| 1st Quarter | | OHIO | BALL |
| Ball State at 15:00 | OHIO | BALL |
| | Ian McGarvey kickoff for 62 yards returned by L.J. Flintall, tackled by Armand Dehaney for 23 yards to the Ohio 31, tackled by Armand Dehaney. | 0 | 0 |
| Ohio at 15:00 | OHIO | BALL |
| 1st and 10 at OHIO 31 | LaVon Brazill rush for 20 yards to the BalSt 49, tackled by Robert Eddins and Koreen Burch for a 1ST down. | 0 | 0 |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 49 | Chris Garrett rush for 1 yard to the BalSt 48, tackled by Travis Freeman. | | |
| 2nd and 9 at BALL 48 | Chris Garrett rush for 9 yards to the BalSt 39, tackled by Charlie Todd for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 39 | Theo Scott rush for a loss of 4 yards to the BalSt 43, tackled by Brandon Crawford and Rene Perry. | | |
| 2nd and 14 at BALL 43 | Theo Scott pass complete to LaVon Brazill for 3 yards to the BalSt 40, tackled by Charlie Todd. | | |
| 3rd and 11 at BALL 40 | Theo Scott pass intercepted by Jason Pinkston at the BalSt 27, returned for no gain to the BalSt 27. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: OHIO drive: 6 plays 29 yards, 00:00 OHIO INT |
| |
| Ball State at 15:00 | OHIO | BALL |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 27 | MiQuale Lewis rush for 4 yards to the BalSt 31, tackled by Gerald Moore and Noah Keller. | 0 | 0 |
| 2nd and 6 at BALL 31 | BALL ST penalty 5 yard false start on Briggs Orsbon accepted. | | |
| 2nd and 11 at BALL 26 | Tanner Justice sacked by Dak Notestine for a loss of 7 yards to the BalSt 19. | | |
| 3rd and 18 at BALL 19 | MiQuale Lewis rush for 7 yards to the BalSt 26, tackled by Gerald Moore. | | |
| 4th and 11 at BALL 26 | Scott Kovanda punt for 39 yards, returned by LaVon Brazill for 8 yards to the Ohio 43, tackled by Kyle Hoke. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: BSU drive: 3 plays -1 yards, 00:00 BSU PUNT |
| |
| Ohio at 11:47 | OHIO | BALL |
| 1st and 10 at OHIO 43 | Chris Garrett rush for 2 yards to the Ohio 45, tackled by Justin Cruz and Drew Duffin. | 0 | 0 |
| 2nd and 8 at OHIO 45 | Chris Garrett rush for 1 yard to the Ohio 46, tackled by Justin Cruz. | | |
| 3rd and 7 at OHIO 46 | Chris Garrett rush for 5 yards to the BalSt 49, tackled by Charlie Todd and Davyd Jones. | | |
| 4th and 2 at BALL 49 | Paul Hershey rush for 7 yards to the BalSt 42, tackled by Cory Sykes and Armand Dehaney for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 42 | OHIO penalty 10 yard holding on David White accepted, no play. | | |
| 1st and 20 at OHIO 48 | LaVon Brazill rush for 14 yards to the BalSt 38, tackled by Travis Freeman and Alex Knipp. | | |
| 2nd and 6 at BALL 38 | Theo Scott pass complete to Vince Davidson for 12 yards to the BalSt 26, tackled by Travis Freeman for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 26 | Theo Scott pass complete to Taylor Price for 11 yards to the BalSt 15, tackled by Koreen Burch for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 15 | Timeout OHIO, clock 05:08. | | |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 15 | Chris Garrett rush for a loss of 4 yards to the BalSt 19, tackled by Charlie Todd. | | |
| 2nd and 14 at BALL 19 | Theo Scott pass incomplete to Taylor Price, broken up by Koreen Burch. | | |
| 3rd and 14 at BALL 19 | Theo Scott sacked by Brandon Crawford for a loss of 3 yards to the BalSt 22, OHIO penalty holding declined. | | |
| 4th and 17 at BALL 22 | Matt Weller 39 yard field goal GOOD. | 3 | 0 |
| | Matt Weller kickoff for 70 yards returned by Eric Williams, tackled by Donovan Fletcher for 28 yards to the BalSt 28, tackled by Donovan Fletcher. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: OHIO drive: 11 plays 35 yards, 05:04 OHIO FG |
| |
| Ball State at 4:12 | OHIO | BALL |
| 1st and 10 at BALL 28 | MiQuale Lewis rush for 6 yards to the BalSt 34, tackled by Patrick Tafua and Gerald Moore. | 3 | 0 |
| 2nd and 4 at BALL 34 | MiQuale Lewis rush for 2 yards to the BalSt 36, tackled by Noah Keller and Gerald Moore. | | |
| 3rd and 2 at BALL 36 | MiQuale Lewis rush for 1 yard to the BalSt 37, tackled by Dak Notestine and Marcellis Williamson. | | |
| 4th and 1 at BALL 37 | Scott Kovanda punt for 62 yards, downed at the Ohio 1. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: BSU drive: 3 plays 9 yards, 00:00 BSU PUNT |
| |
| Ohio at 4:00 | OHIO | BALL |
| 1st and 10 at OHIO 1 | Vince Davidson rush for 3 yards to the Ohio 4, tackled by Travis Freeman. | 3 | 0 |
| 2nd and 7 at OHIO 4 | Theo Scott rush for 8 yards to the Ohio 12, tackled by Charlie Todd for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at OHIO 12 | Vince Davidson rush for 6 yards to the Ohio 18, tackled by Justin Cruz and Travis Freeman. | | |
| | End of 1st Quarter | | |
Ohio 20, 
Ball State 17