Memphis says it should keep '07-08 wins
MEMPHIS, Tenn. -- Memphis says it should keep the victories from the 2007-08 season, which ended in the national title game, after an internal investigation turned up no proof that a former men's basketball player cheated on his SAT exam.
Why ETS investigates test scores
A spokesman for Educational Testing Services, a nonprofit company that develops, administers and scores tests, told ESPN.com on Tuesday that it cannot consider canceling a score unless it has at least two pieces of evidence. Evidence includes handwriting comparisons, comparisons to people seated nearby for evidence of cheating or substantial jumps in scores.
"We can end up investigating a score for any number of reasons," said the spokesman, Tom Ewing. "For instance, we get tips from people that so-and-so cheated. Or we get reports from proctors at our test centers as they're taking notes. Also large score gains alert us. Sixty years of administering this test show that, at most, scores go up 10 or 15 points, not 100.
"If we investigate, we meet with the school officials and we interview the student-athlete in question and then get into the diagnostic of the test.
"The important thing here is we can't cancel a test on one piece of evidence. Like, for example, if someone copied we'd have to have a report from a school official and then verify it with a handwriting example. There has to be two pieces of evidence.
"A tip only gets the ball rolling. We cannot cancel a score on any tip, anonymous or otherwise.
"Cancellations don't happen very often. We administer three million SATs per year. We'd get questions, I'd guess, on 2,000. Of those 2,000, we probably clear at least half or more, so this is not common at all."
"When you're investigating a test score that people want to submit for college, you don't want to take a lot of time but at the same time you don't want to jump to conclusions. I'd say it's an average of four weeks."
-- Dana O'Neil, ESPN.com
"Certainly, the University of Memphis should not suffer a financial penalty or vacation of records for the 2008 NCAA tournament as a result of this allegation," according to a report detailing the school's investigation into NCAA allegations.
The report, released to The Associated Press and other news outlets Tuesday under a public records request, details Memphis' internal probe into accusations that a former player -- widely reported to be Derrick Rose -- allowed a stand-in to take his SAT. The report also looked into charges of grade tampering on behalf of the player.
Most names in the report released Tuesday were redacted by Memphis because of privacy concerns, but multiple sources have told ESPN.com that representatives of Rose did tell Memphis he took the SAT in question.
Rose, the No. 1 pick in the 2008 NBA draft and the league's rookie of the year, was the point guard for the Memphis team that won an NCAA-record 38 games before losing to Kansas in the national championship game.
School officials argue that even if the NCAA Committee on Infractions believes a former player cheated, the program should not be penalized because the school was unaware of any wrongdoing.
"At this point, there is not sufficient evidence on which to conclude that [the player] knew or should have known that he was ineligible at the time of his participation in the NCAA championship," the report says.
Memphis will present its findings to the Committee on Infractions on Saturday in Indianapolis. Former coach John Calipari, now with Kentucky, is expected to participate by phone.
The report released Tuesday says that school officials have encouraged the player -- whose name was blacked out -- to cooperate with the NCAA investigation but that his "consistent response" is that he took the test and already answered the same questions in 2007.
Rose's attorney, Daniel E. Reidy, did not immediately respond to a message left Tuesday at his office.
The report also says the school had no proof the SAT was fraudulent until notified by the Educational Testing Service that the player's score had been canceled. That letter came May 5, 2008, after Rose's only season at Memphis.
When asked directly about the tests he was reported to have taken, the report says, the player responded that he took each of them himself. The player "did not pursue any of the opportunities made available to him by ETS to attempt to validate his scores. The first notice of these opportunities was sent very late in the basketball season. At this point, there is not sufficient evidence on which to conclude that he knew or should have known that he was ineligible at the time of his participation in the NCAA championship.
"The university took all reasonable steps to confirm that [name redacted] had met eligibility requirements," the report states.
Memphis' response to NCAA in the case involving its men's basketball and women's golf teams. Read the complete PDF.
-- Credit: Memphis Commercial Appeal
Memphis officials first began to look into the player's test score in October 2007, when a public school employee in the player's home city contacted the university about possible grade tampering.
The school says the only proof of a fraudulent test score comes from a forensic document examiner hired by the NCAA to look at the player's handwriting samples. She was only able to say that the player's handwriting "probably" did not match the handwriting on the test. The university says the expert's conclusion is not strong enough to prove the player knowingly cheated on the exam.
Memphis athletic director R.C. Johnson declined to speak with The Associated Press through a spokeswoman. He has said the school checks out potential athletes but has refused to detail such efforts.
Kentucky officials were aware of the allegations when they hired Calipari and believe the coach was open and honest about the situation. Johnson interviewed several high-profile coaches when Calipari left, but couldn't lure them to Memphis. So he turned to 31-year-old Calipari assistant Josh Pastner.
Pastner, who has said he knew nothing about the investigation before being hired, was excused from participation because of a previous commitment.
NCAA officials notified Memphis on Jan. 16 of the "knowing fraudulence or misconduct" that occurred in that same 2007-08 season, including alleging that Memphis provided $2,260 in free travel to road games for an associate of a player. The NCAA is charging Memphis with a failure to monitor.
Calipari, who left Memphis and signed an eight-year, $31.65 million contract with Kentucky on March 31, has been assured by the NCAA that he is not under investigation.
Rose has issued a statement through Reidy, his attorney, and won't comment any further on the investigation.
On Monday, Bulls executive vice president for business operations Steve Schanwald said the team stood by Rose.
"Where the truth lies, who knows?" Schanwald told Comcast SportsNet Chicago. "But Derrick says it didn't happen, and I take him at his word."
Information from ESPN.com senior writer Andy Katz and The Associated Press was used in this report.
MORE MEN'S COLLEGE BASKETBALL HEADLINES
- No. 24 San Diego St. rallies by Washington
- Buffs' buzzer-beater stuns No. 6 Jayhawks
- McConnell, No. 2 Wildcats squeak by UNLV
- Mizzou upsets UCLA, extends home streak