Day 4: Rounds 16-20

Updated: February 5, 2009, 12:59 PM ET
ESPN.com

The economy is impacting everyone, baseball included. Teams are looking to build more cost-conscious rosters. But how? Is it doable? Are there enough talented, relatively inexpensive players to build a competitive roster for, say, $40 million, which is roughly the payroll the San Diego Padres hope to operate at in 2009?

Well, ESPN.com put four of its experts on the case.

Over a recent five-day stretch, Baseball Tonight's Steve Phillips, ESPN The Magazine's Buster Olney and ESPN.com's Jayson Stark and Rob Neyer drafted their own 25-man rosters.

All this week, we reveal their selections -- and their thoughts on each other's selections. On Monday, Feb. 9, the four teams will begin going head-to-head in seven-game series conducted by ImagineSports.com, which provides online simulation baseball games, using its Diamond Mind Baseball software. Our ultimate general manager will pit his budget-conscious team against the deep-pocketed New York Yankees in a seven-game series.

On Day 1, some spent, some saved. On Day 2, the guys lined up for pitching. On Day 3, well, everyone kept a close eye on Steve's payroll. Now, though, as the rosters fill out, concentration on picks has gone up. And, yes, Buster is spending, Jayson still loves everyone's team, Rob is keeping the field off balance and Steve, believe it or not, still hasn't gone over his $40 million allotment.