Pittsburgh 4, 
Washington 3
Play-by-play data may not reflect changes made after the game has ended.
| OT Summary | ||
| TIME | TEAM | DETAIL |
| 0:00 | Pittsburgh | Sidney Crosby won faceoff against Dave Steckel |
| 0:11 | Pittsburgh | Giveaway by Brooks Orpik |
| 0:16 | Washington | Matt Bradley shot blocked by Brooks Orpik |
| 0:23 | Washington | Dave Steckel shot blocked by Kris Letang |
| 0:28 | Washington | Brian Pothier credited with hit on Sidney Crosby |
| 0:30 | Washington | Stoppage - Net Off Moorings |
| 0:30 | Pittsburgh | Shot missed by Sidney Crosby(Wide of Net) |
| 0:30 | Washington | Boyd Gordon won faceoff against Jordan Staal |
| 0:48 | Washington | Nicklas Backstrom shot blocked by Hal Gill |
| 1:04 | Washington | Giveaway by Alexander Semin |
| 1:08 | Pittsburgh | Shot on goal by Tyler Kennedy (Slapshot 47 ft) |
| 1:29 | Pittsburgh | Shot on goal by Evgeni Malkin (Backhand 15 ft) |
| 1:29 | Washington | Penalty to Milan Jurcina 2 minutes for Tripping Evgeni Malkin |
| 1:29 | Washington | Shorthanded - Boyd Gordon won faceoff against Sidney Crosby |
| 1:37 | Washington | Shorthanded - Dave Steckel credited with hit on Evgeni Malkin |
| 1:59 | Pittsburgh | Power play - Takeaway by Sidney Crosby |
| 2:11 | Pittsburgh | Power play - Shot missed by Bill Guerin(Wide of Net) |
| 2:19 | Pittsburgh | Power play - Evgeni Malkin shot blocked by John Erskine |
| 2:54 | Washington | Shorthanded - John Erskine credited with hit on Evgeni Malkin |
| 3:15 | Washington | Shorthanded - Takeaway by Dave Steckel |
| 3:20 | Washington | Shorthanded - Shot missed by Dave Steckel(Over Net) |
| 3:28 | Pittsburgh | Goal scored by Evgeni Malkin (Power Play) assisted by Chris Kunitz |
NHL Scores
Saturday, May 9th
| Pittsburgh | 4 | Final |
| Washington | 3 | OT |
| Chicago | 4 | Final |
| Vancouver | 2 |