voss mentioned the Times report on Clemens. Clemens, the judge said, had no legal forum to dispute the charge.
"All he can say is 'It's not true,' " Voss said.
Kozinets argued that the public should have full access to the entire affidavit to be able to make sure the case is being handled fairly. He alluded to concern that the federal government may be providing information to baseball steroids investigator George Mitchell in return for favored treatment of some of those involved.
Kozinets said that he assumes the players named in the affidavit have been contacted by a federal investigator, and would have the right to contest their involvement as part of their regular contact with the press. But Voss wondered why the names are important to public knowledge of the case.
"The names don't really add anything,'' the judge said. "It's the facts that are important, at least to me.''
Parrella said the Grimsley probe was an outgrowth of the initial investigation of the Bay Area Laboratory Co-Operative. He said that probe goes beyond baseball to include track and field and professional football.
In a similar case in New York, lawyers for Hearst Corp. contended this week that federal prosecutors provided Mitchell the names of players implicated in drug use by former New York Mets clubhouse employee Kirk Radomski.
The Hearst lawyers say the names of up to 23 players mentioned in Novitzky's affidavit in that case should be made public if they have been provided to Mitchell.
Copyright 2007 by The Associated Press
• Players' union files grievance on Guillen's behalf
• Mitchell Report due next week
• Guillen, Gibbons suspended 15 days
• Chart: Players who have violated MLB policy
• Sources: HGH suspension in works for Guillen
• Angels owner: Mitchell report will include names
• HBO to turn Bonds steroids book into movie
• BALCO figures fear leaks
• Personal trainer pleads guilty to distribution
• Union: 11 free agents sought in Mitchell talks
• China promises to bust doping industry
• Radomski's sentencing delayed until December
• Matthews Jr. discusses HGH allegations with MLB
• Report: Guillen, Williams bought steroids
• Top lawyer defends MLB testing procedures
• Report: Teams get advance notice of drug tests
• Indians' Byrd admits to using HGH
• NY raid nets $7.2 million in growth hormone
• Union: Mitchell didn't offer to share evidence
• Report: Mitchell gets papers from ex-Mets aide
• Sources: Mitchell's report to reveal many names
• MLB may suspend players who got banned drugs
• Source: Schoeneweis received steroids shipments
• DEA pulls off series of steroid raids
• ESPN The Magazine: China's open drug supply
• Ankiel meets with MLB officials on HGH report
• Report: MLB eyes use of HGH blood test in '08
• Gibbons meets with MLB officials
• Albany sits down with Mitchell Commission reps
• MLB considers adding fertility drugs to banned list
• MLB wants D.A.'s cooperation in pharmacy probe
• MLB requests meeting with Gibbons
• Report: Orioles' Gibbons received steroids, HGH
• Report: Pharmacy shipped steroids to Glaus
• Report: Ankiel linked to HGH | Gammons
• Olney blog: 1998 all over again?
• Harrison cooperated with prosecutors
• Harrison suspended for four games by NFL
• Report: Ex-MLB clubhouse man names names
• Fla. man pleads guilty to steroid sales conspiracy
• Judge denies request to release names in Grimsley case
• Report: Feds provided players names to Mitchell
• Feds: Mitchell got incomplete affidavit
• Ex-BALCO prosecutor says probe could end soon
• Sports leaders, feds discuss fight against steroids
• O's quiet as steroids speculation spins
• Mitchell seeks medical records
• Former doc guilty in prescription scam
From The Archives• The Dope On Steroids
• Mets did little to discourage steroid use
• E-Ticket: Who knew?
Analysis• Howard Bryant: Steroids, HGH and the pennant races
• Buster Olney: Blood test request on horizon
• Jayson Stark: Applying double standards
• Buster Olney: 1998 all over again?
• Rob Neyer: No big deal
• Ankiel timeline
• Peter Gammons: Stuff of legend