NEW YORK -- Maurice Clarett's lawyers contended Friday that the NFL bars younger college players from playing professional football to perpetuate a free farm system for the league.
The lawyers asked the judge to allow Ohio State's suspended
tailback to enter next year's NFL draft. Clarett sued the NFL this
year, challenging the league rule that a player must be out of high
school three years to be eligible for the draft.
The league wants the case tossed out. U.S. District Judge Shira
Scheindlin hopes to rule by Feb. 1.
The player's lawyers said in court papers that the NFL supports
the NCAA college football system to save the league tens of
millions of dollars in development and training.
"College football acts in effect as a minor league, for which
the NFL incurs no expenses," the lawyers said. "While major
league baseball teams each spend an average of $9 million annually
for the minor league system, the NFL teams spend virtually nothing
on a player development system."
The court papers called college football "a willing partner in
a cozy arrangement as it generates millions of dollars for the
colleges without their having to incur the expense of player
"Players who are otherwise able to compete with the best in
their profession must bide their time on the farm working for
nothing," the papers said.
Clarett is not eligible for the draft until 2005 under current
rules. The NFL, in court papers of its own, said Clarett's lawyers
were wrong to assert that blocking Clarett from the draft until
2005 was an unfair restraint of trade.
The league said its market is governed by a contract agreement
with a union representing players. The NFL said Clarett's claim
amounts "to an allegation that the eligibility rule will enable
another player to secure a roster position and compensation that,
in plaintiff's view, should be his own."
Ohio State suspended Clarett for the season. He is accused of
accepting money from a family friend and lying about it to NCAA and
university investigators. He ran for 1,237 yards and led Ohio State
to a national championship as a freshman last season.