Complete: Overall First Pick | First Round
| YEAR | PK(OVR) | NAME | POS | SCHOOL |
| 2003 | 25(25) | WILLIAM JOSEPH | DT | Miami (FL) |
| 2002 | 14(14) | JEREMY SHOCKEY | TE | Miami (FL) |
| 2001 | 22(22) | WILL ALLEN | DB | Syracuse |
| 2000 | 11(11) | RON DAYNE | RB | Wisconsin |
| 1999 | 19(19) | LUKE PETITGOUT | OT | Notre Dame |
| 1998 | 24(24) | SHAUN WILLIAMS | DB | UCLA |
| 1997 | 7(7) | IKE HILLIARD | WR | Florida |
| 1996 | 5(5) | CEDRIC JONES | DE | Oklahoma |
| 1995 | 17(17) | TYRONE WHEATLEY | RB | Michigan |
| 1994 | 24(24) | THOMAS LEWIS | WR | Indiana |
| 1992 | 14(14) | DEREK BROWN | TE | Notre Dame |
| 1991 | 27(27) | JARROD BUNCH | RB | Michigan |
| 1990 | 24(24) | RODNEY HAMPTON | RB | Georgia |
