New York jury acquits Chris Simms
"I'm really just happy it's all over with," a relieved but politely indignant Simms said as he left a Manhattan courthouse with his wife, Danielle. "I love the NYPD, and I'm mad that this happened."
Jurors, who deliberated for about an hour in the misdemeanor case, declined to comment as they left court.
Simms, the 30-year-old son of former New York Giants quarterback Phil Simms, was arrested around 1 a.m. July 1 at a police sobriety checkpoint in downtown Manhattan. He was heading home to New Jersey after going out to dinner with his wife and two friends.
A police officer told jurors that Simms made a tire-squealing turn just before the checkpoint, his Mercedes-Benz SUV reeked of marijuana and Simms himself was "like a zombie." Slurring his words, Simms said there wasn't any marijuana in the car because "he smoked it all," Officer Francisco Acosta testified.
Simms denied the allegations, and he said the officer misunderstood his remark.
"The comment I made to the officer is that there was someone in the car who smoked marijuana," Simms, who didn't testify at his trial, said after it ended. With his then-pregnant wife in the car, "I said, 'You're way off-base. I'm 30 years old, and I already have a 4-year-old at home.'"
A longtime friend, former Bryant University quarterback Charles Granatell, told jurors he was solely responsible for a marijuana scent the officer said was so strong it numbed his tongue. Granatell testified that he smoked pot by the SUV while Simms popped into another friend's 40th birthday party. The party's guest of honor, movie producer and nightclub owner Noel Ashman, told jurors Simms was "very, very lucid" during his stop there.
In her closing argument, Manhattan assistant district attorney Alexandra Glazer dismissed their accounts as "one not worthy of belief, and the other irrelevant." If Granatell was indeed the only one smoking marijuana that night, she asked, "wouldn't he have said something, instead of watching his friend get arrested in front of his eight-months-pregnant wife?"
The DA's office declined to comment after the verdict.
Simms took an alcohol breath test that came back negative, and he declined a urine test that could have shown drug use, if any. His lawyer, Harvey A. Steinberg, said Simms declined the urine test because he was frustrated that he was being arrested first and tested later.
"It's a case of rush to judgment," Steinberg said in his summation.
Simms had turned down a no-jail deal that would have involved pleading guilty to a noncriminal driving-while-impaired violation.
If convicted at the trial, Simms could have faced up to a year in jail. Besides the legal consequences, a conviction or any guilty plea that entailed admitting smoking marijuana could have subjected Simms to a suspension under NFL policies.
After Tampa Bay released him, he went to Tennessee in 2008, played for the Denver Broncos in 2009 as an unrestricted free agent and then returned to the Titans. The Titans released him in September but then re-signed him in November. He has a 7-9 record in his 16 NFL career starts; he didn't play in any games during the 2010 season.
With players locked out amid a contract dispute with the league, all teams' plans for next season are in limbo. The Titans have declined to comment on Simms' trial.
Simms' father played 14 seasons with the Giants, leading them to two Super Bowls. He is now a CBS Sports announcer and analyst.
Copyright 2011 by The Associated Press
The NFL on ESPN.com
WEEK 1 PICKS
MORE NFL COVERAGE
2011 NFL PREVIEW
JOHN CLAYTON QB RANKINGS
- Bill Williamson retweeted
- Paul Gutierrez retweeted
- Jamison Hensley retweeted
- Paul Gutierrez retweeted