Bucs' Garcia in his comfort zone

Bucs QB Jeff Garcia, even more than Giants quarterback Eli Manning, may well have a greater impact on Sunday's playoff game than any other player, writes Greg Garber.

Originally Published: January 4, 2008
By Greg Garber |

Jeff GarciaGetty ImagesJeff Garcia has taken the 49ers, Eagles and Bucs to the playoffs. His 94.6 QB rating this season was seventh best in the league.
TAMPA, Fla. -- It may not be breaking national news, but the Buccaneers are back in the playoffs for the seventh time since 1997. For those of you scoring at home, only two teams have done better; as you might have imagined, the Patriots and Colts have earned a postseason berth eight times in the past 11 seasons.

The biggest reason for this season's playoff berth probably is Jeff Garcia. On Thursday morning, the quarterback sauntered into the interview room at One Buccaneer Place. As he sat down, Garcia discussed his tenuous ticket situation with a team official.

There will be pressure Sunday (1 p.m. ET, Fox) when the Bucs play host to the Giants in a wild-card game at Raymond James Stadium -- New York leads all teams in sacks -- but nothing like the stress induced by Garcia's friends and family seeking tickets to the game. The alternative -- being one of the NFL's 20 nonplayoff teams -- is worse, far worse, someone pointed out.

Best TD/INT Ratio
(Min. 100 TD passes)

Name TDs INTs Ratio
1. Tom Brady 197 86 2.29
2. Steve Young 232 107 2.17
3. D. McNabb 171 79 2.16
4. Pey. Manning 306 153 2.00
5. Joe Montana 273 139 1.96
6. Jeff Garcia 149 77 1.94

Garcia, his face a riot of freckles, smiled.

"Don't I know it," he said.

Indeed, he does. Garcia may well have a greater impact on this game than any other player because he, more often than not, determines whether the Bucs pass -- or fail. More eyes, of course, will be focused on Giants quarterback Eli Manning, but Garcia, one month from his 38th birthday, wasn't a No. 1 overall pick or a passer with an extraordinary pedigree. Garcia wasn't even drafted when he left San Jose State in 1994. And yet:

He will become the first quarterback in the Super Bowl era (1966) to start a playoff game for a division winner for three different franchises. And it's all happened in six years. The 6-foot, 205-pound player has posted numbers of historic significance but is inexplicably taking snaps for his fifth team in five years. Why, then, does he strike such fear into the hearts of the Giants?

Because his two career playoff victories have come against these same Giants. The oddsmakers, who favor Tampa Bay by a field goal, are predicting he'll go 3-for-3.

"This is a challenge for us to make sure it doesn't happen three times in a row," Giants defensive end Michael Strahan told New York reporters earlier this week.

Last Jan. 7, playing for injured Donovan McNabb, Garcia completed 17 of 31 passes for 153 yards and a touchdown as the Philadelphia Eagles ended the Giants' season with a 23-20 defeat. It was a cruel slice of symmetry for Strahan and the Giants, who suffered a catastrophic loss to Garcia and the San Francisco 49ers on Jan. 5, 2003.

The Giants held a comfortable lead, 38-14, with four minutes left in the third quarter, but led by Garcia, the 49ers scored 25 consecutive points. There were two touchdown passes from Garcia, to Terrell Owens and Tai Streets, a pair of two-point conversion catches by Owens and a 14-yard touchdown run by Garcia. San Francisco won 39-38 in the second-biggest comeback in NFL playoff history.

The Bucs allowed the fewest points in the NFC and have the NFL's No. 2 defense in terms of yards allowed (278.4), but it is Garcia who has put them over the top. Last season, with Bruce Gradkowski, Chris Simms and Tim Rattay taking the snaps, the Bucs went 4-12. Garcia signed a two-year contract for a reported $7 million in March and when head coach Jon Gruden couldn't talk Jake Plummer out of retiring, Garcia produced a terrific season. He threw 13 touchdown passes and only four interceptions and his passer rating (94.6) was the league's seventh-best figure.

This should come as no surprise. All of Garcia's playoff appearances have come in the comfort and safety of the scheme in which he operates best, the West Coast offense. It is not a coincidence that the father of that offense, the 49ers' late head coach, Bill Walsh, was a father figure to Garcia.

"We've watched Joe Montana do it, we've watched Steve Young do it, we've even watched Doug Flutie do it," Walsh said in a 2002 interview with ESPN. "We've seen any number of smaller men play the position as well as anybody.

"Jeff is a very intelligent player, he's instinctive and very mobile. He's got great nerve. As far as his performance from week to week and statistics, his ability to take the team from behind and win, his ability to make spontaneous plays, all of those are very comparable."

Sunday NFL Countdown's Greg Garber examines the special bond between Hall of Fame coach Bill Walsh and Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Jeff Garcia on "Sunday NFL Countdown. (ESPN, 11 a.m. ET)

To Hall of Fame quarterbacks Montana and Young, that is.

It was Walsh who encouraged Garcia when he went undrafted in 1994 and counseled him to seek his fortune in Canada. Garcia spent five seasons in Calgary, where he led the Stampeders to a CFL Grey Cup championship and was named game MVP. When Walsh returned to the 49ers in 1999, he promptly signed Garcia, who wound up starting 10 games that season when Young suffered what turned out to be a career-ending concussion.

Walsh died in late July of leukemia and before every game Garcia pays him tribute.

"I still pray and thank him before I go out on Sundays because of the opportunity that he gave me, the belief that he had in me," Garcia said. "There's not enough in this world, even when he was living, to give back to him as far as thanks is concerned."

Perhaps there is.

"I really was in a lot of ways playing for him, especially when the illness got pretty deep," Garcia said. "I knew he looked forward to every Sunday, to be able to turn on the TV and be able to watch me play."

Consider the favor returned.

Greg Garber is a senior writer for

Jeff Garcia's journey

Quarterback Jeff Garcia has played for five teams in the past five seasons. Improbably, he carries his third different team into the playoffs in the past six years. -- Greg Garber

2003 San Francisco 49ers
After leading the San Francisco 49ers to back-to-back playoff appearances and being voted to three consecutive Pro Bowls, Garcia takes the 49ers to a 7-9 record under first-year coach Dennis Erickson. He throws 18 TDs and 13 INTs but is eventually supplanted by backup Tim Rattay.
2004 Cleveland Browns
After signing as a free agent in Cleveland, Garcia plays in the first 10 games but throws only one pass in the remaining six games. The Browns, coached by Butch Davis and Terry Robiskie, go 4-12. The following year Cleveland has a new coach (Romeo Crennel) and a new quarterback (Trent Dilfer).
2005 Detroit Lions
Playing behind Joey Harrington, Garcia manages only five starts for the Detroit Lions, in large part because of a fractured fibula suffered in the preseason. For the second straight year, Garcia's team has two coaches (Steve Mariucci and Dick Jauron) and a losing team (5-11).
2006 Philadelphia Eagles
Signed as a free agent by the Philadelphia Eagles, Garcia doesn't play in eight of the first nine games, but when starter Donovan McNabb suffers a knee injury, Garcia goes on to win six straight games, including a wildcard game over the Giants.
2007 Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Garcia's success in Philadelphia allows him to sign a free-agent contract with Tampa Bay. He goes 8-5 as a starter and leads the Bucs to the playoffs with the second-best passer rating (94.6) in franchise history.

Greg Garber

Writer, Reporter
Greg Garber joined ESPN in 1991 and provides reports for NFL Countdown and SportsCenter. He is also a regular contributor to Outside the Lines and a senior writer for