DENVER -- Weeks after scoring a publicity coup with a
30-second Super Bowl ad featuring Heisman Trophy winner Tim Tebow,
conservative Christian group Focus on the Family is at the center
of another marketing tug-of-war -- this time involving the major
governing body of college sports.
The National Collegiate Athletic Association removed a Focus on
the Family banner ad from one of its Web sites this week, NCAA
spokesman Bob Williams said Wednesday.
The NCAA made the decision after some of its members - including
faculty and athletic directors -- expressed concern that the
evangelical group's stance against gay and lesbian relationships
conflicted with the NCAA's policy of inclusion regardless of sexual
orientation, Williams said.
The ad in question was not about sexuality. It featured a father
holding his son and the words, "All I want for my son is for him
to grow up knowing how to do the right thing." Like the Tebow ad,
it included the address of Focus on the Family's Web site and the
slogan, "Celebrate Family. Celebrate Life."
Focus on the Family spokesman Gary Schneeberger said that if
such material were "all of a sudden labeled hate speech, we have
deeper problems in our country than we even know."
Williams said the decision to pull the ad was based not on the
message but on the messenger.
Advertisers "should be generally supportive of NCAA values and
attributes and/or not be in conflict with the NCAA's mission and
fundamental principles," according to NCAA standards. The NCAA may
exclude ads or advertisers "that do not appear to be in the best
interests of higher education and student athletes."
The NCAA Web site is maintained by CBS Sports, and the ad was
part of Focus on the Family's Super Bowl contract with CBS,
Schneeberger said. CBS sells ads to support the NCAA.com site --
which features information about NCAA championships -- and the NCAA
reviews the ads, Williams said.
He said the ad was reviewed and the content did not raise any
red flags. Williams said he was sure there was some discussion of
Focus on the Family, as well, but he did not know the details.
Schneeberger said there is nothing political, controversial or
hateful about the ad, saying it's meant to urge people enduring
life challenges to check out Focus on the Family as a resource.
But Pat Griffin, a retired University of Massachusetts Amherst
professor who is a consultant to the NCAA on gay and lesbian
issues, said it's not a generic feel-good message.
She said the slogan's "life" reference is anti-abortion, and
celebrating families does not extend to all families but "a very
specific kind of family - heterosexual married families. A large
part of their energy goes to preventing other kinds of families of
Griffin said it's one thing for CBS to accept such an ad, but
it's different for the NCAA.
"It's not the right image or role for the NCAA to be endorsing
an organization that has such an extreme right-wing Christian
political mission," said Griffin, who used her blog to protest the
Schneeberger said Focus on the Family spends 90 percent of its
budget on providing parenting and marriage resources and 10 percent
on advocacy on issues such as abortion and gay marriage.
The Tebow Super Bowl ad -- featuring the football player and his
mother -- attracted protests even before it aired from women's
groups that suspected it would feature an explicit anti-abortion
The ad featured Tebow's mother talking about how she nearly lost
her son during pregnancy and ended with Tebow tackling his mother
and the pair joking they have to be "tough" to endure their