Edgar Martinez
DH, Seattle Mariners
1995 ALDS, Games 4 and 5

In their first-ever postseason appearance, the Mariners topped the Yanks thanks to Gar's two home runs in Game 4 and a game-winning (and series-winning) double in the bottom of the 11th in Game 5. For the series, Martinez hit .571 with 10 RBI.

SportsNation: Vote on the best playoff performances

Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images