"Now you're about 135 behind me," the grizzled veteran said, laughing. "Not that I'm counting."
Kariya actually trails Tkachuk by 137 goals. Yet, this one was more than a milestone. It snapped a third-period tie and lifted the Blues to a 4-3 victory over the New York Rangers on Thursday night.
Trying to repeat their late run of a year ago that secured a playoff berth, the 10th-place Blues closed within five points of Detroit, which sits at the postseason cutoff in the Western Conference.
"I never really pay too much attention to stats," the 35-year-old Kariya said. "It's a nice milestone but the two points were more important. We're in a desperate situation where we need wins. It was nice to get the 400th in a win."
The Blues registered only 16 shots -- a season low for them and the fewest allowed by New York -- and took advantage of uncharacteristically shaky Rangers goalie Henrik Lundqvist.
St. Louis scored four times on its first 14 shots and handed the Rangers a key loss in their pursuit of an Eastern Conference playoff spot. New York fell behind Atlanta into 10th place and trails eighth-place Boston by three points with 11 games left.
Rangers coach John Tortorella stressed after Tuesday's loss to Montreal that his club needed to beat St. Louis. It didn't happen. That makes New York's next game at Boston on Sunday more critical.
"Still in the race," Tortorella said. "They're not down. There is no sense of being down. It's just a matter of getting ready to play another game and try to win."
Just 1:13 after Wade Redden got the Rangers even at 3, Kariya took a feed in front from T.J. Oshie and scored his milestone goal.
Redden's first in 58 games gave the Rangers brief life that Kariya took away. Marian Gaborik had a goal and two assists, and Ryan Callahan also scored for New York, which has lost six of eight (2-4-2).
"Our focus needs to be on the next game," captain Chris Drury said. "That's all we can be thinking about right now, which happens to be the team we're chasing."
Weaver tied it at 2 at 2:21 of the second after the Rangers failed to clear the puck. Weaver let go a shot from inside the blue line that eluded Lundqvist. The New York netminder banged his stick and was still shaking his head side to side when the teams lined up for the ensuing faceoff.
The defenseman hadn't scored a goal since March 23, 2007. He chuckled as he tried to figure out how many games he would need to play to catch Kariya in goals.
"It really didn't bother me," Weaver said of his drought. "I pretty much ignored it every single time. It wasn't a big thing for me. I'm not a goal scorer so I don't really focus on that."
Lundqvist's rough game got worse 3:24 later when Johnson sent a seemingly tame shot from the right wing boards that sneaked in between his pads during a power play. Lundqvist fought the puck all night. Despite putting only 10 pucks on net, St. Louis carried a 3-2 lead into the third.
"The third goal is a bad goal, but the rest of the goals were pretty tough plays," Lundqvist said. "I still feel like I could have played better.
"It is very disappointing to be in this position, but we have to stay positive and try to turn this thing around."
New York held the Blues to six shots in the first period and took a 2-1 edge.
St. Louis got the jump for the second straight game. It wasn't as quick as Alex Steen's team record-tying goal 8 seconds into Tuesday's home loss to Colorado, but still fast.
Boyes staked the Blues to a 1-0 lead 1:10 in. St. Louis won a faceoff in the Rangers end and dug out the puck in the corner. It came to Boyes in the left circle and he zipped a shot over Lundqvist's glove for his 13th goal.
Olli Jokinen fired a shot from the center blue line that hit Callahan in front and caromed in to make it 1-1 at 5:52 of the first. Gaborik pushed the Rangers ahead with 2:52 left in the period when his shot hit the stick of defenseman Carlo Colaiacovo and fluttered past Conklin's glove for his 37th goal.
The Rangers had a 5-on-3 power play for 1:17 of the third after consecutive delay-of-game penalties. ... St. Louis has earned 1,400 points on the road. ... St. Louis is 5-4-2 in its last 11 visits to New York. ... The Blues, 21-11-4 on the road, have won seven of their last 10 away games.
Copyright by STATS LLC and The Associated Press
Arena: Madison Square Garden Location: New York, New York
Referees: Kevin Pollock, Dean Morton Linesmen: Scott Cherrey, Jean Morin
Attendance: 18,200 (101.1% full)
Team Stat Comparison
Power Play Goals
Power Play Opportunities
Shots on Goal
Brad Boyes (13)
Assists: Jay McClement, Alexander Steen
Ryan Callahan (19)
(Power Play) Assists: Olli Jokinen, Marian Gaborik
Marian Gaborik (37)
Assists: Vinny Prospal, Wade Redden
Mike Weaver (1)
Erik Johnson (7)
(Power Play) Unassisted
Wade Redden (2)
Assists: Marian Gaborik, Brandon Dubinsky
Paul Kariya (16)
Assists: T.J. Oshie, David Backes