Series: Game 1 of 3

Philadelphia leads 1-0 (as of 5/21)

Game 1: Friday, May 21
San Diego4Final
Game 2: Saturday, May 22
San Diego9Final
Game 3: Sunday, May 23
San Diego4Final

Padres 4

(23-19, 10-10 away)

Phillies 5

(23-17, 11-7 home)

7:05 PM ET, May 21, 2004

Citizens Bank Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 

123456789 R H E
SD 002020000 4 8 0
PHI 01000022 - 5 7 0

W: R. Madson (3-1)

L: A. Otsuka (3-2)

S: T. Worrell (4)

Fill-in second baseman has made his mark

PHILADELPHIA (AP) -- Chase Utley may not return to the minors if he keeps playing the way he has this year.

Utley had three hits and three RBI, including a go-ahead single in the eighth inning that capped a comeback from a three-run deficit and led the Philadelphia Phillies over the San Diego Padres 5-4 Friday night.

Utley homered for the second straight game and is 11-for-37 with three homers and 13 RBI in 10 games since his recall from the minors.

With Opening Day second-baseman Placido Polanco set to come off the disabled list on Sunday, the Phillies must decide what to do with the hot-hitting Utley.

"I'm not going to answer questions about that until we have to make a roster move," said Phillies manager Larry Bowa, who then added, "Don't forget what Polanco did last year (.289, 14 HRs, 63 RBI). You go on the disabled list, you don't lose your job.

"Utley's going to be a very good baseball player. He is right now. But I'm not going to go into what we're going to do."

Utley will at least make Bowa's decision difficult, having provided much more offense than Polanco's one RBI in 112 at-bats this season.

"Right now, I have a great opportunity to help this team win," Utley said.

David Bell also homered for the Phillies.

Ryan Madson (3-1) pitched a hitless eighth inning, and Tim Worrell finished for his fourth save in six chances. After Terrence Long doubled with one out and advanced on Kerry Robinson's groundout, Mark Loretta hit a game-ending grounder to Worrell.

Brian Giles homered for the second straight night and had three RBI for San Diego.

With the Phillies trailing 4-3 in the eighth, Jimmy Rollins drew a two-out walk, stole his team-high 10th base and scored on Bobby Abreu's triple off Akinori Otsuka (3-2). Pat Burrell walked, and Utley then singled to left to knock in the go-ahead run.

Otsuka had given up only two runs in 20 2-3 innings entering Friday.

"The bullpen's done a good job all year. It just didn't happen tonight," San Diego manager Bruce Bochy said.

Former Phillie Adam Eaton, who has never beaten Philadelphia, allowed two runs and four hits in six-plus innings.

"I could have went farther, but you know how things go," Eaton said. "The past few starts, I've struggled, so get me out of there with a good situation and good mind frame."

Phillies starter Kevin Millwood tied a season-high with seven strikeouts but gave up four runs and seven hits in six innings.

Utley hit a 448-foot homer in the second, the first to land in the visitor's bullpen beyond right field at Citizens Bank Park.

"That's pretty much everything I have," Utley said.

Giles's eighth homer, a two-run drive, put San Diego ahead 2-1 in the third. Giles added an RBI groundout in the fifth and Phil Nevin followed with a double off Abreu in right to make it 4-1.

After Utley's homer, Eaton retired 14 of 16 batters. Utley hit an RBI double in the seventh, then was thrown out trying to advance by catcher Ramon Hernandez. Four pitches later, Bell homered off Scott Linebrink to cut the Padres' lead to one.

"I can't fault a guy for being aggressive," Bowa said of Utley's baserunning blunder. "That's how he plays. That's why they call him 'Dirtball.' "

Game notes

Phillies 1B Jim Thome missed his third straight game with a sprained index finger. ... Loretta scored a pair runs to push his team-leading total to 30. ... Sean Burroughs was caught stealing in the fourth, but was successful in the eight for his team-high fourth stolen base of the year. ... Before Abreu's triple, the top four hitters in the Phillies' lineup combined to go 0-for-12. ... RHP Rod Beck returned to the Padres after missing two months because of personal reasons. He did not pitch. ... After the game, the Phillies optioned RHP Geoff Geary to Triple-A Scranton Wilkes-Barre to make room on the roster for Saturday's starter, Josh Hancock, who was recalled.

Copyright by STATS LLC and The Associated Press