In reply to suit, ex-coach also says WVU drove him from job
MORGANTOWN, W.Va. -- Rich Rodriguez says opening the books of West Virginia's private fundraising arm is the only way to determine whether his abrupt resignation as football coach harmed the school financially.
That was a key demand in the formal response that Rodriguez filed Friday to WVU's lawsuit over the $4 million buyout clause in his contract. He also said it was the administration's actions -- not a better offer -- that forced him to resign in December and take the coaching job at Michigan.
WVU attorney Jeff Wakefield said Rodriguez's response "contains nothing new or unexpected."
"It will have no effect on the merits of the university's claims," he said. "We believe there is no basis in fact or law for their claims and defenses. We look forward to presenting our case before the court as soon as possible."
Largely, Rodriguez's answer to the lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Clarksburg restated many of the arguments his camp has made since Dec. 18, when his resignation sparked a feud with the school. His lawyers have ratcheted up the stakes by drawing the WVU Foundation into the matter.
The foundation, which had been run in part by WVU president Mike Garrison's chief of staff, Craig Walker, is not legally obligated to open its books to public scrutiny under ordinary circumstances. But the foundation is a key part of keeping the WVU football program self-sufficient.
According to its annual report, the foundation ended fiscal 2007 with total assets of more than $1 billion and endowment investments of $474 million, a 24-percent increase over the previous year.
"The only way to tell whether or not West Virginia University has been damaged is to see if its donations to the foundation have decreased and/or if other expenses have increased,'' his lawyers said, noting WVU hired assistant coach Bill Stewart to replace Rodriguez at a significantly smaller salary.
Rodriguez asked the court to make the foundation a third party to the lawsuit, citing recent news releases that claimed gifts to the foundation "were at an all-time high." He wants the right to examine its books to find out if donations have dropped off since his departure.
Rodriguez also aimed to disprove Garrison's alleged assertion that "certain large donors" demanded the coach's contract include the $4 million buyout clause.
Rodriguez has repeatedly claimed that WVU broke the contract by failing to honor a variety of verbal promises, including one to reduce or eliminate his buyout.
WVU, which sued Dec. 27, denies such a promise was made.
The counterclaim also argued that WVU lacked the authority to file the lawsuit, which it said should have first been approved by the Board of Governors.
But Chairman Steve Goodwin said the board, which is named as a plaintiff, "was intimately involved in the decision."
A meeting was not required because of long-standing practice established under former President David C. Hardesty Jr., he said. The president is permitted to act on the board's behalf in initiating or defending lawsuits.
"An actual vote on this was not necessary," Goodwin said.
Rodriguez admitted he didn't spell out his reasons for leaving in a one-sentence resignation letter in December, but pointed out that he did so in a second letter on Jan. 10 that essentially formed the foundation of his legal defense.
Earlier this week, Rodriguez filed a $1.5 million letter of credit with the court, arguing that's the most he could potentially owe under the contract in effect when he quit.
His legal team called that filing a gesture of good faith, not an offer to settle.
The gradual disintegration of the relationship between Rodriguez and the WVU athletic department was documented in a series of e-mails written over a five-month period. They showed that Rodriguez's relationship with the school was on a downhill slide months before he resigned, in part because of his failed attempts to gain total control over the football program.
Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- FSU's Winston captures ACC player of year
- Sarkisian happy to be back 'home' with USC
- QB Mariota to bypass draft, return to Ducks
- Sources: LSU's Mettenberger has torn ACL
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
Breaking up is hard to do. Rich Rodriguez and West Virginia are showing just how hard. The state's once favorite son's divorce from his alma mater has deteriorated into a flurry of accusations and lawsuits. Both sides have suffered significant damage in the proceedings. Mark Schlabach• Affidavit: Rodriguez offered job to accused man
• WVU Foundation wants legal fees from Rodriguez
• Rodriguez wins right to prove fraud on WVU's part
• WVU asks judge to dismiss Rodriguez's complaints
• Lawsuit headed back to W. Va. court
• Rodriguez wants look at WVU foundation's books
• Schlabach: Divorce festers in West Virginia
• Rodriguez offers to pay part of $4M WVU buyout
• Rodriguez claims WVU prez reneged on buyout
• E-mails: Rodriguez, WVU athletic dept. at odds
• Michigan to pay Rodriguez $2.5M annually
• Maisel: Rodriguez aide accuses WVU of racial bias
• Report: Governor refutes Rodriguez 'smear' claim
• WVU pays ex-coach Rodriguez $287,000 bonus
• Rodriguez claims he's target of 'smear campaign'
• WVU's suit against ex-coach goes to federal court
• WVU to investigate disappearance of football files
• Rodriguez's family harassed since resignation
• Stewart to replace Rodriguez at WVU
• Critical alumnus Kendrick donates $1M to WVU
• West Virginia sues Rodriguez, seeks $4M buyout
• Gov. says WVU gave Rodriguez no cause for exit
• Rodriguez joins Michigan, WVU buyout unresolved
• Source: Rodriguez to contest buyout at WVU
• New Michigan coach Rodriguez says leaving WVU 'difficult decision'
• Maisel: Michigan makes sense for Rodriguez
• Rodriguez leaving West Virginia for Michigan
• Report: WVU's Rodriguez meets with Michigan AD