Updated: April 4, 2008, 11:47 AM ET

  • Comment
  • Email
  • Share

AP Photo

Neither Rich Harden nor Jon Lester gave up a run on Wednesday.

Lester, Harden excel in duel

The two things that scare me the most about starting pitchers are walks and injuries. I'll take a chance on wild, brittle pitchers on rare occasions, but let's just say Jon Lester and Rich Harden aren't two pitchers I was targeting this spring. After Wednesday's outing, in which neither permitted a run, I might have to rethink how I feel about them.

The fact is fantasy owners are not ignoring either of these pitchers, and never really have, despite the shortcomings they possess. Feel-good story Lester was owned in too many leagues a year ago, mainly because of what he overcame to even get back to the field, and also due to the popular team he plays for. All of it, however, masked an ugly career WHIP. Lester entered Wednesday's outing at offensively challenged Oakland with a career 4.79 ERA and 1.58 WHIP. The numbers don't lie. It's tough to be successful when you're a hittable lefty with such a high walk rate. A week ago in Japan, Lester walked three and allowed four runs in four innings. Despite this, he was owned in nearly half of ESPN's standard mixed leagues. It must be the name.

Harden's ability has never been questioned, but staying healthy is a skill, and that's where the tantalizing right-hander has consistently fallen short. Harden entered Wednesday with a career 3.58 ERA and 1.25 WHIP, and 440 strikeouts in 470 innings. Unlike Mark Prior, for example, he still appears to have similar stuff as he did before all the injuries and missed time. Harden started a total of 32 games from 2005-07, even though he teases us statistically. I just don't want to invest in a pitcher who can't pitch enough to lead a fantasy team to a title. Harden has pitched twice against the Red Sox and allowed one run and seven hits in 11 innings, fanning 15. He's owned in just about every one of ESPN's standard mixed leagues. If I owned him, I'd be testing the market.

The same goes for Lester, really. Fantasy is about value, and right now these two pitchers, each with a flaw we still have little evidence will be conquered this season, if ever, are wise sell-high options. Then again, there are only so many pitchers like Greg Maddux, guys who avoid walks and the disabled list. Whatever will I do when he retires?

Highlights
Get ADOBE® FLASH® PLAYER
Box Score Bits
Martin Prado filled in ably for the injured Kelly Johnson (knee) with a single, a triple and three runs scored. The 24-year-old hit .316 at Triple-A Richmond last season. He doesn't have the power or speed to appeal to fantasy owners, but he might earn playing time even when Johnson returns to the lineup later this week. ... Arizona's Chris Young didn't do much walking as a rookie, but the three free passes he drew on Wednesday are a terrific sign that he understands the significance of plate discipline. If he gets on base more, he can steal more bases and score more runs. ... Joey Votto earned the start at first base for the Reds and was 1-for-3. There was no sign of Scott Hatteberg. This might be the first lefty-lefty first base platoon in history, and it helps nobody. Wonderful. ... The Indians didn't turn their lineup upside down sans catcher Victor Martinez, but it was interesting to see Jhonny Peralta moved up to Martinez's No. 3 lineup spot, not Travis Hafner or Ryan Garko. Peralta, who went 0-for-5 and scored a run Wednesday, spent more than a third of his at-bats in the No. 3 spot over the past three seasons but didn't produce a higher slugging percentage in the role (.439 hitting third, .442 overall). A better lineup position doesn't always translate to bigger stats. ... The Juan Pierre saga continues. Coming off the bench in the ninth inning to bunt a runner to second base, Pierre failed but reached first base on a fielder's choice. Then he took off for second base as Rafael Furcal struck out, and Bengie Molina threw him out to end the game. This can't help gain Pierre playing time. ... While there were a number of fine, unexpected pitching performances on Wednesday, the first thing on my mind is how angry Tim Lincecum and Chad Billingsley owners must be. Giants-Dodgers was slated to be a matchup of these young right-handers. Well, it was, but not until the middle innings. With the threat of rain looming, Merkin Valdez and Hong-Chi Kuo were summoned within 20 minutes of the first pitch to start the game. Lincecum and Billingsley each entered the game in relief. Lincecum allowed eight baserunners in four innings but did earn the win. Billingsley gave up two hits and a run, while retiring only one hitter. Don't fret, fantasy owners, these guys are starting pitchers going forward, and good ones, assuming their managers don't panic with a bad forecast. ... Tim Redding threw a gem at Philly's bandbox, permitting one hit over seven-plus scoreless innings. Redding isn't a safe fantasy option, despite his understated 3.64 ERA in 15 starts a season ago. ... In Minnesota, 26-year-old rookie Nick Blackburn stymied the Angels for seven innings, allowing his only run on a wild pitch. Blackburn could stay in the Twins rotation even after Francisco Liriano rejoins the team. ... Joe Saunders outdueled Blackburn with eight scoreless innings and should be a popular pickup for his next outing. Just be careful here; Saunders does not have overpowering stuff, and his 1.51 WHIP wasn't helpful in 2007. ... As for Brian Bannister, most fantasy experts have been skeptical about his breakout 2007, based on a low strikeout rate, but he dominated the Tigers. I'd trust Bannister, who is owned in 3.2 percent of ESPN standard leagues, ahead of Redding, Blackburn and Saunders.


ESPN Conversation
Standing Out
WEDNESDAY'S BEST
Oliver Perez, Mets
Think last year was a fluke? Perez struck out eight and -- most importantly -- walked only one in six scoreless innings. Next up? The Phillies at home on Tuesday.




WEDNESDAY'S WORST
Brandon Lyon, Diamondbacks
Three hits, three earned runs, one blown save and exactly zero innings. ERA? Null. WHIP? Null. Time to get Tony Pena on the phone (and on your roster).



Sleepless In Seattle
On the same day that J.J. Putz landed on the disabled list with a strained rib cage, former Blue Jays closer Miguel Batista earned the save for the Mariners. Batista is still slotted as the No. 5 starter, so he's unlikely to be the full-time replacement. Who is?
Fantasy Spin
News and Notes

Lou Piniella shared a few bits of info with reporters after Wednesday's game. According to the Cubs Web site, he surmised the forearm cramps that forced ace Carlos Zambrano to leave his opening day start early were caused by low potassium levels. Now that the team knows this, we'd assume it won't happen again. Zambrano should make his next scheduled start. Second, the rarely-patient Piniella has decided that Alfonso Soriano is 0-for-9 because he's not comfortable hitting in the No. 2 lineup spot. Soriano and Ryan Theriot will switch spots. This shouldn't have much fantasy relevance for statistical purposes, however, unless it really did matter to Soriano. In 2007, Soriano never hit in the No. 2 spot, with 542 of his 579 at-bats coming in the leadoff role. ... With the Nationals facing a serious lack of outfield depth, benched middle infielder Felipe Lopez was seen taking fly balls in left field, just in case. Willie Harris is the nominal starter for now. Lopez could be a major base-stealer for fantasy owners,if he gets playing time, and beating out Harris could be easier than beating out Cristian Guzman or Ronnie Belliard. Dukes, incidentally, has been diagnosed with a Grade 2 hamstring strain, and it's looking unlikely he'll return in April. ... According to MLB.com, Scott Kazmir threw 44 pitches in a 13-minute bullpen session Wednesday and said he expects to rejoin the team later in April.

Transactions
Mariners• To replace J.J. Putz on the roster, the Mariners recalled Roy Corcoran from Triple-A Tacoma. Corcoran, 27, has struck out a batter per inning in his minor league career but is a journeyman unlikely to have fantasy value.

Phillies• The Phillies designated Wes Helms for assignment. Helms didn't hit in 2007, but that shouldn't stop a team like the Dodgers from taking a look. Blake DeWitt has five hits in nine at-bats so far, but fantasy owners should be aware the Dodgers haven't committed to him.
They Wrote It

"So how realistic is it to expect [Pedro] Martinez to return to the Mets' rotation in the first two weeks of May? And how effective will he be when he returns from this latest setback? The answer is complicated and there are a number of factors to consider, but the projected timetable for Martinez seems optimistic."
-- Stephania Bell Full Story


"Rich Harden is going to be the single biggest difference-maker available for trade before the July 31 deadline. If the guy continues to take the ball -- two starts and counting, for a pitcher who has worked only 200 innings the last three years -- he will always take Cy Young-caliber stuff to the mound. "
-- Buster Olney Full Story