All-Star matchup: Watch for Pujols vs. Halladay

Updated: July 13, 2009

Jerry Lai/US Presswire

Nelson Cruz, the runner-up in the Home Run Derby, could surprise in Tuesday's All-Star Game as well.

The American League has been dominant in recent years in the All-Star Game. In fact, the AL hasn't lost since 1996. Most of the wins have been close, and last year's 15-inning affair in New York obviously could have gone either way. But for some reason the AL keeps winning. It's hard to pinpoint why that is, but the AL pitching is a key. I expect that trend to continue this year.

Looking at the two teams, the AL roster has the more dominating closers in Jonathan Papelbon, Mariano Rivera, Joe Nathan and Brian Fuentes. They are harder throwers, while the National League pitchers are typically finesse-type guys who might not be as accustomed to entering the game in a relief role. That shouldn't be overlooked. We all know good pitching beats good hitting. The National League has plenty of great hitters, but the AL pitching has just been a bit better. And that's still the case.

All-Star Game The National League lineup will be centered around Albert Pujols -- for good reason. NL manager Charlie Manuel will try to get him three at bats. That will be no small feat, considering three other first basemen are on the NL roster, and there is no DH slot. Baseball should start using the DH in All-Star Games, even in National League parks. It'd be an obvious way for teams to get more hitters into the game.

The NL could struggle some Tuesday night. Carlos Beltran will be out of the lineup due to injury, while Raul Ibanez, another big bat, was hurt for a while and is likely to get only one or two at-bats. The American League lineup looks a little more loaded. With the possible exception of fan favorite Josh Hamilton, all the AL players have been red-hot.

One matchup I'm looking forward to watching is Roy Halladay versus Pujols. Because big players rise to the occasion in big spots, I expect Pujols to do that against Halladay in his home park. But another guy to keep an eye on is Rangers outfielder Nelson Cruz, who did so well in the Home Run Derby on Monday night. He was named as a replacement for Torii Hunter but hasn't received his due yet, and this could be a chance for Cruz to become more of a household name. At age 29, he developed a little bit later than some expected, but he is a quality power hitter. He has 22 home runs this season, more than any other AL outfielder. He can really ambush you on that first pitch. If someone tries to just lay one in there to start his at-bat, he will hit it out. National League pitchers, beware; he leads the league with 11 first-pitch home runs.

Finally, there are two guys I'll be watching with a smile. Tim Wakefield and Ibanez are both longtime veterans making their All-Star debuts, and they'll both be embracing their opportunity on Tuesday.

Past Baseball Tonight Clubhouses: July 12 | July 9 | July 8 | July 7 | July 6

TOUCH 'EM ALL

Touch 'Em AllWith no games Monday, no one went deep, except for those participating in the Home Run Derby (well, besides Brandon Inge). So with the 80th All-Star Game set to be played Tuesday, here's a look back at the last 10 home runs hit in All-Star competition.

For more on the home run leaders this season, check out the Home Run Tracker page.

Home Run Tracker
YEAR NAME OPP PITCHER SITUATION
2008J.D. Drew, BOSNLE. VolquezBot 7: 1 on, 2 outs
2008Matt Holliday, COLALE. SantanaTop 5: 0 on, 0 out
2007Alfonso Soriano, CHCALJ.J. PutzBot 9: 1 on, 2 outs
2007Victor Martinez, CLENLB. WagnerTop 8: 1 on , 2 outs
2007Carl Crawford, TAMNLF. CorderoTop 6: 0 on, 2 outs
2007Ichiro Suzuki, SEANLC. YoungTop 5: 1 on, 1 out
2006David Wright, NYMALK. RogersBottom 2: 0 on, 1 out
2006Vladimir Guerrero, LAANLB. PennyTop 2: 0 on, 1 out
2005Andruw Jones, ATLALK. RogersTop 7: 1 on, 0 out
2005Mark Teixeira, TEXNLD. WillisBot 6: 1 on, 0 out


ESPN Conversation

BBTN ON THE AIR: TUESDAY

TIME WHO'S ON?
7 p.m. ET
ESPN
Host: Steve Berthiaume
Analysts: John Kruk, Chris Singleton, Eduardo Perez, Tim Kurkjian, Peter Gammons
12 a.m. ET
ESPN
Host: Steve Berthiaume
Analysts: John Kruk, Chris Singleton, Eduardo Perez, Tim Kurkjian, Peter Gammons

BBTN: ALL-STAR GAME PREVIEW

SIMON SAYS

Simon Says ESPN researcher Mark Simon digs deep, looking for the night's best baseball numbers.

Tonight, he looks at the Home Run Derby champions since 2003 and how they fared in the All-Star Game the next day:

HR Derby Champ
In All-Star Game since 2003
2009 Prince Fielder ?
2008 Justin Morneau 2-4, 2 R
2007 Vladimir Guerrero 0-3
2006 Ryan Howard 0-1
2005 Bobby Abreu 1-2
2004 Miguel Tejada 0-1
2003 *Garret Anderson 3-4, HR, 2 RBI
* -- Won MVP

MONDAY'S BEST AND WORST

BEST
There could be only one winner of the Home Run Derby, and this year it was Prince Fielder. The Brewers' slugger pounded out 11 homers in the first round, tying Nelson Cruz for the first-round lead. Two hours later, he outdueled Cruz in the final, winning 6-5.
WORST
Brandon Inge might not take away too many pleasant memories of his Home Run Derby experience. The Tigers' third baseman became the fourth hitter this decade to record zero home runs in the Derby, joining Jason Bay (2005), Bret Boone (2003) and Troy Glaus (2001).

BBTN: MIDSEASON AWARDS

NUMBERS TO KNOW: HE'S NO AVERAGE JOE

Joe Mauer Minnesota's Joe Mauer leads the league with a .373 batting average, but the left-hander is also second and third in OBP and slugging (.447 and .622 respectively). The catcher has helped the Twins stay competitive in the AL Central with a well-rounded performance.

It doesn't matter what pitch you throw Mauer, he hits all pitches high above the league average. He is No. 1 in the majors versus fastballs.

And pitchers better not get behind in the count against Mauer. He is hitting an amazing .581 when the pitcher is behind in the count (1-0, 2-0, 2-1, 3-0, 3-1).

Mauer vs. pitches and counts, 2009 season
Mauer 2008-09
Fastball .403 .283
Curveball .292 .211
Slider .286 .221
Changeup .364 .245
Pitcher Ahead .265 .203
Pitcher Behind .581 .343

-- ESPN Stats & Information