Heisman voters stick by Cam Newton

Updated: November 11, 2010, 12:57 PM ET
ESPN.com news services

NEW YORK -- Cam Newton was on his way to winning the Heisman Trophy -- until about a week ago.

Now the Auburn quarterback is facing allegations that he and his family sought money for him to play at Mississippi State and that he cheated on his schoolwork while a student at Florida.

All Auburn coach Gene Chizik would say Wednesday about Newton is that the star quarterback will start Saturday for the second-ranked Tigers against Georgia.

Chizik declined to answer questions about an ESPN.com report that Newton told a Mississippi State recruiter that his father wanted him to go to Auburn because "the money was too much."

Just two months after former USC running back Reggie Bush returned his Heisman, voters for college football's most famous player of the year award have more than yards and touchdowns to consider.

But there is no denying Newton's worthiness as a player.

He has performed spectacularly, transforming Auburn into a national championship contender. The 6-foot-6, 250-pound junior is 10th in the nation in rushing (114 yards per game), second in passer rating (182.8) and has accounted for 35 touchdowns.

By Dec. 6, about 925 Heisman voters nationwide will be asked to submit a ballot with three players listed. First-place votes are worth three points, second-place two and third-place one.

Most of the voters are media members who cover college football. Previous Heisman winners also get to vote.

I don't think it necessarily knocked him out of the Heisman race, but I think he's teetering on the edge of hemorrhaging a lot of votes.

-- Chris Huston of heismanpundit.com on Auburn QB Cam Newton

Nineteen of 23 voters reached by the AP on Wednesday said they will judge Newton like any contender unless he is found to have broken rules and been declared ineligible by the NCAA.

"If Cam Newton is eligible to play in games at the time my Heisman ballot is due, it won't affect how I vote," Tom Keegan of the Lawrence (Kan.) Journal World said. "If serious allegations later are proven true, then they can always take the award back from him. There is time for this to change, but at the moment, the race for the Heisman is a race for second place. He's the best player in college football."

Four voters said allegations alone could be enough to dissuade them from putting Newton on their ballots.

"I have very serious concerns about what I'm hearing," Bill Cole of the Winston-Salem (N.C.) Journal said. "At this point, I can't envision voting for him. One Reggie Bush tainting the Heisman is enough."

Bush won the Heisman in 2005. The NCAA later determined he and his family received improper benefits and ruled the Southern California star tailback was ineligible for the '05 season.

The Heisman ballot states: "The recipients must be in compliance with the bylaws defining an NCAA student athlete."

As the Heisman Trust considered whether to take away Bush's Heisman, he gave it back in September, and the '05 award was left vacant.

The NCAA is reviewing Newton's recruitment, but Auburn has not received a letter of inquiry, a person told the AP last week on condition of anonymity because the person was not authorized to comment publicly.

Newton started his college career at Florida and was Tim Tebow's backup as a freshman in 2007. He was arrested in November 2008 in Gainesville, when campus police said he stole a $1,700 laptop, then threw it out his dormitory window when officers arrived to investigate.

The charges were dropped after he completed a pretrial intervention program for first-time offenders. Newton has said he bought the stolen computer from someone else.

He left Florida at the end of the 2008 fall semester and landed at Blinn College, a junior college in Texas, in January 2009. He has said he transferred because he didn't want to sit behind Tebow another year.

Coming out of Blinn, he was recruited by Mississippi State and former Florida offensive coordinator Dan Mullen, now the Bulldogs' head coach. Newton has said he picked Auburn over Mississippi State because his father wanted him to be closer to the family's Georgia home.

Former Tennessee coach Lane Kiffin, now at USC, said he recruited Newton as a junior college player, the Los Angeles Times reported. When asked if the Newtons or someone claiming to represent the family said money would be needed for the Vols to sign him, Kiffin said, "No."

Kiffin said Newton and his father made an unofficial visit to Tennessee, according to the report.

"We didn't offer him a scholarship, which doesn't make me look very smart, but we did talk to him," Kiffin said Wednesday, according to the report. "He was a very exciting player that wasn't necessarily a perfect system fit for what we were doing, but we knew he would be great in other systems."

In his first season as a major college starting quarterback, Newton has become the Heisman front-runner.

Chris Huston runs heismanpundit.com and does a weekly straw poll of 13 voters. He has correctly forecast the top-six finishers in the Heisman voting each of the past two seasons.

Newton received 11 first-place votes in this week's heismanpundit poll, which was compiled before the reports of alleged academic cheating.

Huston said it's not surprising that voters are taking an innocent-until-proven-guilty approach.

"The question is: When they're actually sitting down and thinking about all the ramifications, what will they do then?" he said.

No matter how the story plays out, it will have an effect on the Heisman race, Huston said.

"I don't think it necessarily knocked him out of the Heisman race, but I think he's teetering on the edge of hemorrhaging a lot of votes," Huston said.

Voters will have other viable candidates. LaMichael James of No. 1 Oregon leads the nation in rushing, and Kellen Moore of No. 4 Boise State is the country's leading passer.

Had there been no accusations of improprieties, and Newton kept playing the way he was playing -- and Auburn kept on winning -- the Heisman winner would have been a foregone conclusion heading into the Dec. 11 ceremony in New York.

Now, no matter how well Newton plays, it might not be enough.

"I hope I'm like the other 900-plus voters who will judge Newton's merits on the field and allow these off-the-field matters to be resolved, hopefully very soon," Kirk Bohls of the Austin (Texas) American-Statesman said. "But the ghost of Reggie Bush could haunt Cam's Heisman chances."

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

ALSO SEE