Arms of Greatness: Ranking the best QBs by each decade
Jeffri Chadiha ranks the best pro quarterbacks in each decade.
It's not hard to make a list of the best quarterbacks ever. The difficulty lies in deciding how they rank within a particular decade. Not only must you determine exactly when players were at their best, you also have to weigh what means more: How they performed during an entire decade or how well they played during a certain number of years within that time period?
In the list below of the best quarterbacks in each decade, the only thing that can't be questioned is the overall merit of the players who made this list. When they were at their best, they established standards that defined their respective eras.
Quarterbacks really weren't allowed to showcase their arms in the early existence of pro football. Most teams saw the pass as a risky proposition and they believed firmly in controlling the ball with a relentless running attack. However, more talented quarterbacks started to enter the league in the late 1930s and into the 1940s. As they developed, so did the idea of what a quarterback could be.
On top of producing amazing numbers for his time -- he finished his career with 21,886 yards and 187 touchdown passes -- Baugh punted and played defensive back during the first seven years of his career. In fact, Baugh led the NFL in passing, punting and interceptions in 1943 and he still holds the league record for single-season punting (he averaged 51.4 yards per kick in 1940).Honorable Mention • Bob Waterfield, Cleveland Rams/Los Angeles Rams (1945-52)
• Otto Graham, Cleveland Browns (AAFC) (1946-55)
This was the decade when quarterbacks often were measured by their toughness. Many of the top signal-callers had an ample amount of guts, determination, poise and natural leadership ability. A few benefited from playing in more progressive offensives. But most earned their keep by operating as quintessential field generals.
When the Browns moved into the NFL in 1950, Graham was the leader who never let them think they couldn't thrive against tougher competition. He helped the Browns win three NFL titles and they also played in three other championship games. Add 'em up and that's 10 straight championship berths, a feat that is as impressive as Graham's career record of 105-17-10.Honorable Mention: • Norm Van Brocklin, Los Angeles Rams/Philadelphia Eagles (1949-60)
• Y.A. Tittle, San Francisco 49ers (1951-60)
• Bobby Layne, Detroit Lions(1950-58)
• Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts (1956-72)
Because there were two different leagues during these years -- the American Football League started in 1960 and merged with the NFL in 1969 -- there were basically two types of passers.
Most AFL quarterbacks loved throwing the ball all over the field and one, New York Jets quarterback Joe Namath, became pro football's first 4,000-yard single-season passer (he threw for 4,007 yards in 1967).
NFL teams, on the other hand, was far more conservative with their signal-callers. They liked quarterbacks who managed the game and limited their mistakes. Still, the best signal-caller of this decade played in the more established league.
Honorable Mention• Joe Namath, New York Jets (AFL) (1965-76)
• Bart Starr, Green Bay Packers (1956-71)
• Len Dawson, Kansas City Chiefs (AFL) (1963-75)
• Sonny Jurgensen, Philadelphia Eagles/Washington Redskins (1957-74)
• George Blanda, Houston Oilers (AFL) (1960-66)
These were the years when the NFL decided that offensive football needed a boost. Thanks to new rules, offensive lineman could use their hands more liberally while blocking, and receivers could run downfield with the knowledge that defenders had to limit their contact after five yards. Those two changes opened up a whole new world for pro quarterbacks. They haven't looked back.
A four-year commitment to the Navy prevented Staubach from beginning his NFL career until he was 27, yet he still produced extraordinary numbers (22,700 yards, 153 touchdowns and 2,264 rushing yards). He also didn't do too shabbily in the hardware department. With Staubach as the starter, the Cowboys won two Super Bowls while losing two more (yes, we know, to the Steelers).
One year really made all the difference in this decade: 1983. That's when the greatest draft class of quarterbacks entered the NFL, a group that included future Hall of Famers John Elway, Dan Marino and Jim Kelly among the six signal-callers selected in that year's first round. Nearly every team still wanted a classic, strong-armed quarterback to lead its offense, and that trio fit that description.
However, there was an ambitious, introspective head coach in San Francisco who had a different idea about where the passing game was going and what kind of quarterback could get him there. His name was Bill Walsh and his vision for the position involved a player with intelligence, accuracy and a feel for the game that couldn't be taught.
Of course, there were plenty of memorable highlights as well, including that 92-yard drive in the final minutes to beat the Cincinnati Bengals in Super Bowl XXIII. In fact, Montana isn't just the best quarterback of this decade. He is, without question, the best ever.
Honorable Mention• Dan Marino, Miami Dolphins (1983-99)
• John Elway, Denver Broncos (1983-98)
• Dan Fouts, San Diego Chargers (1973-87)
This was the decade when Bill Walsh's influence really changed the NFL landscape. As more members of his coaching tree moved into head coaching jobs -- men like Mike Holmgren, Mike Shanahan and Dennis Green -- more teams started running different versions of Walsh's West Coast system. By the mid-'90s, nearly half the league used some principles of that system. And most of them ran it so well that passing numbers skyrocketed during this 10-year period.
STEVE YOUNG, San Francisco 49ers (1987-99): It still seems unfair that the 49ers had two of the best quarterbacks in NFL history on the same roster. Young replaced Montana as a starter in 1991, and he picked up where his predecessor had left off.
Young won two NFL Most Valuable Player Awards during the 1990s, led the league in passing six times (a record he shares with Sammy Baugh) and retired with a league passer rating record (96.8 for his career) that might never be broken. He also won over Montana loyalists when he led the 49ers to a win over San Diego in Super Bowl XXIX.
Honorable Mention:• Brett Favre, Green Bay (1991-present)
• Troy Aikman, Dallas (1989-2000)
• Dan Marino, Miami Dolphins (1983-99)
• John Elway, Denver Broncos (1983-98)
• Jim Kelly, Buffalo Bills (1986-96)
• Warren Moon, Houston Oilers/ Minnesota Vikings/Seattle Seahawks/Kansas City Chiefs (1984-2000)
This has been the decade when football coaches have taken a more open-minded approach to what a quarterback should be. More teams now covet mobility in their signal-callers, with Pro Bowlers such as Philadelphia's Donovan McNabb, Tampa Bay's Jeff Garcia and former Atlanta quarterback Michael Vick serving as primary beneficiaries of this change in thinking.
Of course, there's still a place for the classic pocket passer in today's world. Just ask the fans in Indianapolis and New England.
• Tom Brady, New England Patriots (2000-present)
• Brett Favre, Green Bay Packers (1991-present)
• Donovan McNabb, Philadelphia Eagles (1999-present)
• Steve McNair, Houston Oilers-Tennessee Titans/Baltimore Ravens (1995-present)
Jeffri Chadiha covers the NFL for ESPN.com.
HOT READ: TOM BRADY
Patriots QB Tom Brady already has produced a record-setting regular season, and after this weekend, he could snag his fourth Super Bowl win. So where does he rank among the all-time greats? Check out our special two-part Hot Read on Brady.
Part I: Is Brady the best ever?• Sando: Ranking the all-time great QBs
• ZOOM gallery: Top 10 QBs of all time
• NFL Live: Who is greatest QB ever?
• Chadiha: Ranking the best QBs by decade
• Klancnik: Best QBs by jersey numbers
• Scouts Inc.: Ranking the top 64 QBs of today
• SportsNation: Rank the greatest QBs | Vote
• SportsNation: Think you know QBs?
• Super Bowls: Ranking every QB's performance
• Fantasy: Greatest Super Bowl QBs
Part II: Becoming a star• Garber: A perfect life ... but with insecurities
• Hashmarks: Remembering the Michigan days
• What would Tom say to others?
• The supermodel's family cheers for Brady
• Hill: Just call him Teflon Tom
SUPER BOWL XLII
In a rematch of their Week 17 game, the unbeaten Patriots will play the red-hot Giants in Super Bowl XLII in Glendale, Ariz.
Super Bowl Central
• Hashmarks blog: Mosley, Sando in Arizona
Commentary/Features• Chadiha: Giants miss Shockey
• Garber: Injured war vet inspires Giants
• Pasquarelli: The Pats' crucial cameos
• Merrill: Hixon's traumatizing season
• Football Outsiders: SB number crunching
• Pasquarelli: Patriots' silent sentinel
• Wojciechowski: Unflappable Eli
• Chadiha: Giants' rookies playing prominent role
• Fleming: Cardinals/Pottsville Curse
• Clayton: Youth serving Giants well
• Hashmarks: Media day coverage | Gallery
• Pasquarelli: Pats' old-school LBs
• Helyar: Marketing windfall for Eli Manning
• Garber: Seau's ring quest
• Pasquarelli: Bruschi's full-circle journey
• Animated plays
• Chadiha: Pierce just wants to win
• Wojciechowski: Explaining Bill Belichick
• Helyar: Recession? Not at Super Bowl!
• Giants' Snee doesn't stray from roots
• Sando: Seymour in eye of storm
• Merrill: Welker scales new heights for Pats
• Pasquarelli: Brady is ready to play
• Garber: The preservation of Plaxico
• Pasquarelli: Hill's spirit lives on
• Clayton: Giants' juggling act at CB works
• Wickersham: Giant ideas
• Klosterman: All too perfect
• Crown Jewels: A look at Super Bowl rings
• FB Outsiders: Giants one of worst SB teams
• Helyar: Patriots will drive TV ratings
• Clayton: First and goal
• Chadiha: Giants' glory road
• Mosley: Brady's ankle saves the week
• Woj: Preseason predictions revisited
• Merrill: David Woodley's dark spotlight
• Former SB QBs: Plunkett | Rypien | Ferragamo
• More: Morton | Humphries | Hostetler | Eason
• Starting matchups of Super Bowl QBs
• Ranking the QB performances: 1-40 | 41-82
• Jaworski: Six Super Bowl surprises
• Joyner: Brady's bad decisions
• Clayton: Eli's managing fine
• Chadiha: Focused Giants
• AccuScore simulation: Pats to prevail
• Chadiha: First Look at the Super Bowl
• Playoff schedule
Page 2• Hill: Teflon Tom Brady
• Hill: Raiders quit on Moss
• Flem File at the Super Bowl
• Fleming: Defining greatness
• Best teams never to win a title
• TMQ: Title-game analysis
• Why Boston teams are so good
• Gallo: Countdown to kickoff
News• Brady ankle not on injury report
• Brady on Plax prediction: Only 17 points for Pats?
• Carey named first black Super Bowl referee
• Brady practices in Pats' first Super Bowl session
• Ross gets sick as unified Giants face flu
• NFL not worried about spying
• Security high for Super Bowl
• Williams to be honored during Super Bowl
• Bootless Brady departs for Arizona
• Tickets reselling for average of $4,300
• Burress: Giants' receivers are better
Scouts Inc.• Scouts: Running-game breakdown
• Horton: Notes from the film room (Day 4)
• QB tale of the the tape
• Horton: Notes from the film room (Day 3)
• Ranking NFL QBs 1-64
• Take II on Super Bowl XLII
• Giants' DBs overmatched or underrated?
• Horton: Notes from film room (Day 2)
• Horton: 10 things to watch in SB XLII
• Horton: Notes from the film room (Day 1)
• A tale of two underrated O-lines
• Take I on Super Bowl XLII
• Players ranked Nos. 1-106
SportsNation• Vote: Which team will win?
• Vote: Who wins the head-to-head matchups?
• Vote: Which team are you rooting for?
• Conversation: Talk Super Bowl XLII
• Map: Which states are picking the Giants?
• Quiz: 42 Super Bowl history questions
• Chat: Hello from Arizona!
• Chat: Live from Media Day
• Chat: Prop bets, Subway's Jared and more!
• Rank: Super Bowl's best individual performances
• Rank: Super Bowl coaches
• Rank: Super Bowl careers
• Rank: Greatest all-time quarterbacks
• Vote: Potential for QB greatness?
• Quiz: Greatest quarterbacks