Buffalo robbed of best chance to win Stanley Cup

Originally Published: November 22, 2004
The Hockey News

GREAT DEBATES
The Hockey News
Purchase at thehockeynews.com
Goal or no goal?
Writers' choice
A panel of 41 writers were asked their opinions on various great debates in hockey. Multiple choices were not provided so as not to color the outcome.
Goal? Votes
No goal 30
Goal 11
Fans' choice
Either fans agree that Brett Hullıs Cup-winning goal in 1999 was tainted by a foot in the crease, or a majority of our readers reside in the Buffalo area.
Goal? Votes
No goal 65.8%
Goal 33.7%
It's fitting the last goal scored when the NHL's ridiculous "toe-in-the-crease" rule was, in effect, clouded with controversy.

Somewhat fitting also is that half-a-decade later, a mere mention of Brett Hull's 1999 Stanley Cup-clinching tally can cause a stirring debate. It also raises the ire of any member of the Buffalo Sabres.

The Dallas Stars' lone Cup victory isn't tainted. Nor should it put a black mark on Hull's magnificent career. The fact remains, under the rules implemented to protect the goaltenders, the triple-overtime Cup-winning goal in Game 6 in Buffalo should never have counted.

The evidence, concrete thanks to the magic of video tape, clearly proves the case against it.

Hull clearly had his left skate in the crease as he dumped the puck past Buffalo goaltender Dominik Hasek. Worse yet, based on the rule at the time, his little piggies were in the blue paint before the puck was on his stick ­ in the split second after Hasek made the save and it ricocheted off a Sabres defenseman's skate.

The final statement against said goal is that the puck was out of the crease when Hull's skate went in it and before it was on his stick.

A steady stream of less important goals were denied all season for the very same reason.

The situation, naturally, was made all the worse by the fact there was no video replay done at the time.

Remember, this was the season when seemingly every goal came with two celebrations. The first one coming immediately after the puck crossed the line and the red light came on, and the second after the officials talked on a telephone for an eternity before finally pointing to center ice.

COUNTERPOINT:
Goal should have counted
Although Hull did have one skate in the crease, he had control of the puck first. When Hull got the puck on the rebound of Mike Modano's shot, he kicked it with his left skate to his stick outside the crease, pivoting his left skate into the crease.

The play was reviewed and officials made the correct call based on what they saw in slow motion. And because the review process was completed quickly, there was no reason to make an announcement over the public address system.

Because the game was in Buffalo and the Stanley Cup was on the line, the safest thing would have been to deny the goal.

But for once the NHL did not take the easy way out. Kudos to its officials.
For some reason, the officiating crew didn't use the technology created by Alexander Graham Bell.

Curiously, the league later said a video review team watched the replay from several angles, deemed it to be a goal and called down in time. (If you think that smacks of a contrived statement made on the spot, you're not alone. It's very similar to the statement released after Game 6 of last year's final regarding the question about Martin Gelinas' potential Cup winner).

Anyway, amidst the pandemonium and celebration, the NHL didn't have the kahunas to deny the goal, tell everyone to return to their positions and wait for a legit goal to end the match. Maybe they didn't want to bother all the photographers who had stormed the ice.

The good news is it served as the final crushing blow for the "toe-in-the-crease" rule that was abolished days later for the more reasonable "no-harm, no-foul" position that served the purpose those 75 years before and ever since.

Well, that and the fact it finally ended the most mind-numbingly dull Stanley Cup final in history -- but that's another debate.

The Hockey News Material from The Hockey News.
To subscribe, visit The Hockey News web site at: http://www.thehockeynews.com

SPONSORED HEADLINES

ALSO SEE

MORE NHL HEADLINES

MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM