TORONTO -- The Seattle Mariners couldn't come through in the clutch Sunday, and it cost them.
The Mariners went 0 for 14 with runners in scoring position and have not won a series north of the border since June 2008.
"We didn't play very well all day," Seattle manager Eric Wedge said. "I didn't feel like we were giving away at-bats, but the end result of at-bats wasn't very good."
Jeff Mathis added a two-run homer as Toronto broke open a close game with a five-run eighth inning.
Seattle put at least one runner at second or third base in each of the first, second, fourth, sixth, seven and ninth innings but failed to cash any of them in.
"We got the runners on, we just couldn't push them across," Figgins said.
Scoring runs wasn't easy against Alvarez (1-2), who allowed one run and six hits in six-plus innings to win for the second time in 15 major league starts. The right-hander, whose only other victory came at Baltimore last Aug. 31, walked a career-high three and struck out one.
"We had some good hacks at him but he started changing speeds, started taking something off his fastball," Figgins said. "I think he saw that we were seeing his pitches and started taking a lot off his fastball."
The Mariners jumped in front early when Figgins drilled Alvarez's sixth pitch of the game over the wall in right, his second leadoff shot this season.
"I broke back," Figgins said. "I felt bad that (Vargas) was going so good and had a no-hitter going for me to break back. (Thames) took a big swing, he was up in the count. I didn't know he hit it off the end of the bat."
The hit moved Encarnacion, who had walked, up to third base, but Vargas escaped when Figgins caught Lawrie's fly ball for the third out.
The Blue Jays broke through against Vargas in the fifth. Rasmus led off with a single, advanced to second on a grounder and scored on a two-out base hit to right by Kelly Johnson.
Encarnacion had a solo homer in Toronto's 9-5 defeat Friday and hit his fourth career grand slam in Saturday's 7-0 win. He went deep again in the finale, lacing a tiebreaking drive to left in the sixth off Vargas. Encarnacion's homer was his team-leading seventh.
"Unfortunately, probably one of the only bad changeups I threw all night was to him and it was the difference in the game," Vargas said.
Encarnacion, who walked in his first two plate appearances Sunday, was hit on the left arm by Steve Delabar in the eighth, responding with a long stare at the mound.
"I can't say whether that pitch got away from them intentionally or what," Blue Jays manager John Farrell said. "But we answered the right way."
Charlie Furbush replaced Delabar before Jose Bautista, who had led off with a single, and Encarnacion pulled off a double steal. Pinch hitter Rajai Davis was intentionally walked before Brett Lawrie hit a two-run double. One batter later, Davis scored on an errant pickoff throw by Olivo. Colby Rasmus struck out before Mathis homered into the second deck in left, his second.
Davis injured his right wrist diving back to third on Olivo's throw and left the game. He was replaced by Ben Francisco in the ninth.
Figgins also hit a leadoff homer in Seattle's 4-1 win at Cleveland on April 18. ... Seattle announced that LH George Sherrill will undergo season-ending elbow surgery on May 4. Sherrill appeared in two games this year. ... Mariners SS Brendan Ryan, stuck in an 0 for 18 slump, was replaced in the lineup by Munenori Kawasaki. 1B Justin Smoak ( 2 for 27) also got the day off. Both are expected to start Monday at Tampa Bay.