The Nation's Best: Fifth Annual Herbies
The Herbies celebrate their fifth season with an all-star cast of players and a few extra catagories from the sights and sounds from around college football.
But before we announce the winners, let's get one thing straight -- The Herbies celebrate college football players. This list has everything to do with the playmakers, the hogmollies, the difference makers and, in short, just great college football players. It has nothing -- nothing -- to do with their pro potential.
Now, what's a Herbie? It's given to the best college football players, coaches, teams and fans from across the nation.
Also, this is just my list. These are my choices and not everyone will agree. That's the beauty of it. Let the second-guessing begin.
So, here they are -- the fifth annual Herbie Awards.
| Reggie Bush, USC | ![]() Reggie Bush gets the Herbie for best running back. |
| Adrian Peterson, Oklahoma | |
| Gerald Riggs Jr., Tennessee | |
| DeAngelo Williams, Memphis | |
| Marshawn Lynch, Cal |
![]() Calvin Johnson has the speed and hops to make the big play. | Calvin Johnson, Georgia Tech |
| Ted Ginn Jr., Ohio State | |
| Robert Meachem, Tennessee | |
| Derek Hagan, Arizona State | |
| Dwayne Jarrett, USC |
| Greg Eslinger, C, Minnesota | ![]() Greg Eslinger is simply dominating at center.. |
| Max Jean-Gilles, G, Georgia | |
| Davin Joseph, G, Oklahoma | |
| Eric Winston, T, Miami | |
| D'Brickashaw Ferguson, T, Virginia |
| Top Tight Ends | |
|---|---|
![]() Marcedes Lewis is a matchup nightmare. |
Marcedes Lewis, UCLA |
| Zach Miller, Arizona State | |
| Dominique Byrd, USC | |
| Greg Olsen, Miami | |
| Jeff King, Virginia Tech | |
| (Honorable Mention: Anthony Fasano, Notre Dame; Joe Klopfenstein, Colorado; David Thomas, Texas; Tim Massaquoi, Michigan) |
| Old School (Classic dropback style) | New School (Run and pass like Michael Vick) |
| Matt Leinart, USC | Reggie McNeal, Texas A&M |
| Brian Brohm, Louisville | Vince Young, Texas |
| Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh | Brad Smith, Missouri |
| Chris Leak, Florida | Marcus Vick, Virginia Tech |
| Brodie Croyle, Alabama | Drew Tate, Iowa |
| Chad Henne, Michigan | Troy Smith, Ohio State |
| Top Defensive Ends | Top Defensive Tackles |
| Stanley McClover, Auburn | Rodrique Wright, Texas |
| Ray Edwards, Purdue | Dusty Dvoracek, Oklahoma |
| Darryl Tapp, Virginia Tech | Jesse Mahelona, Tennessee |
| Mathias Kiwanuka, Boston College | Orien Harris, Miami |
| Mario Williams, NC State | Gabe Watson, Michigan |
| Top Outside Linebackers | Top Inside Linebackers |
| A.J. Hawk, Ohio State | D'Qwell Jackson, Maryland |
| Chad Greenway, Iowa | Abdul Hodge, Iowa |
| Ernie Sims, Florida State | Spencer Havner, UCLA |
| Will Derting, Washington State | Anthony Schlegel, Ohio State |
| Xavier Adibi, Virginia Tech | Aaron Harris, Texas |
| George Hall, Purdue |
| Best Defensive Backs | ||
|---|---|---|
| CORNERBACKS | STRONG SAFETIES | FREE SAFETIES |
| Jimmy Williams, Virginia Tech | Darnell Bing, USC | LaRon Landry, LSU |
| Michael Huff, Texas | Bernard Pollard, Purdue | Scott Ware, USC |
| Charles Gordon, Kansas | Donte Whitner, Ohio State | Ko Simpson, South Carolina |
| Alan Zemaitis, Penn State | Charlie Peprah, Alabama | Nate Salley, Ohio State |
| Darrelle Revis, Pittsburgh | Donnie McCleskey, Cal | Pat Watkins, Florida State |
Purdue -- With 19 starters returning and a favorable schedule, look for the Boilers to be in thick of Big Ten championship chase. |
Texas A&M -- The Aggies have a third year in coach Dennis Franchione's system, a four-year starting QB in Reggie McNeal and they get Texas at home. |
Alabama -- It all comes down to health. If Bama stays healthy (especially at QB), the Tide will be a surprise team in the SEC. |
Oregon -- Expect Mike Bellotti and the experienced Ducks to make some noise in the Pac-10 after a few mediocre seasons. A veteran QB and replenished skill positions (read: loaded with tremendous athletes) will make sure of it. |
Pitt -- Being in the newly redesigned Big East will allow first-year coach Dave Wannstedt -- who inherits a talented Pitt team led by QB Tyler Palko -- to make a great run this year.
|
| Mark It Down | ||
|---|---|---|
| CONFERENCE | CHAMP | SLEEPER |
| ACC Atlantic | Florida State | Boston College |
| ACC Coastal | Virginia Tech | Georgia Tech |
| ACC Champ | Virginia Tech | |
| Big East | Louisville | Pittsburgh |
| Big Ten | Ohio State | Penn State |
| Big 12 North | Colorado | Iowa State |
| Big 12 South | Texas A&M | Texas |
| Big 12 Champ | Texas A&M | |
| C-USA East | UAB | Memphis |
| C-USA West | UTEP | Houston |
| C-USA Champ | UTEP | |
| MAC East | Miami (Ohio) | Ohio |
| MAC West | Toledo | Eastern Michigan |
| MAC Champ | Toledo | |
| Mountain West | Utah | Colorado State |
| Pac-10 | USC | Oregon |
| SEC East | Florida | South Carolina |
| SEC West | LSU | Alabama |
| SEC Champ | LSU | |
| Sun Belt | North Texas | Middle Tennessee |
| WAC | Boise State | New Mexico State |
| Derrick Williams, WR, Penn State | ![]() Derrick Williams will spark the Penn State offense. |
| Patrick Turner, WR, USC | |
| DeSean Jackson, WR, Cal | |
| Jonathan Stewart, RB, Oregon | |
| Marlon Lucky, RB, Nebraska | |
| Kevin Grady, RB, Michigan | |
| Jamario O'Neal, DB, Ohio State | |
| Kenny Phillips, DB, Miami | |
| Justin King, WR/CB, Penn State | |
| Fred Rouse, WR, Florida State | |
![]() Brian Brohm is a name you'll know. |
|
| Brian Brohm, QB, Louisville | |
| Marshawn Lynch, RB, Cal | |
| Michael Robinson, QB, Penn State | |
| Willie Williams, LB, Miami | |
| DeShawn Wynn, RB, Florida | |
| Keith Rivers, LB, USC | |
| Brandon Kirsch, QB, Purdue | |
| JaMarcus Russell, QB, LSU | |
| Courtney Lewis, Texas A&M | |
| Greg Olsen, Miami | |
| Florida | ![]() The Gators always give their fans a reason to cheer. |
| Texas A&M | |
| Michigan | |
| Notre Dame | |
| Utah | |
| (Wisconsin has always been one of my favorite places, but it lost serious points lately. Lighten up on the beer bongs. Have a little more respect for your opponents; and remember, there are kids around, too, so maybe yelling profanities in every other chant isn't such a good idea.) | |
| Ole Miss | |
| Georgia | |
| South Carolina | |
| Tennessee | |
| USC | |
| Offensive Team | Defensive Team |
| QB - Vince Young, Texas | DE - Mario Williams, NC State |
| RB - Reggie Bush, USC | DE - Ray Edwards, Purdue |
| RB - Adrian Peterson, Oklahoma | DT - Rodrique Wright, Texas |
| TE - Marcedes Lewis, UCLA | DT - Dusty Dvoracek, Oklahoma |
| WR - Tedd Ginn, Ohio State | LB - Xavier Adibi, Virginia Tech |
| WR - Robert Meachem, Tennessee | LB - Ernie Sims, FSU |
| C - Donovan Raiola, Wisconsin | LB - Willie Williams, Miami |
| G - Matt Lentz, Michigan | CB - Alan Zemaitis, Penn State |
| G - JB Closner, Alabama | CB - Michael Huff, Texas |
| T - Jonathan Scott, Texas | S - Nate Salley, Ohio State |
| T - D'Brickashaw Ferguson, Virginia | S - Darnell Bing, USC |
| Texas (All white) |
| USC (Cardinal jerseys, Gold pants) |
| Penn State (Blue jerseys, White pants) |
| Miami (Orange pants, White top) |
| FSU (Garnet jerseys, Gold pants) |
Ohio State -- Rabid fans and, selfishly, my wife and kids get a chance to be there. But the Buckeyes' fans support our show as well as -- if not a little bit better than -- any other site. |
Any SEC site -- It's too hard to separate Knoxville from Gainesville from Athens, but anytime we go to an SEC game I'm excited because I know we'll see a great game and the fans will make it an experience to remember. |
USC -- I never thought I'd put a Pac-10 school on this list, but the Trojans' fans blew me away last year with their support. They showed up at 7:30 a.m. local time, and the thousands of Trojans fans let the nation know USC and the Pac-10 are to be taken seriously. |
Virginia Tech -- Same old, same old. The Hokies' faithful always make this list because of their loyalty, knowledge of the game and respect for the game. Virginia Tech fans are as good as it gets. |
Texas A&M -- It starts with 40,000 people gathering at midnight Friday for Yell Practice and continues with all the traditions, including the way they stand for the entire game and cheer on their Aggies. |
| Pete Carroll, USC | ![]() Pete Carroll takes care of ever little detail for USC. |
| Bob Stoops, Oklahoma | |
| Jim Tressel, Ohio State | |
| Mack Brown, Texas | |
| Kirk Ferentz, Iowa | |
| Jeff Tedford, Cal | |
| Top Offensive Coordinators | Top Defensive Coordinators |
| Al Borges, Auburn | Jon Tenuta, Georgia Tech |
| Chris Peterson, Boise State | Bud Foster, Virginia Tech |
| Gary Crowton, Oregon | Brock Spack, Purdue |
| Jimbo Fisher, LSU | Gene Chizik, Texas |
| Brian Stinespring, Virginia Tech | Bob Gregory, Cal |
| Miami -- Great restaurants and, obviously, the weather. |
| Los Angeles -- See above. Every time I'm out on the West Coast I think I want to move there (well, I would if it wasn't so far from family and friends). |
| Salt Lake City -- A great city in itself, but if you enjoy the outdoors, you can't beat Park City (which is just a few miles up the road). |
| Austin, Texas -- Another town I could easily see myself living in if it just wasn't so hot. |
| Fort Collins, Colo. -- One of these days I'm going to learn how to fly-fish when I'm in Fort Collins. |
| Lil' Dooey in Starkville, Miss. (Barry Wood makes the best BBQ in the country) |
| The Palm in Atlanta |
| Mitchell's Steak House in Columbus, Ohio |
| Smith and Wollensky in Miami |
| Ruffinos in Baton Rouge, La. |
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- QB Lunt mulls Illinois after visit, sources say
- Sources: C-USA to put team in Military Bowl
- For Irish, may be BCS or bust for bowl spot
- Federal judge weighs fate of Corbett lawsuit
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
- Kiper: Top prospects for 2014, by position
- Recruiting: Michigan tops 2014 class ranks
- Haney: CFB's top 10 teams based on talent
- Kiper: Top QB prospects for 2014 | RBs | WRs
- Fremeau: Who will win the SEC? | Pac-12




Purdue -- With 19 starters returning and a favorable schedule, look for the Boilers to be in thick of Big Ten championship chase.
Texas A&M -- The Aggies have a third year in coach Dennis Franchione's system, a four-year starting QB in Reggie McNeal and they get Texas at home.
Alabama -- It all comes down to health. If Bama stays healthy (especially at QB), the Tide will be a surprise team in the SEC.
Oregon -- Expect Mike Bellotti and the experienced Ducks to make some noise in the Pac-10 after a few mediocre seasons. A veteran QB and replenished skill positions (read: loaded with tremendous athletes) will make sure of it.
Pitt -- Being in the newly redesigned Big East will allow first-year coach Dave Wannstedt -- who inherits a talented Pitt team led by QB Tyler Palko -- to make a great run this year.



Ohio State -- Rabid fans and, selfishly, my wife and kids get a chance to be there. But the Buckeyes' fans support our show as well as -- if not a little bit better than -- any other site.
Any SEC site -- It's too hard to separate Knoxville from Gainesville from Athens, but anytime we go to an SEC game I'm excited because I know we'll see a great game and the fans will make it an experience to remember.
USC -- I never thought I'd put a Pac-10 school on this list, but the Trojans' fans blew me away last year with their support. They showed up at 7:30 a.m. local time, and the thousands of Trojans fans let the nation know USC and the Pac-10 are to be taken seriously.
Virginia Tech -- Same old, same old. The Hokies' faithful always make this list because of their loyalty, knowledge of the game and respect for the game. Virginia Tech fans are as good as it gets. 


