| Scoring Summary |
| FIRST QUARTER | USF | RUTG |
 | FG | 10:08 | Jeremy Ito 26 Yd
Drive: 12 plays, 72 yds, 4:52 | 0 | 3 |
 | FG | 06:27 | Delbert Alvarado 47 Yd
Drive: 8 plays, 34 yds, 3:35 | 3 | 3 |
| TD | 03:58 | Matt Grothe 18 Yd Run (Delbert Alvarado Kick)
Drive: 5 plays, 57 yds, 1:31 | 10 | 3 |
| SECOND QUARTER | USF | RUTG |
| TD | 13:02 | Tiquan Underwood 3 Yd Pass From Mike Teel (Jeremy Ito Kick)
Drive: 13 plays, 73 yds, 5:56 | 10 | 10 |
| TD | 07:10 | Jessie Hester 28 Yd Pass From Matt Grothe (Delbert Alvarado Kick)
Drive: 1 plays, 18 yds, :21 | 17 | 10 |
| FG | 00:05 | Jeremy Ito 40 Yd
Drive: 10 plays, 48 yds, 1:01 | 17 | 13 |
| THIRD QUARTER | USF | RUTG |
| TD | 12:02 | Tiquan Underwood 69 Yd Pass From Mike Teel (Jeremy Ito Kick)
Drive: 3 plays, 75 yds, 1:25 | 17 | 20 |
| TD | 04:09 | Kevin Brock 15 Yd Pass From Andrew Depaola (Jeremy Ito Kick)
Drive: 9 plays, 70 yds, 4:45 | 17 | 27 |
| FG | 01:26 | Delbert Alvarado 34 Yd
Drive: 10 plays, 62 yds, 2:43 | 20 | 27 |
| FOURTH QUARTER | USF | RUTG |
| FG | 11:59 | Jeremy Ito 51 Yd
Drive: 4 plays, 5 yds, :50 | 20 | 30 |
| TD | 09:16 | Mike Ford 1 Yd Run (Delbert Alvarado Kick)
Drive: 8 plays, 70 yds, 2:43 | 27 | 30 |
South Florida 27, 
Rutgers 30