| Scoring Summary |
| FIRST QUARTER | CIN | USF |
 | TD | 0:08 | MIKE DANIELS 2 YD PASS FROM GINO GUIDUGLI (CHRIS MANFREDINI KICK) Drive info: 15 plays, 76 yards. | 7 | 0 |
| THIRD QUARTER | CIN | USF |
 | TD | 7:34 | ELGIN HICKS 36 YD PASS FROM PAT JULMISTE (SANTIAGO GRAMATICA KICK) Drive info: 10 plays, 64 yards. | 7 | 7 |
| FG | 3:54 | CHET ERVIN 38 YD FG Drive info: 11 plays, 59 yards. | 10 | 7 |
| FOURTH QUARTER | CIN | USF |
| FG | 3:33 | SANTIAGO GRAMATICA 30 YD FG Drive info: 12 plays, 39 yards. | 10 | 10 |
| OVERTIME | CIN | USF |
| TD | 0:00 | DENNIS HART 25 YD PASS FROM GINO GUIDUGLI (CHRIS MANFREDINI KICK) Drive info: 2 plays, 25 yards. | 17 | 10 |
| TD | 0:00 | BRIAN FISHER 4 YD RUN (SANTIAGO GRAMATICA KICK) Drive info: 7 plays, 25 yards. | 17 | 17 |
| TD | 0:00 | DEJUAN GREEN 25 YD RUN (SANTIAGO GRAMATICA KICK) Drive info: 1 plays, 25 yards. | 17 | 24 |
Cincinnati 17, 
South Florida 24