Originally Published: December 4, 2006

Scorecard: Cotto impressive in welterweight debut

Dan Rafael recaps last week's notable boxing results from around the world.

Print Share
Rafael By Dan Rafael
ESPN.com
Archive


A roundup of last week's notable boxing results from around the world:

Saturday at Atlantic City, N.J.
Welterweight
Miguel Cotto TKO5 Carlos Quintana
Wins a vacant welterweight title.
Records: Cotto, 28-0, 23 KOs; Quintana, 23-1
Rafael's remark: Cotto was simply sensational. He performed like a star, won his second world title after moving up from junior welterweight, earned his first seven-figure payday ($1.1 million) and, at age 26, set himself up for monster future business.

There was nothing not to like about the fight and kudos to Showtime for helping make it happen. The first round was nothing but blazing action and the rest of the fight was also highly entertaining. Quintana, 30, fighting his more heralded Puerto Rican countryman, was a virtual unknown before a June upset of Joel "Love Child" Julio. And although he came up short against Cotto, Quintana covered himself in glory with the way he fought. The mere fact that he got to his feet after one of the most savage body shots we have ever seen is a testament to his heart. He got up from a second knockdown in the fifth round, too, before the fight was properly stopped after the round.

There's no reason Quintana can't rebound from the loss. Surely, fans will want to see him again after this performance. Of course, Quintana would have rather won because if he had, he probably would have vacated the title in order to face Shane Mosley for a serious payday in February. We're told that a deal had been agreed to for Quintana to forgo a mandatory fight with Oktay Urkal for the Mosley match.

The weight gain seemed to help Cotto, who had a lot of energy and was throwing bombs. He's going to be even better at 147 pounds than he was at 140. Next, he'll face Urkal, who stepped aside to allow the Quintana match to happen. They could fight in late February or March, but after Cotto beats Urkal (which he will), it should be nothing but big fights for Cotto, perhaps even a showdown with Top Rank stablemate and fellow welterweight titlist Antonio Margarito, who won in the co-feature. We're just so excited about potential big Cotto fights, we can hardly contain it. The one question about Cotto's future is this: Will Showtime try to keep him (it does have a position on his next fight) or will HBO, which mistakenly passed on this card, realize the error of its ways and pull out the checkbook?

Welterweight
Antonio Margarito W12 Joshua Clottey
Retains a welterweight title.
Scores: 118-109, 116-112 (twice)
Records: Margarito 34-4; Clottey 30-2
Rafael's remark: Margarito was in a tough spot with this fight: Win and few would give him much credit, lose and it's a disaster. Well, he did win -- pretty easily after a slow start -- and we want to give him credit for the victory. Clottey is a very tough customer and would have been a handful for just about any welterweight in the world. He's quick and has decent power and a great chin. He did very well in the first four rounds until badly hurting his left hand, which took him totally out of his game.

Margarito, coming off a 10-month layoff , started to come on at about the same time Clottey hurt his hand and slowly took over the fight, despite his own wrist injury. Margarito is like the little engine that could, and as long as he keeps grinding out the victories, eventually he'll get that big-time fight he wants so badly. He's obligated to fight mandatory contender Paul Williams next, which is a tough fight. But if Margarito, who has made seven title defenses, can get through it, he finally might reach the promised land. Obviously, we'd love to see him fight Miguel Cotto, who starred in the main event.

Saturday at Tampa, Fla.
Middleweight
Winky Wright W12 Ike Quartey
Scores: 117-110 (twice), 117-109
Records: Wright, 51-3-1; Quartey, 37-4-1
Rafael's remark: Is anyone surprised by this result? You shouldn't be, because it went exactly the way most people expected, which is why we are still scratching our heads as to why HBO wasted in the neighborhood of $3 million-plus to buy a non-competitive match, especially when it could have had the less expensive (and superior) Miguel Cotto/Antonio Margarito doubleheader that Showtime smartly picked up.

Wright, coming off his June draw with middleweight champ Jermain Taylor, was just too big for Quartey, a former welterweight champ who recently has been fighting at junior middleweight. His power was ineffective against Wright, who is bigger, stronger and a far superior technician. It was really the first time in Quartey's career that he was dominated; his other losses were in close fights with Oscar De La Hoya and Fernando Vargas and a bad decision against Vernon Forrest in August. But we don't blame Quartey for taking the fight -- he made $1 million. He'll be better served returning to junior middleweight, where he can compete with the best fighters.

Wright, fighting in his hometown for the first time since 1992, was trying to put the Taylor debacle behind him and his subsequent insane rejection of $5 million for a rematch. Wright won easily, scored two dubious knockdowns and threw more than 1,000 punches. It was a good performance from Wright, but one no one needed to see. Now, Wright is calling out De La Hoya (who co-promoted the fight). If De La Hoya beats Floyd Mayweather in May, it is conceivable the fight could happen. That would be worth watching.

Super middleweight
Jeff Lacy W10 Vitali Tsypko
96-94 (twice), 95-95
Records: Lacy, 22-1; Tsypko, 17-2
Rafael's remark: Former beltholder Lacy escaped with a majority decision in his hometown in a fight that many people believe he lost. Although it was an entertaining fight because they traded clean shots throughout the match, it was not the sharp performance Lacy probably was looking for in his first fight since taking an absolute beating from Joe Calzaghe in their March unification fight.

Lacy might never return to his old form. Not only did Calzaghe physically torture him, but Lacy probably has spent the past nine months mentally tortured by the loss. If Lacy's problems are mental, they can be overcome. If they are physical, we could be looking at the next David Reid, who, like Lacy, was a highly touted American Olympian whose career was ruined early by a crushing loss [in Reid's case, to Felix Trinidad].

Lacy and Tyspko had met before, in a 2004 elimination fight. But it ended in the second round because Tsypko, of Ukraine, suffered a bad cut from an accidental head butt. In the rematch, there was another accidental head butt that opened a cut over Tsypko's eye, but it wasn't nearly as bad the one in 2004. Lacy, who said he hurt his shoulder in the second round, dominated the first few rounds before Tsypko found a groove. He badly rocked Lacy at the end of the eighth round and dominated the final four rounds to do enough, it seemed, to win.

Junior featherweight
Rey Bautista TKO4 Giovanni Andrade
Records: Bautista, 21-0, 16 KOs; Andrade, 52-10
Rafael's remark: Bautista, just 20 and signed to Golden Boy Promotions, is considered one of the best prospects from the Philippines and a possible heir apparent to Manny Pacquiao as the nation's No. 1 fighter. He also happens to be trained by Freddie Roach, who also works with Pacquiao. Bautista stayed undefeated when Andrade stayed on his stool after the bell rang to begin the fourth round. Bautista, coming off a broken collarbone, did most of his damage to Andrade with a punishing body attack.

Saturday at Osaka, Japan
Junior bantamweight
Nobuo Nashiro W12 Eduardo Garcia
Retains a junior bantamweight title.
Scores: 118-110, 117-112 (twice)
Records: Nashiro, 9-0; Garcia, 17-5
Rafael's remark: Nashiro amazingly won a world title in only his eighth fight when he stopped Martin Castillo on cuts to take the title in July in a major upset. Making his first defense, Nashiro, 25, outpointed his former sparring partner in a fight that reportedly was more difficult for Nashiro than the scores might indicate. Nashiro is expected to face Castillo in a rematch next year.

Saturday at Berlin
Middleweight
Mariano Carrera TKO11 Javier Castillejo
Wins a middleweight title.
Records: Carrera, 30-4, 21 KOs; Castillejo, 61-7
Rafael's remark: Carrera, of Argentina, joined countryman Carlos Baldomir in pulling off an upset this year. Although Carrera's isn't as big as the two pulled by Baldomir, it was still a surprise. Carrera wasn't supposed to give Castillejo, 38, too many problems in advance of an expected rematch next year with Felix Sturm, whom Castillejo had knocked out in an upset to win a belt in July. Instead, Castillejo, of Spain, got knocked out, and now Carrera, 26, is likely to make his first defense against Sturm. According to promoter Universum, the fight was a competitive action battle until the 11th round, when Carrera finally overwhelmed Castillejo with a series of unanswered punches.
Middleweight
Felix Sturm TKO6 Gavin Topp
Records: Sturm, 26-2, 12 KOs; Topp, 20-3-2
Rafael's remark: Sturm, of Germany, bounced back from his upset 10th-round knockout loss to Javier Castillejo in July in which Castillejo took Sturm's belt. Sturm, whose only other loss was a controversial decision to Oscar De La Hoya, cut Topp over the left eye in the fifth. The cut got worse in the sixth and the fight was stopped with the Australian unable to continue.

Sturm was hoping a victory combined with a Castillejo win on the same card would lead to a rematch next year. However, Castillejo got knocked out, meaning Sturm now will get a shot against Castillejo's conqueror, Mariano Carrera.

Saturday at Paris
Cruiserweight
Valery Brudov TKO11 Luis Pineda
Wins a vacant cruiserweight title.
Records: Brudov, 33-1, 25 KOs; Pineda, 21-5
Rafael's remark: With this fight, we welcome you to the sewer that boxing can be, a place so insane and disgusting that even lifelong junkies are considering quitting the sport cold turkey. This fight, and what it represents, is the singular reason for the abolition of the sanctioning organizations. Brought to you by the utterly heinous machinations of the WBA, it is the very essence of why boxing is such a joke to so many people.

We can live with the WBA wrongly believing that Brudov, of Russia, deserved a championship bout (of sorts) after beating two stiffs following a lopsided decision loss in January in a title bout against Virgil Hill. We can even live with the WBA deeming Pineda, a big hitter from Panama who was wiped out in one round in 2003 by then-titlist Wayne Braithwaite, worthy of a title match. That's all kid's stuff and expected from the sanctioning organizations.

However, in an era where sanctioning organizations make up their rules as they go along, do anything for money and destroy the sport piece by piece, we have a new undisputed champion of horrific moves. This one is the worst of all time, even worse than the WBO ranking a deceased fighter -- super middleweight Darrin Morris, who died in October 2000. (Morris remained ranked and even moved up the rankings in January 2001.) That's saying a lot, too, because the WBA, after all, created a "super champion" policy that led to having two champions in one division. When one of its champions unifies belts, it "elevates" the unified title holder to "super champion" and sanctions a "regular" title fight in an effort to score two sanction fees in the same division. So while it's bad enough that the WBA has crowned two champions in some divisions, this fight marks the first time it has crowned three champions in one division.

Before we puke, try to follow the so-called logic: O'Neil Bell (the only real cruiserweight world champion by virtue of his January knockout of Jean-Marc Mormeck in their undisputed title fight) is the WBA's "super champion." When he beat Mormeck, the organization invoked its "super champion" policy and sanctioned the January Hill-Brudov fight for the "regular" title. Hill won, giving the WBA two cruiserweight champions. But then Hill was granted an exception to his mandatory obligation in order to face rival Henry Maske in Germany in March.

That means neither Bell nor Hill will have fought since January, and heaven forbid the WBA go without a sanction fee in the cruiserweight division for so long. Therefore, in an unprecedented move, the WBA approved Brudov and Pineda to fight for the "interim regular title" (can't believe this phrase is in print). With this move, the WBA shoots ahead of the IBF in the race for worst sanctioning organization. Congrats. Now, someone please pass the barf bag and keep the sharp objects away from us.

Flyweight
Roberto Vasquez W12 Takefumi Sakata
Wins a vacant flyweight title.
Scores: 115-113, 114-113 Vasquez, 114-113 Sakata
Records: Vasquez, 24-1; Sakata, 29-4-1
Rafael's remark: Vasquez, a 23-year-old from Panama, is a former junior flyweight champion who vacated his crown to move up to flyweight to challenge titlist Lorenzo Parra in October. However, when Parra suffered a bad knee injury, the fight was called off and Vasquez was approved to face Sakata, of Japan, for an interim belt. In 2004, Sakata lost a majority decision to Parra in a title bout in Japan. In his second world title fight, Sakata dropped another close fight on a split decision. When Parra is ready to fight again, he will be obligated to face Vasquez.
Junior flyweight
Brahim Asloum TKO4 Rafael Lorenzo
Records: Asloum, 21-1, 8 KOs; Lorenzo, 18-3
Rafael's remark: Asloum, a 2000 Olympic gold medalist for France, won his second in a row since a surprisingly lopsided loss to titlist Lorenzo Parra. Asloum scored four knockdowns against Lorenzo, of Spain, before the fight was halted.
Super middleweight
David Gogiya W12 Jackson Chanet
Retains European super middleweight title.
Scores: 116-112, 116-111, 115-112
Records: Gogiya, 17-1; Chanet, 28-2
Rafael's remark: Gogiya, from the former Soviet Republic of Georgia, pulled off his second consecutive upset. The first one came in October when he won the title on a split decision from Mger Mkrtchian in Mkrtchian's hometown of St. Petersburg, Russia. In his first defense, Gogiya went to Chanet's home country as the underdog and did it again.

Friday at Cicero, Ill.
Junior featherweight
Takalani Ndlovu W12 Ricardo Castillo
Title eliminator.
Scores: 116-112 (twice) Ndlovu, 115-113 Castillo
Records: Ndlovu, 27-3; Castillo, 32-3
Rafael's remark: Ndlovu, a South African fighting in the United States for the third time, edged Castillo -- the younger brother of former two-time lightweight champ Jose Luis Castillo -- on a split decision to become the mandatory challenger for newly crowned title holder Steve Molitor. This was one of the best Telefutura bouts of the year, a meaningful and exciting fight between two hungry contenders. Ndlovu won his sixth straight since a split-decision loss to countryman and former world champion Vuyani Bungu in 2004.

Friday at Santa Ynez, Calif.
Featherweight
Mario Santiago KO7 Salvador Garcia
Records: Santiago, 17-0, 12 KOs; Garcia, 14-4-2
Rafael's remark: Making his third appearance on Showtime's "ShoBox" series, Santiago, of Puerto Rico, notched his sixth consecutive stoppage victory when Garcia's corner threw in the towel at 1:51 of the seventh round. Santiago dominated the entire bout against Garcia, 27, who resumed boxing in 2005 after a three-year layoff. He dropped to 4-1 with a no contest in his comeback. We'd like to see Santiago step up his level of competition at least a little bit -- nothing crazy mind you, but at 28, it's time to see what he can do.
Junior welterweight
Timothy Bradley Tech. Dec. 8 (accidental head butt) Jaime Rangel
Scores: 79-73 (three times)
Records: Bradley, 17-0; Rangel, 30-10-1
Rafael's remark: Bradley, a 23-year-old prospect who recently signed a co-promotional deal with promoter Gary Shaw, received his first national TV exposure on this "ShoBox" card and had a tough time with the experienced veteran Rangel, who lost his sixth consecutive fight. Rangel's losing streak began with a first-round knockout loss in a title fight with Zab Judah in 2003.

Although Bradley won by a large margin on all three scorecards, this fight seemed a lot closer. Even if Bradley was winning most of the rounds, they were competitive. The fight ended prematurely, however, when an accidental head butt opened a cut over Rangel's right eye and referee Raul Caiz stopped the action fight and sent it to the scorecards with Rangel unable to continue.

If Bradley -- whose bid to make the 2004 U.S. Olympic team ended in the U.S. Western Trials in a loss to eventual Olympian Vanes Martirosyan -- is the prospect Shaw brags about him being, then this fight should serve Bradley well as an excellent learning experience.

Thursday at Sacramento, Calif.
Junior lightweight
Vicente Escobedo KO4 Julian Rodriguez
Records: Escobedo, 12-1, 11 KOs; Rodriguez, 17-13-3
Rafael's remark: Escobedo, a 2004 U.S. Olympian, had to get off the mat to rally for the knockout victory, his third in a row since an upset eight-round split-decision loss in April to Daniel Jimenez. Rodriguez, who fell to 1-4-1 in his last six bouts, knocked Escobedo down in the third round, and then Escobedo knocked him down before finishing him in the next frame.

Dan Rafael is the boxing writer for ESPN.com.