SportsNation Blog ArchivesSN Blog Archives Buster Posey

How do the top catchers in Major League Baseball stack up? That question has been answered by our experts in the latest installment of the Baseball Tonight 100 (#BBTN100), a project to rank the top players across all 30 teams. We'll reveal a new position each day and unveil the overall 1-100 rankings March 27.

Do you agree with the experts' take on catchers? Simply click on the images of the top 10 below to submit your ballot.

Rank: #BBTN100 Catchers

Yan Gomes

Yan Gomes

Cleveland Indians
BBTN Rank: 8

Jonathan Lucroy

Jonathan Lucroy

Milwaukee Brewers
BBTN Rank: 9

Russell Martin

Russell Martin

Pittsburgh Pirates
BBTN Rank: 10

Brian McCann

Brian McCann

New York Yankees
BBTN Rank: 3

Yadier Molina

Yadier Molina

St. Louis Cardinals
BBTN Rank: 2

Miguel Montero

Miguel Montero

Arizona Diamondbacks
BBTN Rank: 7

Salvador Perez

Salvador Perez

Kansas City Royals
BBTN Rank: 4

Buster Posey

Buster Posey

San Francisco Giants
BBTN Rank: 1

Carlos Santana

Carlos Santana

Cleveland Indians
BBTN Rank: 6

Matt Wieters

Matt Wieters

Baltimore Orioles
BBTN Rank: 5

Your Rankings

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

Comment »

Miguel Cabrera, Mike TroutChris Buck for ESPNMiguel Cabrera and Mike Trout battled it out for the AL MVP vote in 2012.


Voting for the 2013 ESPYS Awards is open, and today we're debating the best player in baseball from the past year. Miguel Cabrera pulled off the first Triple Crown in quite some time, but some stats have Mike Trout's 2012 season as far above Cabrera's. R.A. Dickey and David Price were nigh unhittable last season, and Buster Posey won NL MVP in the same year he added another World Series trophy to his case. Who gets your vote?

Comment »

2. Would you leave off Posey or Heyward?

We're generally not fans of mindless orthodoxy around here, but sometimes, you can think a little bit too far outside the box. For example: the writers who either voted for Gaby Sanchez as their NL Rookie of the Year, or left Jason Heyward or Buster Posey off entirely. Could you see yourselves doing the same thing, SportsNation? Assuming you had a ballot. Which you don't. Probably.

Comment »

Maybe this is the "Year of the Pitcher" in Major League Baseball, but this week has offered its fair share of evidence pointing to another theme. At least until the Phillies traded for Roy Oswalt, the week's bggest pitching story was Stephen Strasburg's trip to the DL. The big Phillies news prior to the trade might have been Domonic Brown hitting a home run in his first game -- the same night Atlanta's Jason Heyward stole home against the Nationals.

Could this actually be the Year of the Rookie?

John Wall's performance in NBA summer ball receives detailed analysis. Sam Bradford's contract talks with the Rams is the subject of daily updates. Neftali Feliz's progress? Well, he probably has more name recognition in Dallas than Cowboys fifth-round pick DeAngelo Smith. Maybe. Actually, don't quote us on that.

Most of the time, even the best baseball rookies are hardly household names right away. In some cases (Jerome Walton, Marty Cordova and Bobby Crosby spring to mind), they stay that way even after winning Rookie of the Year. But as the news of the week suggests, and Jayson Stark pointed out in a recent chat, this year's class has a chance to be different.

Mike (SF)

Does Posey have a chance at the ROY? Has his power surprised you this early in his career?

Jayson Stark
Jayson Stark

Absolutely. Buster Posey is the real deal. In my midseason awards column, I gave Jaime Garcia the midseason ROY award. But a lot can change in the second half, with Jason Heyward coming back, Stephen Strasburg going out there every five days, Posey raking and one of the great rookie classes of recent times. If I were Jaime, I don't think I'd reserve a spot on my shelf for that trophy just yet. Full July 9 transcript

Comment »