Ninth Annual Herbie Awards
With the season's kickoff just days away, it's time to step back and celebrate the players, coaches, color and pageantry of college football. Who are the players to know? Where are the places to be? The ninth annual Herbie Awards presentation answers those questions and more.
This list tackles the top playmakers, the defensive difference-makers, the fresh faces on the scene, the student sections that roar and everything else that's great about college football. Herbies are given to the best college football players, coaches, teams and fans across the nation.
Also, this is just my list. These are my choices, and not everyone will agree. That's the beauty of it. Let the second-guessing begin.
So, without further ado, here are the ninth annual Herbie Awards:
BORN TO RUN: BEST RUNNING BACKS
![]() Jahvid Best has his eyes on a Herbie Award. (Photo by Daniel R. Harris/Icon SMI)
1. Jahvid Best, California
2. Jonathan Dwyer, Georgia Tech 3. DeMarco Murray, Oklahoma 4. Jacquizz Rodgers, Oregon State 5. C.J. Spiller, Clemson 6. Kendall Hunter, Oklahoma State |
OFF AND RUNNING: READY TO TAKE IT TO THE NEXT LEVEL
|
1. Toby Gerhart, Stanford
2. Dexter McCluster, Ole Miss 3. Damion Fletcher, Southern Miss 4. LeGarrette Blount, Oregon 5. Michael Smith, Arkansas 6. Nic Grigsby, Arizona ![]() Toby Gerhart will have Cardinal foes seeing red. (Photo by Daniel R. Harris/Icon SMI)
|
CATCH A RISING STAR: TOP WIDE RECEIVERS
![]() Defenses will handle Dez Bryant with care in 2009. (Photo by Scott Wachter/Icon SMI)
1. Dez Bryant, Oklahoma State
2. Julio Jones, Alabama 3. A.J. Green, Georgia 4. Damian Williams, USC 5. Arrelious Benn, Illinois 6. Jordan Shipley, Texas 7. Golden Tate, Notre Dame 8. Mardy Gilyard, Cincinnati |
THE HOGMOLLIES: BEST IN THE TRENCHES
|
C - Kristofer O'Dowd, USC
G - Sergio Render, Virginia Tech G - Rodney Hudson, Florida State T - Ciron Black, LSU T - Russell Okung, Oklahoma State ![]() USC's Kristofer O'Dowd is the center of attention. (Photo by Jeff Golden/Getty Images)
|
END GAME: TOP TIGHT ENDS
![]() Catching Jermaine Gresham won't be easy in '09. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/Icon SMI)
1. Jermaine Gresham, Oklahoma
2. Aaron Hernandez, Florida 3. Kyle Rudolph, Notre Dame 4. Rob Gronkowski, Arizona 5. Ed Dickson, Oregon 6. Dennis Pitta, BYU 7. D.J. Williams, Arkansas |
QUARTERBACKS: POCKET PRESENCE
|
1. Sam Bradford, Oklahoma
2. Jevan Snead, Ole Miss 3. Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame 4. Max Hall, BYU 5. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas 6. Colin Kaepernick, Nevada 7. Tim Hiller, Western Michigan ![]() Will Sam Bradford make another Heisman connection? (Photo by Todd Kirkland/Icon SMI)
|
QUARTERBACKS: DUAL THREAT
![]() Tim Tebow's focused on another title run. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/Icon SMI)
1. Tim Tebow, Florida
2. Colt McCoy, Texas 3. Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State 4. Zac Robinson, Oklahoma State 5. Robert Griffin III, Baylor 6. Jake Locker, Washington 7. Todd Reesing, Kansas |
ANTICIPATION: TOP FIRST-YEAR QB STARTERS
|
1. Greg McElroy, Alabama
2. Kyle Parker, Clemson 3. Matt Barkley, USC 4. Zac Lee, Nebraska 5. Jacory Harris, Miami 6. Jarrett Brown, West Virginia ![]() Greg McElroy's ready for his turn with the Tide. (Photo by Doug Benc/Getty Images)
|
OFF THE EDGE: BEST DEFENSIVE ENDS
![]() Carlos Dunlap will have his eyes on QBs this fall. (Photo by Sam Greenwood/Getty Images)
1. Carlos Dunlap, Florida
2. Greg Hardy, Ole Miss 3. Jeremy Beal, Oklahoma 4. Sergio Kindle, Texas 5. Everson Griffen, USC 6. Rahim Alem, LSU |
NOWHERE TO RUN: TOP DEFENSIVE TACKLES
|
1. Gerald McCoy, Oklahoma
2. Ndamukong Suh, Nebraska 3. Terrence Cody, Alabama 4. Jared Odrick, Penn State 5. Geno Atkins, Georgia ![]() Look for Gerald McCoy to be a destructive force. (Photo by June Frantz-Hunt/Icon SMI)
|
INSIDE EDITION: TOP INSIDE LINEBACKERS
![]() Brandon Spikes has the inside track for a Herbie. (Photo by Tim Larson/Icon SMI)
1. Brandon Spikes, Florida
2. Rolando McClain, Alabama 3. Sean Lee, Penn State 4. Ryan Reynolds, Oklahoma 5. Reggie Carter, UCLA |
OUTSIDE EDGE: BEST OUTSIDE LINEBACKERS
|
1. Rennie Curran, Georgia
2. Navorro Bowman, Penn State 3. Travis Lewis, Oklahoma 4. Sean Weatherspoon, Missouri 5. Sean Spence, Miami 6. Eric Norwood, South Carolina ![]() Rennie Curran is the top dog at outside linebacker. (Photo by Brad Schloss/Icon SMI)
|
CORNERING THE MARKET: TOP CORNERBACKS
![]() Joe Haden has things covered for the Gators. (Photo by Sam Greenwood/Getty Images)
1. Joe Haden, Florida
2. Syd'Quan Thompson, California 3. Trevard Lindley, Kentucky 4. Myron Lewis, Vanderbilt 5. Alterraun Verner, UCLA 6. Patrick Peterson, LSU |
SAFETY DANCE: NATION'S BEST SAFETIES
|
1a. Eric Berry, Tennessee
1b. Taylor Mays, USC 3. Morgan Burnett, Georgia Tech 4. Bo McNally, Stanford 5. Chad Jones, LSU ![]() Taylor Mays and Eric Berry share a Herbie. (Photo by Getty Images)
|
RETURN ENGAGEMENT: TOP RETURN MEN
![]() The final returns have Brandon James on top. (Photo by Marc Serota/Getty Images)
1. Brandon James, Florida
2. Dez Bryant, Oklahoma State 3. Javier Arenas, Alabama 4. Syd'Quan Thompson, California 5. C.J. Spiller, Clemson |
FRESH APPROACH: TOP TRUE FRESHMEN
|
1. Matt Barkley, USC
2. Manti Te'o, Notre Dame 3. Trent Richardson, Alabama 4. Tate Forcier, Michigan 5. Jelani Jenkins, Florida 6. Marlon Brown, Georgia 7. Bryce Brown, Tennessee 8. Alex Okafor, Texas 9. Rueben Randle, LSU 10. Jonathan Bostic, Florida ![]() Matt Barkley will have a leading role in L.A. in '09. (Photo by Kirby Lee/Image of Sport/US Presswire)
|
REMEMBER ME: HOUSEHOLD NAMES BY THE END OF SEPTEMBER
![]() Mark Ingram will help the Tide roll this season. (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
1. Mark Ingram, Alabama
2. Richard Samuel, Georgia 3. Jason Worilds, Virginia Tech 4. Thaddeus Gibson, Ohio State 5. Russell Wilson, NC State 6. David Ausberry, USC 7. Jewel Hampton, Iowa 8. David Nelson, Florida 9. Detron Lewis, Texas Tech 10. Jarrett Brown, West Virginia |
RODNEY DANGERFIELDS: PLAYERS WHO DON'T GET ENOUGH RESPECT
|
1. Aaron Hernandez, Florida
2. Kerry Meier, Kansas 3. Chris Brown, Oklahoma 4. Josh Pinkard, USC 5. Evan Royster, Penn State 6. Josh Nesbitt, Georgia Tech ![]() No way the Herbies would overlook Aaron Hernandez. (Photo by Al Messerschmidt/Getty Images)
|
TEAMS ON THE MOVE
| Movin' On Up | Headin' On Down |
|---|---|
| 1. LSU Tigers | 1. Missouri Tigers |
| 2. Notre Dame Fighting Irish | 2. Cincinnati Bearcats |
| 3. Clemson Tigers | 3. Connecticut Huskies |
| 4. UCLA Bruins | 4. Northwestern Wildcats |
| 5. Arkansas Razorbacks | 5. Boston College Eagles |
| 6. Michigan Wolverines | 6. Texas Tech Red Raiders |
MARK IT DOWN: CONFERENCE PICKS
| Conference | Champion | Sleeper |
|---|---|---|
| ACC Atlantic | Florida State | NC State |
| ACC Coastal | Georgia Tech | North Carolina |
| ACC champ | Georgia Tech | |
| Big 12 North | Nebraska | Colorado |
| Big 12 South | Texas | Oklahoma State |
| Big 12 champ | Texas | |
| Big East | Rutgers | West Virginia |
| Big Ten | Penn State | Michigan State |
| Pac-10 | USC | UCLA |
| SEC East | Florida | South Carolina |
| SEC West | Alabama | Arkansas |
| SEC champ | Florida | |
| C-USA East | Southern Miss | |
| C-USA West | Houston | |
| C-USA champ | Southern Miss | |
| MAC East | Temple | |
| MAC West | Western Michigan | |
| MAC champ | Western Michigan | |
| MWC | BYU | |
| Sun Belt | Troy | |
| WAC | Boise State |
UP AND COMING ASSISTANTS AND COORDINATORS
![]() Bryan Harsin directs the Boise State offense. (Photo by Brian Losness/US Presswire)
1. Josh Heupel, Oklahoma
2. Justin Wilcox, Boise State 3. Danny Langsdorf, Oregon State 4. Corwin Brown, Notre Dame 5. Bryan Harsin, Boise State 6. Kirby Smart, Alabama |
HEAD COACHES IN WAITING
|
1. Brent Venables, Oklahoma
2. Charlie Strong, Florida 3. Kevin Wilson, Oklahoma 4. Tom Bradley, Penn State 5. Gus Malzahn, Auburn ![]() Brent Venables looks like a future head coach. (Photo by Peter G. Aiken/Getty Images)
|
ALL-UNI TEAM: WHAT A COLLEGE TEAM SHOULD LOOK LIKE
| Offensive Team | Defensive Team |
|---|---|
| QB - Jake Locker, Washington | DE - Carlos Dunlap, Florida |
| RB - C.J. Spiller, Clemson | DE - Thaddeus Gibson, Ohio State |
| RB - DeMarco Murray, Oklahoma | DT - Jared Odrick, Penn State |
| RB - Toby Gerhart, Stanford | DT - Gerald McCoy, Oklahoma |
| WR - Arrelious Benn, Illinois (captain) | LB - Rolando McClain, Alabama |
| WR - Mardy Gilyard, Cincinnati | LB - Martez Wilson, Illinois |
| WR - Dez Bryant, Oklahoma State | LB - Quan Sturdivant, North Carolina |
| TE - Jermaine Gresham, Oklahoma | LB - Travis Lewis, Oklahoma |
| C - Stefen Wisniewski, Penn State | CB - Chykie Brown, Texas |
| G - Jeff Byers, USC | CB - Joe Haden, Florida |
| G - Mike Johnson, Alabama | S - Eric Berry, Tennessee |
| T - Trent Williams, Oklahoma | S - Taylor Mays, USC (captain) |
| T - Sam Young, Notre Dame |
STUDENT BODY RIGHT: BEST STUDENT SECTIONS
![]() Penn State's student section roars to the top. (Photo by Paul Spinelli/Getty Images)
1. Penn State
2. Florida 3. Oregon 4. LSU 5. Wisconsin 6. Ohio State 7. Notre Dame 8. South Carolina 9. Auburn 10. Michigan |
ROAD TRIP: SITES GAMEDAY MUST GET TO
|
1. Ole Miss: The Grove
2. Washington: Lake Washington 3. California: Tightwad Hill 4. Boise State: The Blue Turf 5. West Virginia: Country Roads ![]() Saturday in the Grove is on the wish list. (Photo by Scott Burton/Getty Images)
|
Kirk Herbstreit is an analyst on ESPN's "College GameDay."
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- Sources: Oklahoma St. limits QB Lunt's options
- For Irish, may be BCS or bust for bowl spot
- Saban: 'Devil' words 'terribly disappointing'
- Running back Richardson will leave Virginia
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
2009 College Football Preview
Will Florida repeat as BCS champion? Which teams will surprise? Who'll walk away with the major awards? ESPN.com's 2009 college football preview has the answers.
The National Scene
- Ivan Maisel: Power surge
With stars back, there's plenty of electricity and history expected in 2009. - Power rankings: Who's No. 2?
- Preseason bowl projections
- Mark Schlabach: What's hot (and not)
- Maisel: Heisman hype not hyperbole
- 2009 Heisman Watch
- Pat Forde: Safety first at USC and UT
- Maisel: Preseason All-America team
- Schlabach: Coaches on the hot seat
- Forde: Top 40 villains
Big 12 Preview
- Maisel: Red River Rivalry revenge
- Griffin: OSU's Triplets | Northern lights
- ESPN The Magazine: Colt hero
- Griffin: Predictions | Five to watch
- FBO: Big 12 divisional analysis

- SportsNation: Rank 'em
ACC Preview
- Mark Schlabach: ACC's BCS title search
- Dinich: Hokies' hopes | Cool runnings
- Dinich: Pressure on third-year coaches
- Dinich: Predictions | Five to watch
- FBO: Preseason analysis

- SportsNation: Rank 'em
Notre Dame, MAC & Sun Belt Preview
- Woj: Weis, Irish eye improved product
- Bennett: Stars aligned for Clausen
- Bennett: Irish Golden at receiver
- Bennett: Five things to watch
- Jim Dent excerpt: "Resurrection"
- Watson: Buffalo's Roosevelt quietly stars
- MAC: Predictions | Five to watch
- Schlabach: Sun Belt quarterbacks glimmer
- Sun Belt: Predictions | Five to watch
- Rank 'em: MAC | Sun Belt
SEC East
- Schlabach: Smoth sailing for Florida
- Gators DBs corner the market
- Low: SEC coaching carousel a wild ride
- FBO: SEC divisional analysis

- Low: Hybrid players all the rage
- Five things to watch in the SEC East
SEC West
- Forde: Rebels with a cause
- Low: Big Two QBs and who?
- Schlabach: Hogs' Mallett more than myth
- Low: LSU follows the leader
- Low: Living on the edge
- Five things to watch in the SEC West
Pac-10
- Miller: Fall of Troy will take a 9-team effort
- Miller: Where have all the QB stars gone?
- Miller: Stanford hoping for lots of Luck
- Miller: Washington's Locker has no regrets
- Miller: Rise and shine for Oregon QB Masoli
- Five things to watch in the Pac-10
- Pac-10 predictions
Big East
- Maisel: Marrone ready to rebuild Syracuse
- Bennett: Big East race a jumble
- Bennett: Grothe, Selvie have Bulls focused
- Big East Predictions
- Five things to watch in the Big East
- SportsNation: Rank 'em
C-USA, MWC and WAC Preview
- Watson: Fletcher eyes redemption
- C-USA Predictions
- Five things to watch in C-USA
- SportsNation on C-USA: Rank 'em
- Watson: Pitta grows into BYU's main weapon
- Watson: Utah's gamble pays off
- MWC Predictions
- Five things to watch in the MWC
- SportsNation on MWC: Rank 'em
- Watson: Boise still the WAC team to beat
- WAC Predictions
- Five things to watch in the WAC
- SportsNation WAC: Rank 'em
- FBO: How good is the Non-BCS

Big Ten Preview
- Kiper: Top prospects for 2014, by position
- Recruiting: Michigan tops 2014 class ranks
- Haney: CFB's top 10 teams based on talent
- Kiper: Top QB prospects for 2014 | RBs | WRs
- Fremeau: Who will win the SEC? | Pac-12

























