| 1st Quarter | | CON | VALP |
| Concordia University (WI) at 0:00 | CON | VALP |
| | Concordia Wisc penalty 5 yard illegal procedure on Kevin Elliot accepted, no play. | 0 | 0 |
| | Dan Winsey kickoff for a loss of 7 yards returned by John Popper, tackled by Joe Moro for a loss of 32 yards to the 50 yard line, tackled by Joe Moro. | | |
| Valparaiso at 15:00 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at VALP 50 | Ross Wiemer rush for 8 yards to the CBM 42, tackled by Nick Napoli. | 0 | 0 |
| 2nd and 2 at CON 42 | John Popper rush for 4 yards to the CBM 38 out-of-bounds for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CON 38 | Ross Wiemer rush for no gain to the CBM 38, tackled by Travis Pagel. | | |
| 2nd and 10 at CON 38 | Warren Arnold pass complete to Nicholas Henton for 7 yards to the CBM 31, tackled by Justin Rogers. | | |
| 3rd and 3 at CON 31 | John Popper rush for 15 yards to the CBM 16, tackled by Kyle Stouff and Ryan Schwartzberg for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CON 16 | Concordia Wisc penalty 5 yard offside accepted. | | |
| 1st and 5 at CON 11 | Ross Wiemer rush for 11 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | 0 | 6 |
| | - Smith extra point GOOD. | 0 | 7 |
| | - Smith kickoff for 61 yards returned by Justin Cardarelle, tackled by JaVon Welch and Luke Kanclerz for 23 yards to the CBM 32, tackled by JaVon Welch and Luke Kanclerz. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: VALPO drive: 6 plays 50 yards, 03:44 VALPO TD |
| |
| Concordia University (WI) at 11:16 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at CON 32 | Thomas Pacchioli pass incomplete to Jerrod Watkins, broken up by Andrew Mack. | 0 | 7 |
| 2nd and 10 at CON 32 | Thomas Pacchioli rush for 8 yards to the CBM 40, tackled by Sean Dillon. | | |
| 3rd and 2 at CON 40 | Jason McClelland rush for a loss of 1 yard to the CBM 39, tackled by Matt Watkins. | | |
| 4th and 3 at CON 39 | Tom Roberts punt for 39 yards, downed at the Valpo 22. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: CUW drive: 3 plays 7 yards, 00:00 CUW PUNT |
| |
| Valparaiso at 11:10 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at VALP 22 | Ross Wiemer rush for 1 yard to the Valpo 23, tackled by Ryan Bott. | 0 | 7 |
| 2nd and 9 at VALP 23 | John Popper rush for 2 yards to the Valpo 25, tackled by Travis Pagel. | | |
| 3rd and 7 at VALP 25 | Warren Arnold pass complete to Steven Ogden for 31 yards to the CBM 44, tackled by Justin Rogers out-of-bounds for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CON 44 | John Popper rush for 4 yards to the CBM 40, tackled by Travis Pagel. | | |
| 2nd and 6 at CON 40 | Warren Arnold pass incomplete to Ryan Myers. | | |
| 3rd and 6 at CON 40 | Warren Arnold pass incomplete to Ross Wiemer. | | |
| 4th and 6 at CON 40 | Mitch Secrest punt for 40 yards for a touchback. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: VALPO drive: 6 plays 38 yards, 02:43 VALPO PUNT |
| |
| Concordia University (WI) at 9:32 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at CON 20 | Thomas Pacchioli pass complete to Jason McClelland for 2 yards to the CBM 22, tackled by Dominick Bellotte. | 0 | 7 |
| 2nd and 8 at CON 22 | Thomas Pacchioli pass incomplete to David White. | | |
| 3rd and 8 at CON 22 | David White rush for 2 yards to the CBM 24, tackled by Andrew Mack and Adam Rundh. | | |
| 4th and 6 at CON 24 | Tom Roberts punt for 50 yards, returned by John Popper, tackled by David Wieland out-of-bounds. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: CUW drive: 3 plays 4 yards, 01:42 CUW PUNT |
| |
| Valparaiso at 6:49 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at VALP 34 | Ross Wiemer rush for a loss of 3 yards to the Valpo 31, tackled by Andrew Hobus. | 0 | 7 |
| 2nd and 13 at VALP 31 | Warren Arnold pass incomplete to Ryan Myers. | | |
| 3rd and 13 at VALP 31 | Warren Arnold pass incomplete to John Popper, hurried by David Wieland. | | |
| 4th and 13 at VALP 31 | Mitch Secrest punt for 42 yards, returned by Montrell Davidson for a loss of 8 yards to the Valpo 31, tackled by Matt Watkins, Concordia Wisc penalty 10 yard illegal block on Justin Rogers accepted. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: VALPO drive: 3 plays -3 yards, 01:04 VALPO PUNT |
| |
| Concordia University (WI) at 5:07 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at CON 19 | Justin Cardarelle rush for 8 yards to the CBM 27, tackled by Eli Crawford and Jr. Darren Kincaid. | 0 | 7 |
| 2nd and 2 at CON 27 | Jason McClelland rush for 4 yards to the CBM 31, tackled by Adam Rundh for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CON 31 | Kasiem Duran rush for 5 yards to the CBM 36 out-of-bounds. | | |
| 2nd and 5 at CON 36 | Jason McClelland rush for a loss of 3 yards to the CBM 33, tackled by Jr. Darren Kincaid. | | |
| 3rd and 8 at CON 33 | Thomas Pacchioli pass incomplete to Justin Cardarelle, hurried by Adam Rundh. | | |
| 4th and 8 at CON 33 | Tom Roberts punt for 52 yards, downed at the Valpo 15. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: CUW drive: 5 plays 14 yards, 02:32 CUW PUNT |
| |
| Valparaiso at 4:03 | CON | VALP |
| 1st and 10 at VALP 15 | Warren Arnold rush for 8 yards to the Valpo 23, tackled by Justin Rogers. | 0 | 7 |
| 2nd and 2 at VALP 23 | John Popper rush for a loss of 4 yards to the Valpo 19, tackled by Nick Napoli. | | |
| 3rd and 6 at VALP 19 | Warren Arnold pass complete to Steven Ogden for 12 yards to the Valpo 31 for a 1ST down. | | |
| 3rd and 6 at VALP 19 | End of 1st Quarter | | |
Concordia University (WI) 10, 
Valparaiso 34