Marquis Wright scored 19 points to lead Wiley (7-6), an NAIA team. No other player reached double figures for the Wildcats.
Stephen F. Austin trailed 7-6 before taking the lead for good with a 12-0 run. The Lumberjacks increased their advantage to 39-23 at halftime and led by 38 in the second half.
Cutler was 5 of 6 from the floor, helping the Lumberjacks shot 53.6 percent, and 6 of 6 from the foul line.