The tournament's other favorite

Updated: March 20, 2006, 5:59 PM ET
By Graham Hays |


Cappie Pondexter cutting through defenders and banking in a pull-up jumper from the block. Matee Ajavon running ahead of defenders desperately trying to just keep her within reach. Kia Vaughn grabbing rebounds right and left. And nobody in a green uniform getting anything resembling an open look at the basket.

Everything was right in the world again for Rutgers.

Too bad it only lasted for four minutes.

Playing for the first time since losing to lowly West Virginia in the Big East tournament 13 days earlier, C. Vivian Stringer's team jumped out to a 13-0 lead on Dartmouth in a first-round game in Trenton, N.J. Granted, the Ivy League champs weren't expected to offer much resistance -- they dropped a first-round game against Connecticut by 48 points last year -- but any kind of easy win would help erase memories of the loss that likely cost Rutgers a No. 1 or 2 seed.

But when Dartmouth cut the lead to three with the ball and less than a minute to play in the game, it was Rutgers' 16-0 record in the conference regular season that was quickly vanishing from memory. The Scarlet Knights, aided by a dubious offensive foul on Dartmouth shooting star Angie Soriaga, pulled out the 63-58 victory, but it was an effort that took winning "ugly" to a whole new level.

The scary thing for Rutgers fans ought to be that, unlike the West Virginia game, the outcome wasn't entirely dictated by poor efforts on the part of Stringer's players. In particular, Ajavon bounced back from a poor Big East tournament performance with one of her best offensive outings. The sophomore finished with 19 points and capably handled point guard duties on occasion, freeing up Pondexter to play on the wing.

If Ajavon produces points and Pondexter scores like she's supposed to (team-leading 22 points against Dartmouth), other title contenders, never mind the Ivy League champs, shouldn't be within three points of Rutgers.

And while Stringer might disagree, Rutgers wasn't that bad on defense. The Big Green shot 39 percent from the floor and 37 percent from behind the arc. Neither number suggests Dartmouth had its way on the offensive end, but they show exactly how much the Scarlet Knights count on defensive excellence. Being merely good isn't enough for a team that wins by taking away every ounce of comfort an offense is used to having.

After the game, Stringer sounded as optimistic as a coach could be after nearly seeing her team become the first No. 3 seed to lose a first-round game. The coach told ESPN, "We're glad we won, but let's call this rusty after two weeks. Hopefully we can be much better, because if we don't, we're going to be in trouble."

The problem is Stringer offered a similar take after surviving a tough game against Villanova in the Big East quarterfinals. And in that case, her warning turned out to be prophetic.

Two weeks ago, Rutgers looked like a potential No. 1 seed and a legitimate national title contender. After games against Villanova, West Virginia and Dartmouth, the Scarlet Knights look like a flawed No. 3 seed.


OK, now she's got the dunk(s) checked off the list …

Tennessee's Candace Parker threw it down twice against Army on Sunday. Then afterward both she and coach Pat Summitt talked about it being a relief to "get it over with" and "get it out of the way."

I'm not sure how this great athletic move got turned into the equivalent of an IRS audit, but I suppose they didn't really mean it that way. Seems like Tennessee really is excited about Parker's feat, considering the headline on the school's Web site reads: "Candace Parker Dunks Twice as Lady Vols Roll to 102-51 Win Over Army."

The dunk has such a weird history in women's basketball. Weird in that Georgeann Wells did it two decades ago, then Charlotte Smith a decade ago, then Michelle Snow in the early part of this decade and now Candace Parker … and I keep wondering when it will stop being the athletic equivalent of a grand parlor trick and really make that firm step toward the commonplace in the women's game.

OK, maybe not "common" -- but certainly not rare. All along, I've thought the mental barriers to dunking have been a bigger deal than the physical ones. What I mean is, for the players who do have the physical capability.

For the majority of women's players, dunking is something they never even think about -- anymore than they'd think about jumping over the rim. It's just not an option, and they don't waste one second of time "working" on it.

However, those players who physically can do it are plagued with doubt about when they should even try. For example, here's what Parker said after Sunday's game: "I'm just going to approach the games like I've normally done it, and I'm not going to force anything. If it's a close game, no way, I will make the best decision for the team. I just thought it brought energy, and I'm not pressured to do it again."

Surely, Parker wasn't suggesting that when she dunked Sunday it wasn't the best decision for the team. If she can dunk, that is a high-percentage shot. That's good for your team. So why not do it in a close game?

I would assume it comes down to the fact that Parker still believes a lot more in her ability to make a layup than to dunk. And that's totally fine.

Don't think I'm criticizing her in anyway whatsoever. Maybe she'll feel differently as her career goes on and maybe she won't. That's something only someone of her athletic skill can determine.

Either way, she's still going to be one of the greatest players of her era. The ability to dunk got her four points on Sunday -- all the rest of her abilities added up to 22 more points, five rebounds, seven assists, four blocks and two steals. Wow, you look at that and you could almost wonder what the fuss about dunking is.

Well, it's really cool … that's what it is. And when you can do it, it's a smart play and an exciting one.

But the next real "step" -- if you will -- in the so-called "dunk evolution" in the women's college game is the player who says after she does it, "Well, of course I dunked. I can dunk. And next time I get an opening, I will dunk again. And the next time after that, I will do it again. And the next time …"

Mechelle Voepel of The Kansas City Star is a regular contributor to Reach her at


Candace Parker might have been the story of the day in the NCAA Tournament.

The dunk in women's basketball has long been a spectacle that means more to people who don't follow the game than those who do. The women's game isn't played above the rim, and the few instances of a player dunking were at best aberrations, and at worst, contrived sideshows.

But Parker's dunk was different. She dunked in the flow of the action, with a defender in close proximity, and with the outcome of an NCAA Tournament game still very much in doubt.

Parker's dunk is important not because she got her hand above the rim and scored two points by pushing the ball through the hoop, but because it highlights the player at the forefront of an athletic revolution in women's basketball.

Just as the physical training and conditioning that once made Tiger Woods stand alone in the world of pro golf are now par for the course, Parker's unique brand of athleticism is a sign of things to come in women's basketball.

Parker can rise above the rim to dunk, but at 6 feet, 3 inches, she can also run the Lady Vols from the point or guard the opposing center on defense. And those last two displays of athleticism are at least as impressive, if not as highlight-worthy, as her vertical skills.

Still, Parker's dunks, 26 points and career-best seven assists might not have been the most important development for her own team.

For those seeking a gauge on how Tennessee will ultimately fare in a region Pat Summitt wanted no part of, Alexis Hornbuckle's line of three points, seven rebounds and three assists was just as informative as Parker's brilliance.

Hornbuckle's availability for the postseason came as something of a surprise; she missed just seven games after breaking a bone in her hand against Vanderbilt on Feb. 12.

Playing with a soft cast to protect the screw now lodged at the base of the thumb on her right hand, Hornbuckle missed her first shot after coming off the bench against Army but spent the rest of her minutes proving she can be more than just an inspirational boost.

By winning the SEC tournament, Tennessee proved it could compete for a national title with Shanna Zolman and Parker running the offense.

But Hornbuckle's return at point guard gives the Lady Vols the best of both worlds, with Zolman and Parker distributing the ball better than ever but now freed from the pressure of constantly playing out of position.

Even with a day far quieter than her high-flying teammate, Hornbuckle showed that a region already loaded with contenders just got a little tougher.


Even Summitt excited
Pat Summitt doesn't do excited. But even Tennessee's coach was smiling after Candace Parker's dunks Sunday.

Dunks a game changer
The few instances of a woman dunking were at best aberrations, and at worst, contrived sideshows. Candace Parker changed all that Sunday.

Experts' take
Anyone who has a problem with Parker dunking is the grinch that stole March Madness. It shows off her athleticism, and that's what we love about sports.

Shantia Grace
AP Photo/Steve Helber
HEAD CASE: USC and Chloe Kerr (rear) are headed to the second round, despite a tough effort from Shantia Grace and South Florida.
4 -- The number of double-digit seeds to reach the Sweet 16 in the last five years.

Like the Super Bowl MVP, there is precedent for awarding the Dish's player-of-the-day honors to a player from a losing team. And Dartmouth's Angie Soriaga deserves to win something after scoring 23 points against Rutgers, including 20 in the second half, in one of the most entertaining shooting displays in recent memory.

Second on the team in both points and 3-pointers during the regular season, Soriaga set the tone for a second-half Dartmouth rally by recording her first points on a shot from just inside half court as time ran out in the first half. But Soriaga didn't just beat the buzzer, she seemed to beat physics (leave it to an Ivy Leaguer) by getting a shooter's bounce off the rim from 40 feet.

Throughout the second half, the ball seemed to find Soriaga whenever Dartmouth needed points with the shot clock running down. Having already scored 17 points in the half, she drilled a 3-pointer with 1:02 remaining to cut the deficit to three points. The game ended with the renowned Rutgers defense still unable to solve Soriaga, bailed out by an offensive foul call as the senior from College Station, Texas, moved into position for a potential game-tying shot with 18 seconds left.

Soriaga started every game of her college career, but she definitely saved the best for last.

The city of Hartford likes to market itself with the dubious moniker of "New England's Rising Star," but the slogan finally appears to accurately describe at least one thing in the colorless capital.

By scoring a 64-58 win against No. 6 seed Temple in Trenton, N.J., on Sunday, the 11th-seeded Hartford Hawks became just the second America East team to advance to the second round (following Maine in 1999). Jennifer Rizzotti's team is also one more upset away from moving on to Bridgeport, Conn., where the local Cinderellas would draw the kind of media attention usually reserved for the academic neighbors to the east at the University of Connecticut.

The Hawks have some NCAA Tournament experience of their own, but a lot of it shows up for games dressed in the coach's designer duds. Senior guards Danielle Wexler and Erika Messam, who were around for both of Hartford's first two trips to the NCAA Tournament, were instrumental in Sunday's upset, but a freshman, sophomore and junior led the way down the stretch.

Sophomore Danielle Hood led the Hawks with 18 points, just as she led a balanced attack in scoring during the regular season. And it was freshman Erica Beverly and junior Ikea Witt repeatedly stepping up in the final minutes, quelling a Temple rally that seemed destined to overcome the upstarts.

Rizzotti knows firsthand that building a program into a postseason juggernaut is a gradual process, but that's one piece of experience she might choose not to share with her young team.

Go figure. Even when five Pac-10 teams advance to the second round of the NCAA Tournament, the conference that plays while the East Coast media sleeps can't get the geographic spotlight to itself.

As chronicled by Mechelle Voepel on Saturday, the Mountain West emerged as the big winner among conferences in the first round of the NCAA Tournament (a showing further enhanced by No. 11 seed TCU upsetting Texas A&M on Sunday, sending all four MWC teams through to the next round).

But don't overlook the accomplishments of the five Pac-10 teams that advanced. Arizona State and Stanford entered their games as heavy favorites, but UCLA beat a ranked Bowling Green team, USC knocked off Big East invitee South Florida and Washington topped Big Ten foe Minnesota. Only Cal, playing No. 7 seed St. John's, came up short.

Fresh off a 5-0 first round in 2005, it's becoming clear that sticking with the underrated Pac-10 is a good way to score some easy wins in your bracket.

There is no way to spin the final game of Megan Duffy's career at Notre Dame, other than to say it's difficult to imagine an outcome less indicative of what she represented to Muffet McGraw's program.

Granted a reprieve after stumbling badly during the second half of the season, Notre Dame entered a first-round game with former Big East rival Boston College looking to finally live up to some of its preseason hype. Instead, the Irish looked on, somewhat passively, as the Eagles took them apart 78-61. Duffy finished with 15 points and four assists, handing over the reins to freshman Lindsay Schrader, who paced the Irish with 29 points.

A three-year starter (she also started five games as a freshman), Duffy came off a standout performance for Team USA in last summer's World University Games hoping to better back-to-back Sweet 16 appearances for the Irish the last two seasons. It didn't happen, as Duffy's unselfish, pass-first instincts didn't fit a team missing a go-to scorer like Jacqueline Batteast.

A point guard who found herself without a team to lead, Duffy quietly departs as one of the college game's most underrated floor generals.

You get the feeling Georgia's Andy Landers is the coach most likely to live out the scene in "Hoosiers" where Gene Hackman's character makes a point by continuing with four players instead of subbing in a player he's struggling to control. With a roster already effectively reduced to six players by injuries and other issues this season, Landers didn't make a single substitution during the first half against Marist, leaving regular starter Cori Chambers on the bench for all 20 minutes.

Without knowing the internal specifics, Landers presumably felt he had to bench Chambers, who returned and played well in the second half. But her initial absence underlines exactly how little depth the Bulldogs have. A seventh player, Desire Bostice, didn't check in for Georgia until the Bulldogs were up by 20 points and four minutes remained. Having missed an opportunity to rest the rotation during a first-round game that remained in doubt longer than most expected, Georgia's fate may rest on Landers' ability to find some rest, any rest, for his stars.

Times are changing in women's basketball. Parker was throwing down dunks, coach Kim Barnes Arico was leading St. John's to its first tourney win in 18 years and Rizzotti was leading Hartford to its first tourney win ever Sunday. But with progress comes change, and sometimes familiar faces get left behind.

For the fifth time in six years, Old Dominion is departing the tournament in the first round. Sunday's 87-72 loss to George Washington was all the tougher to swallow, coming on Old Dominion's turf in Norfolk, Va., at the hands of anything but a national power. That the Lady Monarchs continue to exert their influence over the Colonial Athletic Association is one thing, but this isn't a program used to annually playing the role of fodder for other contenders.

The good news for Wendy Larry's team is they lose only guard Lawona Davis from a young team that went 22-9 and pushed North Carolina to overtime in the regular season. But with yet another March disappointment on their minds, and with more and more programs, not to mention entire conferences, on the rise and receiving more exposure, it might be some time before we see ODU again return to the second week of play.

Graham Hays is a regular contributor to's women's basketball coverage. E-mail him at

Graham Hays covers college sports for espnW, including softball and soccer. Hays began with ESPN in 1999.